Претензия по франшизному спору: Досудебная претензия в США

🇷🇺 🇺🇸

Претензия по франшизному спору

Франчайзор не выполняет обязательства по поддержке, training, или нарушает территориальные права? Пошаговый гид по подготовке досудебной претензии (demand letter) за нарушение franchise agreement в США.

FTC Franchise Rule

10-14 Дней на ответ

State Laws Дополнительная защита

Записаться на консультацию Шаблоны претензий FAQ

Когда подавать претензию по франшизному спору

Типичные ситуации

Франчайзор не предоставляет обещанный training, marketing support, или operational assistance. Другой franchisee открыт на вашей protected territory в нарушение соглашения. Франчайзор увеличивает royalty fees, advertising contributions без вашего согласия. Качество продукции или approved suppliers не соответствует стандартам, что вредит вашему бизнесу. Франчайзор угрожает termination без cause или good faith basis.

Что такое franchise relationship в США

Franchise - это contractual relationship где franchisor предоставляет franchisee право использовать brand, business model, и operational system в обмен на fees и compliance с standards.

FTC Franchise Rule (16 CFR Part 436)
Franchisor обязан предоставить Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) минимум за 14 дней до signing. FDD включает Item 19 (financial performance), Item 5 (initial fees), Item 6 (recurring fees), Item 12 (territory), Item 11 (franchisor obligations). Нарушение FTC Rule - основание для rescission и damages.
State franchise laws (relationship laws)
15+ штатов имеют franchise relationship laws защищающие franchisee от unfair termination, encroachment, non-renewal. Например: California Franchise Relations Act, Illinois Franchise Disclosure Act, Wisconsin Fair Dealership Law. Дают дополнительные remedies beyond FTC Rule.
Франчайзор obligations (типичные)
Training (initial и ongoing), marketing support (national + co-op advertising), operational assistance, quality control, territory protection, supply chain management. Все это должно быть specified в FDD и FA.
Franchisee obligations
Royalty fees (обычно % от gross sales), advertising fees, compliance с brand standards, participation в required programs, reporting requirements. Breach by franchisee может дать franchisor право на termination.

Когда отправлять demand letter

Условие Что проверить Действующая Franchise Agreement Проверьте term, renewal status, termination provisions. Убедитесь что agreement не expired. Franchisor breach Конкретное нарушение: не provided training, opened competing location на вашей territory, не выплатил rebates, etc. Ваш compliance Вы платили royalties вовремя, соблюдали standards, reported sales. Franchisor может заявить counterclaim если вы в breach. Damages или harm Quantifiable harm: потеря revenue от encroachment, costs от inadequate support, harm to reputation. Notice requirements в FA Многие FA требуют written notice + cure period перед litigation. Проверьте dispute resolution clause (mediation, arbitration).

Encroachment - территориальное нарушение

Encroachment - когда franchisor или другой franchisee открывает location на вашей protected territory. Это одно из самых частых нарушений. Многие FA включают "territory" clause (exclusive или non-exclusive). Если ваша territory exclusive, и franchisor открыл competing unit - это material breach. Даже если territory non-exclusive, franchisor может иметь implied duty не encroach unreasonably.

Нужна помощь с претензией по franchise dispute?

Я готовлю demand letters для споров франчайзи с учетом FTC Rule, state franchise laws, и FA terms. Работаю на русском и английском. Фиксированная цена.

Записаться на Zoom owner@terms.law

Правовые основания для претензии

FTC Franchise Rule (16 CFR Part 436)

FTC Rule регулирует pre-sale disclosure, но не дает private right of action для franchisee. Однако нарушения FDD могут быть использованы как evidence в breach of contract или fraud claims.

