❌ DON'T demand they "stop competing" or "not work for competitors"
❌ DON'T cite or attempt to enforce void noncompete clauses
❌ DON'T demand they stop soliciting clients without trade secret доказательства
❌ DON'T threaten new работодатель without proof of misappropriation
⚠️ SB 699 Risk: Attempting to enforce void noncompetes violates Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.5 — exposing you to civil штрафы and counterclaims.
Federal Trade Secret Protection: Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA)
The DTSA (18 U.S.C. § 1836) provides a private federal cause of action for trade secret misappropriation. Key requirements:
Trade secret must be related to a product or service used in interstate or foreign commerce
Allows for ex parte seizure orders in extraordinary circumstances (rare but powerful)
Remedies include injunctive relief, убытки (actual loss or unjust enrichment), and exemplary убытки up to 2× for willful/malicious misappropriation
Адвокатs' fees available for willful/malicious conduct or недобросовестность assertions
California Uniform Trade Secrets Act (CUTSA)
California гражданский кодекс § 3426 et seq. defines and protects trade secrets under state law:
Element
Requirement
Definition of trade secret
Information (technical or business) that: (1) derives independent economic value from not being generally known, and (2) is subject to reasonable efforts to maintain secrecy
Misappropriation
Acquisition by improper means OR disclosure/use in breach of a duty to maintain secrecy
Injunction, убытки (actual loss or unjust enrichment), exemplary убытки (up to 2×), адвокатs' fees for willful/malicious conduct
💡 What Qualifies as a Trade Secret? Customer lists, pricing structures, margin data, supplier relationships, product roadmaps, source code, manufacturing processes, marketing strategies, and proprietary datasets—if they derive value from secrecy and you took reasonable steps to protect them.
Duty of Loyalty While Employed
Even in California (which strongly protects работник mobility post-employment), работникs owe a duty of loyalty while still employed:
Cannot actively divert clients or opportunities to a competing business they're planning to start
Cannot use работодатель's resources (time, equipment, contacts) to build a competing venture
Cannot download or copy конфиденциальный information in anticipation of departure
Cannot recruit colleagues to leave while still employed (California allows post-departure recruitment, but not while on the payroll)
Нарушение of the duty of loyalty can support claims for breach of fiduciary duty, even without a written contract.
Client Poaching in California
California's strong anti-noncompete policy (Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600) means customer non-solicitation agreements are generally unenforceable for regular работникs. Однако, client poaching is still actionable when it involves:
Scenario
Actionable?
Правовая Основа
Using trade secret customer lists or конфиденциальный business info
✅ Да
CUTSA/DTSA misappropriation
Soliciting clients while still employed
✅ Да
Breach of duty of loyalty
Using работодатель's конфиденциальный pricing/margin data to undercut
✅ Да
Trade secret misappropriation
Скачатьing CRM data, proposal templates, client files before leaving
✅ Да
Trade secret theft, нарушение договора
Competing for clients after departure using general knowledge
❌ Нет (generally)
Protected by § 16600—работникs can compete
Non-solicit in sale-of-business context (owner selling equity)
✅ Да (narrow exception)
Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 16601, 16602
⚠️ California-Specific Caution: You cannot enforce a customer non-solicitation agreement against a regular работник under § 16600, even if they signed it. Your требование must focus on trade secret misappropriation and duty of loyalty нарушениеs, not simply "you can't compete for our clients."
Common Fact Patterns
The exodus: Работник downloads entire CRM database, emails it to personal account, resigns, and starts competing business with former clients within weeks
The slow build: Работник spends final 3–6 months using work time to build competing business, recruit colleagues, and line up clients to transition immediately upon departure
The poacher: Former работник contacts clients using конфиденциальный contact info, pricing, and project details they copied before leaving
The team defection: Multiple работникs coordinate departure, taking client lists, templates, source code, and proprietary processes to new competing venture
Step 1: Identify What Was Taken
Document exactly what конфиденциальный information or trade secrets the former работник or подрядчик accessed, copied, or used:
Конфиденциальныйity markings: Documents labeled "Конфиденциальный," "Proprietary," or "Trade Secret"
Need-to-know policies: Restricted access to sensitive data on a business-need basis
Exit procedures: Return-of-property checklists, exit interviews, certification of data deletion
Работник handbook/policies: Written policies prohibiting unauthorized copying or disclosure
If you had no protective measures, courts may find the information wasn't a protectable trade secret. Однако, even minimal measures (NDAs + password protection) can suffice if the information derives real value from secrecy.
🔍 Discovery Red Flags: Unusual data access patterns in final weeks (late-night logins, bulk downloads, forwarding emails to personal accounts, printing hundreds of pages, copying files to USB drives, syncing to personal cloud storage).
