Before You Sue: Exhaust Other Options
Lawsuits should be a last resort, not a first response. Before considering litigation, make sure you've tried these approaches:
- Internal Appeal: Most policies allow you to appeal claim denials. This is usually free and sometimes works.
- Demand Letter: A well-written demand letter citing specific legal violations often prompts reconsideration.
- Regulatory Complaint: File a complaint with your state's Department of Insurance. They can pressure insurers to act fairly.
- Mediation: A neutral mediator may help you reach a settlement without the cost of litigation.
- Appraisal: For property claims where the dispute is about amount (not coverage), appraisal is often faster and cheaper than court.
Even before you decide to sue, document every interaction with your insurer. Keep copies of letters, emails, claim notes, and records of phone calls. This evidence is crucial if you later litigate.
When Litigation Makes Sense
✅ Sue When:
- Claim value is substantial (usually $25,000+)
- Insurer has completely denied coverage
- Clear bad faith conduct (delays, misrepresentations, unreasonable denial)
- Strong evidence supports your position
- Statute of limitations is approaching
- Other resolution methods have failed
- You need punitive damages (unavailable in arbitration)
❌ Don't Sue When:
- Claim is small (litigation costs exceed recovery)
- Coverage genuinely doesn't exist under your policy
- You haven't exhausted simpler options
- Your policy has a mandatory arbitration clause
- The dispute is only about claim amount (use appraisal)
- You can't afford to wait 1-3+ years for resolution
The Math of Insurance Litigation
Before suing, do a realistic cost-benefit analysis. Consider:
- Attorney fees: Contingency (25-40% of recovery) or hourly ($200-500+/hour)
- Litigation costs: Filing fees, depositions, expert witnesses, document production ($5,000-50,000+)
- Time value: Cases typically take 1-3 years; can you wait that long?
- Emotional cost: Litigation is stressful and requires significant personal involvement
- Risk of loss: Even strong cases can lose; are you prepared for that outcome?
California provides several advantages for insurance litigation:
- Brandt Fees: If you prove bad faith, the insurer pays your attorney fees (Brandt v. Superior Court)
- Punitive Damages: Available for conduct with "oppression, fraud, or malice" (Civil Code Section 3294)
- Emotional Distress: Recoverable without physical injury in bad faith cases
- Regulatory Violations: Violations of California's Fair Claims Settlement Practices are evidence of bad faith
Types of Insurance Lawsuits
1. Breach of Contract
The most common claim. You allege the insurer failed to pay benefits owed under the policy. Damages are limited to policy benefits plus interest. Punitive damages are not available for breach of contract alone.
2. Bad Faith (First-Party)
You allege the insurer unreasonably denied, delayed, or underpaid your claim. This is a tort claim that allows recovery beyond policy limits, including emotional distress, consequential damages, and potentially punitive damages.
3. Bad Faith (Third-Party)
When your liability insurer fails to properly defend you or refuses a reasonable settlement, exposing you to a judgment exceeding your policy limits. This can result in the insurer paying the entire judgment.
4. ERISA Claims (Health/Disability)
If your health or disability insurance is through an employer-sponsored plan, you may be limited to ERISA claims in federal court. ERISA severely restricts available damages - usually only the denied benefits, no punitive damages, no emotional distress.
If your health or disability insurance is through your employer, ERISA may preempt state law claims. This dramatically limits your recovery. An attorney can determine whether ERISA applies to your situation.
The Litigation Process
Pre-Suit Preparation
Gather all documents, prepare a demand letter, and attempt pre-suit resolution. Many insurers settle after a strong demand letter from an attorney.
Filing the Complaint
Your attorney files a lawsuit in the appropriate court (state or federal). The insurer has 20-30 days to respond. This formally starts the litigation clock.
Discovery Phase
Both sides exchange documents, take depositions, and gather evidence. This is often the longest phase, lasting 6-18 months. You'll get to see the insurer's claim file and internal communications.
Motion Practice
The insurer will likely file motions to dismiss or for summary judgment, arguing the case should be decided without trial. Defeating these motions is crucial.
Settlement Negotiations
Most cases settle before trial. As trial approaches and the insurer's risk becomes clearer, settlement offers often improve significantly.
Trial
If the case doesn't settle, a judge or jury decides the outcome. Trials typically last 3-10 days for insurance disputes. Only about 2-5% of filed cases go to trial.
Appeal (If Necessary)
Either side can appeal an unfavorable verdict. Appeals can add 1-2 years to the process but are only successful about 10-20% of the time.
Litigation vs. Other Options
| Factor | Litigation | Arbitration | Mediation | DOI Complaint |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Binding? | Yes (subject to appeal) | Yes (very limited appeal) | No - voluntary | No - advisory |
| Timeline | 1-3+ years | 3-12 months | 1 day - 2 months | 2-6 months |
| Cost | High ($10K-100K+) | Moderate ($5K-30K) | Low ($1K-5K) | Free |
| Punitive Damages | Available | Usually not | N/A | N/A |
| Discovery | Full access | Limited | None | None |
| Best For | Large claims, bad faith | Mid-size disputes | Settlement-minded parties | Regulatory violations |
Choosing an Insurance Litigation Attorney
Not all attorneys are created equal. For insurance disputes, look for:
Key Qualifications
- Insurance-specific experience: Insurance law is complex; general litigators may miss important issues
- Plaintiff-side focus: Attorneys who typically represent insurers may have conflicts
- Trial experience: Insurers settle better when they know your attorney will actually try the case
- Resources: Insurance litigation requires expert witnesses and significant costs
- Track record: Ask about verdicts and settlements in similar cases
Fee Arrangements
- Contingency: Attorney gets 25-40% of recovery; you pay nothing if you lose. Best for larger claims.
- Hourly: You pay as you go ($200-500+/hour). Better for smaller, straightforward disputes.
- Hybrid: Reduced hourly rate plus smaller contingency percentage.
Remember: in California bad faith cases, the insurer may be required to pay your attorney fees under Brandt v. Superior Court if you prove bad faith. This makes contingency arrangements more attractive for attorneys and can enhance your recovery.
Statutes of Limitations
You have limited time to file a lawsuit. Missing the deadline bars your claim forever. Common timeframes:
- Breach of Contract: Usually 4-6 years (varies by state)
- Bad Faith: Usually 2-4 years (varies by state)
- ERISA Claims: Often 2 years from denial, but can be shorter if plan documents specify
The statute of limitations deadline is when you must file, not when you should start. Consult an attorney well before the deadline to allow proper case preparation. Waiting until the last minute forces rushed decisions and weaker cases.
Related Guides
Considering Insurance Litigation?
I help policyholders evaluate their options and pursue claims against insurers. Get a professional assessment of your case before making a decision.