Misrepresentation в FDD (Item 19)
Если franchisor представил false или misleading financial performance data в FDD Item 19, franchisee может иметь fraud claim. Требуется: (1) material misrepresentation, (2) reliance, (3) damages. Fraud claims дают punitive damages в некоторых states.
Failure to disclose material facts
Franchisor обязан disclose: litigation history (Item 3), bankruptcy (Item 4), initial investment (Item 7), restrictions (Item 9). Если franchisor omitted material facts, franchisee может rescind agreement и требовать refund.
Breach of franchisor obligations (Item 11)
FDD Item 11 перечисляет franchisor's obligations: training, site selection, operational assistance. Если franchisor не выполнил promised obligations, это breach of contract основанный на FDD representations.

State franchise relationship laws

Некоторые штаты имеют специальные statutes защищающие franchisee от unfair practices.

Штат Statute Ключевые protections California Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 20000 Good cause requirement для termination/non-renewal. Anti-encroachment protection. Illinois 815 ILCS 705/19 Good cause для termination. Reasonable notice (90+ days). Compensation за inventory on termination. Wisconsin Wis. Stat. § 135.03 Fair Dealership Law - good cause для termination, 90 days notice, buyback requirements. New Jersey N.J.S.A. 56:10-1 Franchise Practices Act - good cause, 60 days notice, prohibition on unreasonable standards.

"Good cause" для termination

В штатах с relationship laws franchisor не может terminate без "good cause". Good cause обычно означает: material breach by franchisee (non-payment, violation of standards), criminal conduct, loss of required license, abandonment. Если franchisor terminates без good cause, franchisee может требовать damages, injunction, buyback of inventory. Это мощная защита.

Breach of contract (Franchise Agreement)

Основной claim - breach of Franchise Agreement. Типичные breaches со стороны franchisor:

Failure to provide support
FA обещает training, marketing, operational assistance. Если franchisor не provided - breach. Damages: cost to obtain alternative support, lost profits due to inadequate assistance.
Encroachment (territory violation)
FA grants exclusive или protected territory. Franchisor открыл competing location или authorized другого franchisee в вашей territory - breach. Damages: lost sales, diminished brand value.
Unilateral fee increases
Franchisor увеличил royalty, advertising fees без authority под FA. Если FA не дает право на unilateral modification - breach. Franchisee может refuse to pay increased fees.
Failure to maintain brand standards
Franchisor не enforces quality standards на других franchisees, что harms brand reputation. Это breach of implied duty to protect brand integrity.

Implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing

Все contracts в США включают implied covenant of good faith. Franchisor не может:

Действовать in bad faith чтобы deprive franchisee of contract benefits
Например: terminate franchisee перед renewal чтобы открыть company-owned unit на его location. Это breach of implied covenant даже если termination technically allowed под FA.
Unreasonably withhold consent
Если FA требует franchisor approval для site relocation, transfer, remodeling - franchisor не может unreasonably withhold consent. Standard: commercially reasonable grounds.

Консультация по franchise law

Разберу ваш FA, FDD, определю applicable state law, оценю damages, подготовлю претензию.

Записаться на Zoom owner@terms.law

Шаблоны претензий по franchise disputes

Структура demand letter

Стандартная претензия: (1) Executive summary, (2) Franchise relationship - когда signed FA, FDD disclosures, (3) Franchisor obligations - что было обещано в FA/FDD, (4) Breach - конкретные нарушения с dates/evidence, (5) Your compliance - вы платили fees, соблюдали standards, (6) Damages - quantified harm, (7) Legal basis - breach of contract + state franchise law, (8) Cure demand - remedy + deadline, (9) Consequences - litigation, state law remedies, injunction.

Сниппеты для demand letter (EN)

Opening - Franchise Breach

I represent [YOUR NAME/ENTITY] ("Franchisee"), operator of a [BRAND NAME] franchise located at [ADDRESS], in connection with [FRANCHISOR NAME]'s ("Franchisor") material breach of the Franchise Agreement dated [DATE] (the "FA," attached as Exhibit A) and related Franchise Disclosure Document (the "FDD," attached as Exhibit B). Franchisee has fulfilled all obligations under the FA, including timely payment of royalties and advertising fees, compliance with brand standards, and participation in required programs. Despite Franchisee's performance, Franchisor has breached multiple obligations, causing substantial financial harm. This letter constitutes formal demand that Franchisor immediately cure the breaches described below and compensate Franchisee for damages incurred.