Step 3: Document How You Know Misappropriation Occurred
Gather forensic доказательства showing the former работник/подрядчик took or used your trade secrets:
Доказательства Type
What to Collect
System logs
IT audit logs showing file downloads, email forwards, cloud uploads, USB connections, printing activity
Email forensics
Emails to personal accounts, attachments with конфиденциальный files, messages coordinating client transitions
Device imaging
Forensic snapshots of company laptops/phones before return (if you can legally access them)
Third-party reports
Clients reporting contact from former работник using your конфиденциальный info, LinkedIn messages, competitor intelligence
Comparative analysis
Side-by-side comparison of your materials vs. competitor's (e.g., identical proposal language, pricing structures, code snippets)
Свидетель statements
Co-workers who observed suspicious behavior, heard plans to take clients, or saw data being copied
Step 4: Assess Убытки and Leverage
Calculate your actual losses and unjust enrichment to determine the stakes:
Lost revenue: Clients who defected to the former работник's new venture, using your конфиденциальный information
Unjust enrichment: Value the former работник gained by using your trade secrets (e.g., faster time-to-market, lower customer acquisition costs)
Development costs avoided: What it would have cost them to develop the information independently (e.g., years of R&D, customer relationship building)
Competitive advantage lost: Diminished market position, eroded pricing power, loss of first-mover advantage
Leverage factors:
Strength of forensic доказательства (smoking-gun emails, clear download logs)
Egregious conduct (mass data theft, coordinated team departure, lying during exit interview)
Availability of injunctive relief (can you stop ongoing use and prevent further damage?)
Former работник's financial resources and reputational sensitivity
✅ Quick-Strike Advantage: If you act within days or weeks of discovery, вы можете потребовать a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) or preliminary injunction to immediately stop the misuse. Delay weakens ваше дело and signals that the harm isn't "irreparable."
Objectives of the Требование
Your cease-and-desist letter should accomplish multiple goals simultaneously:
Immediate cessation: Stop all use and disclosure of specific categories of конфиденциальный information
Return and destruction: Require return of all misappropriated materials and certification of deletion from all devices
Disclosure of recipients: Identify everyone to whom the information was disclosed (new работодатель, clients, partners)
Preservation of доказательства: Prohibit deletion of emails, wiping devices, or altering cloud data
Customer de-solicitation: Demand they cease contact with specific clients (when supported by trade secret theory, not just noncompete)
Create мировое соглашение leverage: Signal serious intent and exposure to injunctive relief and убытки
Tone: High-Threat vs. Cooperative
Choose your tone strategically based on the relationship and desired outcome:
Approach
When to Use
Language Style
High-threat
Egregious theft, ongoing harm, former работник unresponsive or combative
"We will seek emergency injunctive relief, exemplary убытки, and адвокатs' fees if you do not comply within 48 hours."
Cooperative
Valued former работник, potential for negotiated resolution, relationship preservation desired
"We believe this situation can be resolved amicably. We're prepared to work with you to unwind the use of конфиденциальный information without судебный процесс."
Hybrid
Most common—firm on legal rights but open to мировое соглашение
"While we are prepared to pursue all available legal remedies, we would prefer to resolve this matter promptly and without the cost of судебный процесс."
Essential Elements of the Требование
Identification of trade secrets: Be specific—"client contact information, pricing data, and proposal templates," not just "конфиденциальный information"
Доказательства of misappropriation: Reference specific acts (e.g., "On [date], you downloaded 15,000 customer records to a USB drive")
Contractual and statutory нарушениеs: Cite the NDA, employment agreement, and CUTSA/DTSA
Immediate demands:
Cease all use and disclosure
Return all materials (physical and electronic)
Certify deletion from personal devices and cloud storage
Identify all recipients of the information
Preserve all доказательства (no deletion or destruction)
Deadline: Typically 48 hours to 7 days depending on urgency
Мировое Соглашение opening (optional): "We are willing to discuss a resolution that avoids судебный процесс if you take immediate corrective action."
Образец Текста Требования (Opening)
Dear [Former Работник/Подрядчик]:
I represent [Company Name] in connection with your misappropriation of trade secrets and конфиденциальный business information in нарушение of your Конфиденциальныйity Agreement dated [date], the California Uniform Trade Secrets Act (гражданский кодекс § 3426 et seq.), and the federal Defend Trade Secrets Act (18 U.S.C. § 1836 et seq.).
