What Is Insurance Arbitration?
Arbitration is a private dispute resolution process where a neutral third party (the arbitrator) hears evidence from both sides and makes a binding decision. Unlike court proceedings, arbitration is typically faster, less formal, and conducted behind closed doors.
Insurance policies often include arbitration clauses - contract provisions requiring you to arbitrate disputes instead of going to court. These clauses are generally enforceable under the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), though there are important exceptions.
Key Characteristics of Arbitration
- Binding: The arbitrator's decision is final and enforceable - very limited grounds for appeal
- Private: Proceedings and decisions are not public record
- Limited Discovery: Fewer opportunities to obtain evidence from the insurer
- No Jury: A single arbitrator or panel decides your case, not a jury of peers
- Faster: Typically resolved in months rather than years
California has additional protections for insurance arbitration. Under California Code of Civil Procedure Section 1281.97, if an insurer fails to pay arbitration fees within 30 days, you may have the right to withdraw from arbitration and proceed in court.
Additionally, California Insurance Code Section 11580.2 gives you certain rights in uninsured motorist (UM) arbitrations that cannot be waived.
Types of Insurance Arbitration Clauses
Mandatory Arbitration
These clauses require all disputes to go to arbitration. You give up your right to sue in court entirely. Common in health insurance, auto policies, and some homeowners policies.
Appraisal Clauses (Property Insurance)
Different from arbitration - appraisal only determines the amount of loss, not whether coverage exists. If you and your insurer disagree on how much damage occurred (not whether it's covered), either side can demand appraisal. Each side picks an appraiser, and the two appraisers select an umpire.
Optional Arbitration
Some policies allow either party to demand arbitration, but don't require it. If neither side demands arbitration, disputes proceed through court.
Carve-Out Clauses
Some arbitration clauses exclude certain claims - often bad faith claims or claims for punitive damages. Read your clause carefully to understand what's covered.
Some arbitration clauses limit the damages you can recover, impose short filing deadlines, or require arbitration in inconvenient locations. These provisions may be unconscionable and unenforceable in some states.
Arbitration vs. Litigation: Comparison
| Factor | Arbitration | Litigation (Court) |
|---|---|---|
| Decision Maker | Arbitrator (often industry expert) | Judge or Jury |
| Timeline | Usually 3-9 months | Often 1-3+ years |
| Cost | Lower filing fees, but arbitrator fees can be high | Higher overall, but no arbitrator fees |
| Discovery | Limited - fewer documents, depositions | Extensive - full access to evidence |
| Appeal Rights | Very limited - almost never reversed | Full appellate review available |
| Privacy | Confidential proceedings | Public record |
| Punitive Damages | Often limited or barred | Available for bad faith |
For straightforward claims where the main dispute is the amount owed (not coverage), arbitration can be faster and cheaper. It's often better for smaller claims where litigation costs would eat into your recovery.
Can You Avoid Mandatory Arbitration?
While arbitration clauses are generally enforceable, there are several ways to challenge or avoid them:
1. Unconscionability
Courts may refuse to enforce arbitration clauses that are fundamentally unfair. This typically requires showing both "procedural unconscionability" (unfair bargaining process - like hidden terms or take-it-or-leave-it contracts) and "substantive unconscionability" (unfair terms - like one-sided fee provisions or venue requirements).
2. Waiver by the Insurer
If the insurer takes substantial litigation steps before demanding arbitration - like filing motions, taking depositions, or engaging in extensive discovery - they may have waived their right to compel arbitration.
3. Carve-Outs in the Clause
Some arbitration clauses don't cover all claims. Bad faith claims, claims for injunctive relief, or claims above certain dollar amounts may be excluded.
4. State Law Protections
Some state laws limit or prohibit arbitration in certain insurance contexts. The McCarran-Ferguson Act allows state insurance regulations to override federal law in some circumstances.
California courts are relatively receptive to unconscionability challenges. In particular, California has found arbitration clauses unconscionable when they:
- Impose costs that effectively prevent the claimant from pursuing relief
- Limit discovery in ways that prevent a fair hearing
- Allow the insurer to select the arbitrator or arbitration organization
- Require arbitration in inconvenient or inaccessible locations
Preparing for Insurance Arbitration
Step 1: Understand the Rules
Arbitration is governed by the arbitration clause and the rules of the arbitration organization (often AAA - American Arbitration Association or JAMS). Get copies of both and understand the procedures, deadlines, and fee requirements.
Step 2: Select the Right Arbitrator
Arbitrator selection is critical. Research the arbitrators' backgrounds, prior decisions, and industry affiliations. Former insurance company attorneys may be biased toward insurers.
Step 3: Maximize Limited Discovery
Because discovery is limited, be strategic. Focus on the documents that will prove your case. Request the complete claim file, all communications, and any expert reports relied upon by the insurer.
Step 4: Prepare Your Evidence
Arbitrators weigh documentary evidence heavily. Organize your evidence chronologically, prepare clear exhibits, and have supporting documents for every factual claim you make.
Step 5: Consider Legal Representation
Insurance companies will have experienced counsel. For significant claims, hiring an attorney with arbitration experience can level the playing field and significantly improve your outcome.
Arbitration rules often have strict deadlines for filing claims, selecting arbitrators, and submitting evidence. Missing a deadline can result in waiving important rights or losing your case entirely.
After the Arbitration Decision
Arbitration awards are generally final and binding. Courts will confirm arbitration awards almost automatically. Grounds for vacating (overturning) an award are extremely narrow:
- Corruption or fraud in the arbitration proceedings
- Evident partiality - proven bias of the arbitrator
- Arbitrator misconduct - refusing to hear material evidence or other serious procedural violations
- Exceeded authority - the arbitrator decided issues outside the scope of the arbitration agreement
Simply disagreeing with the arbitrator's interpretation of the evidence or law is not grounds for vacating an award. This is why arbitrator selection and preparation are so critical.
Related Guides
Facing Insurance Arbitration?
I help policyholders navigate arbitration proceedings with demand letters, case strategy, and representation. Don't face the insurance company alone.