Замените [YOUR NAME], [BRAND], [FRANCHISOR NAME], [DATE]

Breach - Failure to Provide Support

Under the FA (§ [X]) and FDD (Item 11), Franchisor committed to provide: (a) Initial training for Franchisee and staff (minimum [X] hours at Franchisor headquarters); (b) Ongoing operational support, including quarterly on-site visits by Franchisor's field consultant; (c) National and regional marketing campaigns, funded by Franchisee's advertising contributions ([X]% of gross sales); (d) Access to approved suppliers and negotiated pricing. Franchisor has materially breached these obligations: • Initial training was limited to [Y] hours (not [X] as promised), and critical operational topics were omitted; • Since [DATE], Franchisor has conducted zero on-site visits despite Franchisee's repeated requests for assistance; • Advertising fund contributions have not been used for promised campaigns—no regional advertising has occurred in [TIME PERIOD]; • Franchisor failed to maintain relationships with approved suppliers, forcing Franchisee to source at higher costs. As a result, Franchisee has incurred $[AMOUNT] in additional training costs, $[AMOUNT] in lost sales due to operational deficiencies, and $[AMOUNT] in excess supplier costs.

Будьте максимально specific: dates, amounts, missed obligations

Breach - Encroachment (Territory Violation)

Under FA § [X], Franchisor granted Franchisee an exclusive territory defined as [TERRITORY DESCRIPTION - e.g., "a 5-mile radius from the Franchised Location at [ADDRESS]"]. Franchisor expressly agreed not to operate, or authorize any other franchisee to operate, a [BRAND] location within this territory during the term of the FA. In breach of this provision, on [DATE], Franchisor authorized a new [BRAND] franchise located at [COMPETING ADDRESS], which is [DISTANCE] from Franchisee's location, within Franchisee's exclusive territory. Evidence of encroachment: • Attached as Exhibit C is the new franchise's grand opening announcement; • Attached as Exhibit D are GPS coordinates confirming the competing location is within the protected territory; • Franchisee's sales have declined [X]% since the competing location opened, from $[PRE-ENCROACHMENT] per month to $[POST-ENCROACHMENT] per month. This encroachment constitutes material breach of the FA and violates [STATE] franchise law [CITATION], which prohibits franchisor encroachment on protected territories.

Encroachment - очень сильный claim. Приложите map, sales data

Breach - Unilateral Fee Increase

Under FA § [X], Franchisee agreed to pay: • Royalty fee: [X]% of gross sales • Advertising contribution: [Y]% of gross sales The FA contains no provision authorizing Franchisor to unilaterally modify these fees. On [DATE], Franchisor notified Franchisee (via email attached as Exhibit E) that effective [DATE], royalty fees would increase to [Z]%, and advertising contributions would increase to [W]%. Franchisor provided no contractual basis for this increase and did not seek Franchisee's consent. This unilateral modification constitutes breach of contract and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. Franchisee has continued paying the original rates ([X]% and [Y]%) and reserves the right to offset any claimed underpayment against damages owed by Franchisor.

Если FA позволяет modifications with notice - проверьте точные terms

Compliance & Performance by Franchisee

Franchisee has fully complied with all obligations under the FA, including: • Timely payment of all royalty fees and advertising contributions (payment records attached as Exhibit F); • Adherence to brand standards, operational procedures, and quality control requirements; • Participation in all required training programs and system updates; • Submission of monthly sales reports and financial statements as required; • Maintenance of required insurance coverage and business licenses. Attached as Exhibit G is a compliance audit conducted by Franchisor on [DATE], confirming Franchisee's full compliance with system standards (audit report rated Franchisee [SCORE/GRADE]). Franchisor cannot claim any material breach or default by Franchisee that would justify non-performance of Franchisor's obligations.