Our investigation has revealed that, до your resignation on [date], you engaged in a systematic effort to misappropriate [Company]'s proprietary information, including:
Customer contact information, purchasing history, and account details for over [X] clients;
Конфиденциальный pricing structures, margin data, and discount schedules;
Proprietary proposal templates, marketing materials, and business development strategies; and
[Other specific trade secrets].
В частности, our IT audit logs show that on [dates], you:
Скачатьed [X] files containing customer data to a USB drive;
Forwarded [Y] emails containing конфиденциальный pricing information to your personal email account ([email]);
Copied [Z] proprietary documents to your personal Dropbox account; and
Accessed and exported the entire CRM database on [date], three days before your resignation.
You have since used this misappropriated information to solicit [Company]'s clients and compete directly against us in нарушение of your legal obligations.
Specific Требования Section
IMMEDIATE ТРЕБОВАНИЕS:
To avoid immediate legal action, you must comply with the following within 48 hours of receipt of this letter:
Cease and desist from all use, disclosure, or dissemination of [Company]'s trade secrets and конфиденциальный information.
Return all конфиденциальный materials, documents, files, and data in any form (physical, electronic, cloud-based) to [Company] at [address].
Certify in writing that you have:
Deleted all copies of конфиденциальный information from your personal devices (computers, phones, tablets, USB drives, external hard drives);
Deleted all copies from personal cloud storage accounts (Dropbox, Google Drive, iCloud, etc.);
Deleted all emails containing конфиденциальный information from personal email accounts; and
Not disclosed any конфиденциальный information to third parties.
Identify all individuals and entities to whom you disclosed [Company]'s конфиденциальный information, including your new работодатель, clients, business partners, and investors.
Preserve all доказательства related to your access, use, and disclosure of [Company]'s information. Do not delete, alter, or destroy any documents, emails, text messages, or electronic files.
Cease all contact with the following [Company] clients: [list specific clients if appropriate and legally supportable].
Consequences and Closing
LEGAL CONSEQUENCES:
If you fail to comply fully with these demands, [Company] will immediately seek:
A Temporary Restraining Order and preliminary injunction prohibiting your use of trade secrets;
Monetary убытки for actual losses and unjust enrichment;
Exemplary убытки of up to twice the amount of actual убытки under CUTSA and DTSA;
Адвокатs' fees and costs for willful and malicious misappropriation; and
All other relief available under state and federal law.
We expect your full written response and соблюдение by [specific date and time]. Direct all communications to me at [адвокат contact info].
[Optional мировое соглашение language:] While we are prepared to pursue all available remedies, we are willing to discuss a resolution that avoids protracted судебный процесс if you take immediate corrective action and demonstrate добросовестность.
С уважением,
[Адвокат Name] Counsel for [Company Name]
⚠️ California § 16600 Соблюдение: Do NOT demand that the former работник "stop competing" or "not work for competitors." Focus exclusively on trade secret misuse and return of конфиденциальный materials. Demanding they cease competition can violate California law and undermine ваше дело.
Digital Forensic Доказательства
The strongest trade secret cases are built on clear digital доказательства of theft:
Доказательства Type
How to Obtain
What It Proves
IT audit logs
System administrator pulls logs showing file access, downloads, emails, cloud syncs, USB connections
Former работник accessed and copied specific files on specific dates
Email server data
Review emails sent to personal accounts, especially with attachments or large file transfers
Forwarding of конфиденциальный documents to non-company email
Cloud storage logs
Check Dropbox, Google Drive, OneDrive admin consoles for sharing/syncing activity
Syncing company folders to personal cloud accounts
Device imaging
Forensic image of company laptop/phone before return (requires legal right to access)
Network printer logs showing unusual printing activity (hundreds of pages in final week)
Physical removal of конфиденциальный documents
🔐 Preservation Notice: As soon as you suspect misappropriation, send a preservation letter instructing IT to preserve all logs, emails, and system data related to the former работник. Courts can impose sanctions for spoliation if you fail to preserve доказательства once судебный процесс is reasonably anticipated.
Свидетель Доказательства
Interview current работникs who may have knowledge of the former работник's activities:
Co-workers who observed suspicious behavior: Staying late, working on personal devices, downloading files, taking photos of screens
Managers who had exit conversations: What did the работник say about their plans? Did they lie about where they were going?
IT staff: Unusual help desk tickets (password resets, access requests, исковое заявлениеs about locked-out USB drives)
Clients who were contacted: Did they receive calls/emails from the former работник using your конфиденциальный information?
Comparative Analysis: "Smoking Gun" Similarities
Compare your materials to the former работник's new work product to show copying:
What to Compare
Red Flags
Proposal templates
Identical formatting, section headings, boilerplate language, even your company's typos
Same color schemes, imagery, taglines, positioning language
Pricing structures
Identical tier names, suspiciously similar price points, same discount schedules
Client lists
Contacting exact same clients in same order as your CRM database
Create side-by-side exhibits showing the similarities. The more identical the materials, the stronger the inference of copying.