Доказать ваш compliance критично - prevents counterclaim defense

Demand for Cure & Compensation

Accordingly, Franchisee demands that Franchisor, no later than [DATE] at 5:00 p.m. [TIME ZONE]: (a) Immediately cure all breaches described above: • Provide the promised training, operational support, and marketing services; • Cease operations at the encroaching location [ADDRESS] or provide Franchisee with compensation for lost sales; • Rescind the unilateral fee increases and confirm royalty/advertising rates per the FA; (b) Compensate Franchisee for damages incurred: • Lost profits due to inadequate support: $[AMOUNT] • Lost sales due to encroachment: $[AMOUNT] • Excess costs (training, suppliers): $[AMOUNT] • **TOTAL DAMAGES: $[TOTAL]** (c) Provide written confirmation (under penalty of perjury) that Franchisor will comply with all FA obligations going forward and will not engage in further encroachment or unilateral modifications. Payment shall be made by wire transfer or certified check to [YOUR ACCOUNT/ADDRESS].

10-14 дней стандартный срок для franchise disputes

Consequences - State Franchise Law Remedies

If Franchisor fails to cure these breaches and compensate Franchisee, Franchisee will pursue all available legal remedies, including: • Filing a breach of contract lawsuit in [JURISDICTION] seeking damages, specific performance, and declaratory relief; • Asserting claims under [STATE] Franchise Act [CITATION], which provides franchisees with protection against encroachment, wrongful termination, and unfair practices; • Seeking a preliminary injunction prohibiting Franchisor from operating or authorizing competing locations within Franchisee's protected territory; • Pursuing claims for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, fraudulent misrepresentation (based on FDD Item 11 and Item 19 representations), and violation of state consumer protection laws; • Reporting Franchisor's conduct to the Federal Trade Commission and state regulatory authorities for potential violations of franchise disclosure laws; • Recovering attorney's fees and costs as provided under [STATE STATUTE § X] and/or FA § [Y]; • Seeking rescission of the FA and full refund of all fees paid, plus consequential damages, if Franchisor's breaches constitute material failure of consideration. Franchisee also reserves the right to withhold future royalty and advertising payments pending resolution of this dispute, as Franchisor's material breaches constitute grounds for suspension of Franchisee's payment obligations.

Укажите specific state franchise law если applicable (CA, IL, WI, etc.)

Нужна адаптация шаблона под вашу ситуацию?

Я персонализирую demand letter с учетом вашего FA, FDD, evidence, state law.

Записаться на Zoom owner@terms.law

Частые вопросы (FAQ)

Это типичная retaliation tactic. В штатах с franchise relationship laws (CA, IL, WI, NJ) franchisor не может terminate без "good cause". Если franchisor terminates в retaliation за вашу legitimate complaint, это может быть wrongful termination + breach of implied covenant of good faith. Документируйте всё: ваша complaint, franchisor's termination notice, timeline. Вы можете seek preliminary injunction чтобы prevent termination pending resolution dispute. Anti-retaliation provisions усиливают вашу позицию.

Проверьте FA § Territory и FDD Item 12. Если territory designated as "exclusive", encroachment - это clear breach. Если "non-exclusive" или territory undefined, сложнее но не impossible. Можете argue: (1) implied exclusivity based on FDD representations, industry custom, или course of dealing, (2) breach of implied covenant of good faith если franchisor encroached unreasonably (например, opened location 1 mile от вас когда market не supports two units), (3) некоторые state laws (CA) дают protection даже при non-exclusive territory если encroachment unreasonable.

Рискованно но иногда justified. Общий contract law principle: если одна сторона в material breach, другая сторона может suspend performance. Но franchisor почти всегда заявит что non-payment - это material breach дающий право на immediate termination. Safer approach: continue paying, но send notice что вы reserve right to offset damages против future payments. Или escrow royalties pending resolution. В demand letter можете state: "Franchisee reserves right to suspend payments under doctrine of substantial breach, but continues paying under protest." Consult counsel перед withholding.

Возможно, под fraud или misrepresentation claim. Нужно доказать: (1) franchisor made false statements в Item 19 (financial performance representations), (2) statements были material (вы relied на них), (3) franchisor knew или should have known что false, (4) вы suffered damages. Remedy: rescission (возврат initial franchise fee, investment) + consequential damages. FTC Rule не дает private right of action, но state fraud/consumer protection laws дают. Statute of limitations обычно 2-4 года от discovery. Rescission - это nuclear option, лучше negotiate settlement first.

Обычно да. Большинство FA включают arbitration clause (AAA, JAMS). Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) делает arbitration agreements enforceable. Exceptions: (1) некоторые state franchise laws invalidate arbitration clauses (California иногда), (2) если clause unconscionable (extreme one-sided terms), (3) если dispute касается injunctive relief (некоторые courts позволяют seek injunction в court даже при arbitration clause). Arbitration может быть faster и cheaper чем litigation, но вы теряете jury trial и appeal rights. Review clause carefully - может быть grounds to challenge enforceability.

Зависит от FA arbitration clause. Многие современные FA включают class action waiver: вы agree не participate в class или collective actions. Supreme Court (AT&T Mobility v Concepcion, 2011) upheld такие waivers под FAA. Но некоторые exceptions: (1) state law может invalidate waiver (California иногда, если unconscionable), (2) NLRB позиция (хотя меняется) что class waivers нарушают labor rights, (3) если waiver не enforceable, вы можете join class. Если много franchisees имеют similar claims (например, systemwide encroachment, fraudulent FDD), class action - мощный leverage. Consult class action counsel.

Franchisor bankruptcy - сложная ситуация. Вы становитесь unsecured creditor за damages owed. Priority: secured creditors, bankruptcy costs, employees, taxes, потом unsecured. Ваш claim может дать pennies on dollar. Но: (1) вы можете продолжить operate franchise если FA не rejected в bankruptcy, (2) можете buy brand assets из bankruptcy estate если franchisor liquidates, (3) некоторые franchisees form cooperative чтобы acquire brand collectively. Immediate action: file proof of claim в bankruptcy court, monitor proceedings, retain bankruptcy counsel. Franchise relationship laws могут дать priority в некоторых states.

Остались вопросы по franchise disputes?

Разберу вашу ситуацию на консультации, объясню стратегию и риски.

Записаться на Zoom owner@terms.law

Контакты и услуги

Я помогаю franchisees защищать свои права в спорах с franchisor в США. Услуги:

Консультация (30 мин Zoom)
Разбор вашего FA, FDD, оценка breach evidence, стратегия demand letter vs arbitration/litigation. Объясняю FTC Rule, state franchise laws, encroachment claims.
Подготовка demand letter
Полный текст на английском с detailed breach analysis, damages calculation, legal citations. Включает cure demand, consequences, notice compliance. Фиксированная цена.
FA/FDD review
Проверка вашего Franchise Agreement и FDD на enforceability, franchisor obligations, dispute resolution. Рекомендации по strengthening вашей позиции.
Coordination с US franchise counsel
Если нужен arbitration, litigation, injunction - помогу найти и координировать с franchise attorney experienced в вашей jurisdiction и franchise system.

Почему обращаются ко мне

Работаю на русском и английском. Знаю специфику franchise disputes Russia/CIS → USA. Объясняю FTC Franchise Rule, state relationship laws, arbitration простым языком. Фокус на practical outcomes: protecting your franchise investment. Фиксированная цена на demand letter.

Услуга Описание Формат Консультация Разбор ситуации, стратегия, Q&A 30 мин Zoom Demand Letter Полный текст на EN с breach analysis 4-6 страниц + exhibits FA/FDD Review Enforceability + obligations analysis Written memo Litigation Coordination Referral к franchise counsel, координация Ongoing

Готовы действовать?

Запишитесь на консультацию или напишите напрямую.

Записаться на Zoom owner@terms.law

Записаться на консультацию

Выберите удобное время для Zoom-звонка