Timeline Доказательства: The "Plan to Steal"
Build a chronological timeline showing premeditation:
3–6 months before departure: Incorporation of new competing business, domain registration, товарный знак filings
Final weeks: Spike in data access and downloads, meetings with clients positioned as "farewell" but actually transition discussions
Final days: Mass email forwarding, CRM exports, printing of конфиденциальный documents
Resignation: Short or no notice, vague about future plans or outright lies about new role
Post-departure: Immediate launch of competing business, client announcements, identical service offerings
This timeline shows the theft was intentional, planned, and willful—supporting claims for exemplary убытки and адвокатs' fees.
✅ Third-Party Discovery: In судебный процесс, you can subpoena the former работник's new работодатель, cloud storage providers, and email hosts to obtain additional доказательства of misappropriation. The threat of this discovery often prompts мировое соглашение.
Emergency Injunctive Relief: TRO and Preliminary Injunction
If ongoing misappropriation is causing irreparable harm, seek immediate суд intervention:
Remedy
Timing
Standard
Temporary Restraining Order (TRO)
Issued within days, sometimes same day (ex parte)
Immediate and irreparable injury; likelihood of success on the merits
Preliminary Injunction
Hearing within 2–3 weeks; can last duration of case
Likelihood of success + balance of hardships + public interest
Permanent Injunction
After trial or summary judgment
Actual success on the merits; ongoing need for relief
What the суд can order:
Immediate cessation of use of trade secrets
Return and destruction of all misappropriated materials
Prohibition on soliciting specific clients (if trade-secret-based, not just noncompete)
Forensic imaging of devices to verify deletion
In extreme cases under DTSA: ex parte seizure of devices and materials
⚠️ DTSA Ex Parte Seizure: 18 U.S.C. § 1836(b)(2) allows for extraordinary ex parte seizure of property to prevent propagation or dissemination of trade secrets. This is rarely granted and requires showing: (1) TRO inadequate, (2) immediate and irreparable injury, (3) person would destroy/move property if notified, (4) narrow seizure scope. Use cautiously—courts disfavor ex parte seizures.
Monetary Убытки Under CUTSA and DTSA
Damage Type
Calculation
Notes
Actual loss
Lost profits, lost business opportunities, diminished value of trade secret
Requires proof of causation (losses directly caused by misappropriation)
Unjust enrichment
Profits ответчик gained from using trade secrets
Alternative to actual loss if ответчик profited but you can't prove your losses
Reasonable royalty
What ответчик would have paid to license the information
Used when actual loss and unjust enrichment are hard to quantify
Exemplary убытки
Up to 2× actual убытки for willful/malicious misappropriation
Requires showing intentional, deliberate theft (easy to prove with download logs, emails)
Адвокатs' fees
Reasonable fees and costs
Available for willful/malicious misappropriation OR недобросовестность требование (cuts both ways)
Мировое Соглашение Dynamics
Most trade secret cases settle before trial. Common мировое соглашение structures:
Standstill agreement: Ответчик agrees to stop using trade secrets; истец agrees not to sue for past conduct; mutual release
Negotiated license: Ответчик pays royalty or lump sum to continue using information under defined constraints
Return and destroy: Ответчик certifies return/destruction of all materials; истец releases past claims
Client carve-out: Ответчик agrees not to solicit specific clients for defined period (if legally supportable)
Monetary payment: Lump sum to cover убытки, адвокат fees, and avoid admission of ответственность
Non-disparagement and конфиденциальныйity: Both sides agree not to discuss the dispute publicly
💡 Negotiation Leverage: Emphasize the cost and disruption of судебный процесс (discovery of devices, depositions, expert свидетель fees). Former работникs often have limited resources and high incentive to settle quickly. Работодательs have staying power but face reputational risk if the case becomes public.
Срок Исковой Давности
Jurisdiction
Требование
Срок Исковой Давности
Federal (DTSA)
Misappropriation
3 года from discovery or when should have discovered (18 U.S.C. § 1836(d))
California (CUTSA)
Misappropriation
3 года from discovery or when should have discovered (Civ. Code § 3426.6)
California
нарушение договора (NDA)
2 года (oral) or 4 года (written)
Continuing нарушение doctrine: If misappropriation is ongoing (e.g., ответчик continues to use stolen client list), the срок исковой давности may not begin to run until the use ceases.
🧮 California Соблюдение Risk Scorer
Before sending your требование, use this tool to assess whether it risks violating California Business & Professions Code § 16600 or SB 699. A high risk score means you should revise your approach.
🔴 Section 1: What Does Your Agreement Contain?
Check all restrictive covenants in your employment agreement, offer letter, or NDA.
🟡 Section 2: What Are You Demanding?
Check what your требование asks the former работник to do.
🟢 Section 3: Доказательства & Protective Language
These factors REDUCE your risk.
California Соблюдение Risk Score
📊 Risk Breakdown
📝 Recommendations
🚨 SB 699 Нарушение Risk
Your требование may violate Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.5 (SB 699), which makes it unlawful to attempt to enforce void noncompete agreements. This could expose you to:
Civil штрафы
Работник counterclaims for unfair competition
Requirement to notify all affected работникs
Адвокат fee awards to the работник
✅ California-Compliant Требование Checklist
⚠️ Отказ от ответственности: This tool provides general guidance only and does not constitute legal advice. California employment law is complex and fact-specific. Consult a California employment адвокат before sending any требование to a former работник.
How I Can Help
I represent companies in trade secret misappropriation, unfair competition, and breach of fiduciary duty cases involving former работникs and подрядчикs. I handle matters from требованиеs through emergency TROs and full судебный процесс under CUTSA and DTSA.
Услуги Offered
Forensic investigation coordination: Work with IT and forensic experts to document data theft and preserve доказательства
Cease-and-desist требованиеs: Aggressive, legally sound letters demanding immediate cessation, return of materials, and preservation of доказательства
Emergency injunctive relief: File for TROs and preliminary injunctions to stop ongoing misappropriation
Trade secret судебный процесс: Prosecute claims under CUTSA and DTSA for убытки, exemplary убытки, and адвокатs' fees
Мировое Соглашение negotiation: Secure favorable standstills, licenses, or monetary мировое соглашениеs without protracted судебный процесс
California § 16600 соблюдение: Ensure требованиеs and судебный процесс strategy comply with California's anti-noncompete laws
My Approach
Rapid response: Time is critical in trade secret cases. I move quickly to stop ongoing harm and preserve доказательства before it's destroyed.
Forensic-driven strategy: I work with IT and forensic experts to build airtight доказательства of theft—download logs, email trails, side-by-side comparisons.
Aggressive требованиеs: My cease-and-desist letters are detailed, доказательства-based, and designed to create immediate мировое соглашение pressure while preserving your right to emergency relief.
California law expertise: I navigate the tension between protecting your trade secrets and complying with California's strict anti-noncompete laws (§ 16600, SB 699).
Emergency судебный процесс readiness: If the former работник doesn't comply, I'm prepared to file for a TRO within 24–48 hours, with declarations, exhibits, and proposed orders ready to go.
🔒 Former Работник Stole Your Trade Secrets?
Контакт me immediately for a consultation. I'll assess your доказательства, draft a cease-and-desist letter, and if necessary, seek emergency суд intervention to stop the bleeding.
Нет—not simply because they're competing. California Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600 voids noncompete agreements. Однако, you can stop them from using your trade secrets, soliciting clients using конфиденциальный information, or competing using misappropriated data. Focus on what they're using, not where they're working.
You can still pursue trade secret misappropriation under CUTSA and DTSA even without a written NDA. The statutes protect trade secrets based on the information's secrecy and your protective measures (access controls, passwords, etc.), not just contractual obligations. Однако, an NDA strengthens ваше дело significantly.
System logs (file downloads, emails to personal accounts, USB connections), forensic imaging of devices, side-by-side comparison of your materials vs. theirs, свидетель statements, and client reports of being contacted with your конфиденциальный information. Work with IT to pull audit logs immediately—they may be overwritten or deleted if you wait.
Да. вы можете потребовать a TRO or preliminary injunction requiring return and destruction of misappropriated materials, certification of deletion from all devices, and in some cases forensic imaging to verify соблюдение. In extraordinary circumstances under DTSA, courts can even order ex parte seizure of devices.
Actual losses (lost profits, diminished trade secret value), unjust enrichment (profits ответчик made), and up to 2× actual убытки for willful/malicious misappropriation. You can also recover адвокатs' fees if the misappropriation was willful or malicious. Both CUTSA and DTSA provide these remedies.
3 года from when you discovered (or reasonably should have discovered) the misappropriation under both CUTSA and DTSA. Однако, if the use is ongoing (continuing нарушение), the clock may not start until the use stops. Don't wait—early action is critical for emergency relief and доказательства preservation.
📝 Создайте Ваше Требование
Generate a professional требование, CA суд исковое заявление, or арбитраж demand