👶 Types of Birth Injuries

Birth injuries occur when medical negligence during pregnancy, labor, or delivery causes harm to the mother or child. These injuries often result in lifelong disabilities requiring extensive medical care, therapy, and support services. California law provides recourse for families affected by preventable birth injuries.

Common Birth Injuries from Medical Negligence

🧠 Cerebral Palsy

Brain damage from oxygen deprivation (hypoxia/asphyxia) during labor, often caused by failure to monitor fetal distress or delayed C-section. Results in motor function impairment, muscle spasticity, and developmental delays.

💪 Erb's Palsy / Brachial Plexus

Nerve damage to the shoulder and arm caused by excessive force during delivery, improper handling of shoulder dystocia, or misuse of forceps/vacuum. May cause permanent arm weakness or paralysis.

🧠 Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE)

Brain injury from lack of oxygen and blood flow. Caused by umbilical cord problems, placental abruption, uterine rupture, or prolonged labor without intervention. Can result in severe cognitive and physical disabilities.

💀 Skull Fractures / Intracranial Hemorrhage

Head trauma from improper use of vacuum extractors, forceps, or excessive pressure during delivery. May cause bleeding in the brain, seizures, and long-term neurological damage.

Additional Birth Injury Types

  • Facial Nerve Palsy - Nerve damage causing facial paralysis, often from forceps pressure
  • Clavicle Fractures - Broken collarbone from difficult delivery or shoulder dystocia
  • Spinal Cord Injuries - Rare but devastating injuries from excessive twisting or pulling
  • Caput Succedaneum / Cephalohematoma - Scalp swelling or bleeding, usually from vacuum extraction
  • Meconium Aspiration Syndrome - Lung damage from inhaling fecal matter due to delayed delivery
  • Kernicterus - Brain damage from untreated severe jaundice (bilirubin toxicity)

Maternal Birth Injuries

Mothers can also suffer injuries from obstetric negligence:

  • Uterine Rupture - Tear in the uterus, often during VBAC (vaginal birth after cesarean)
  • Hemorrhage - Excessive bleeding from placental problems or surgical errors
  • Infection - Post-operative or post-delivery infections from improper sterile technique
  • Nerve Damage - From improper epidural placement or surgical injury
  • Wrongful Death - Maternal mortality from uncontrolled complications

⚠ California Birth Injury Claims: MICRA Applies

Birth injury claims in California are subject to the Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA). This means:

  • Non-economic damages (pain and suffering) are capped at $350,000+ (2024)
  • 90-day pre-suit notice required before filing lawsuit
  • Special statute of limitations rules for minor children
  • Expert witness testimony required to prove standard of care

👍 Birth Injury Claims Often Have High Economic Damages

While MICRA caps non-economic damages, there is NO CAP on economic damages. Birth injury cases often involve:

  • Lifetime medical care - Often $5-15 million+ for severe injuries
  • Therapy costs - Physical, occupational, speech therapy for decades
  • Special education - Costs of specialized schooling and tutoring
  • Home modifications - Wheelchair ramps, accessible bathrooms, lifts
  • Lost earning capacity - Child's future wages they'll never earn
  • 24/7 care needs - Home health aides, nursing care

🔬 Evidence Checklist for Birth Injury Claims

Gathering comprehensive evidence is critical for birth injury cases. Medical records must be preserved immediately, and expert review is essential to establish both breach and causation.

Essential Medical Records

📄 Prenatal Records

  • ✓ Complete prenatal visit notes from OB/GYN
  • ✓ Ultrasound images and reports
  • ✓ Lab results (glucose tolerance, blood type, infections)
  • ✓ Non-stress tests (NST) and biophysical profiles
  • ✓ Risk assessments and birth plan discussions

📈 Fetal Monitoring Strips

  • ✓ Complete electronic fetal monitoring (EFM) tracings
  • ✓ Contraction patterns and timing
  • ✓ Any internal monitoring data (scalp electrode)
  • ✓ Annotations and interpretations by staff

📋 Labor & Delivery Records

  • ✓ Admission notes and initial assessment
  • ✓ Labor progress notes (cervical dilation, station)
  • ✓ Medication administration records (Pitocin dosing)
  • ✓ Delivery summary and delivery method
  • ✓ Time stamps for all interventions

👶 Newborn Records

  • ✓ APGAR scores (1 minute, 5 minute, 10 minute)
  • ✓ Resuscitation records if applicable
  • ✓ Cord blood gas results (pH, base deficit)
  • ✓ NICU admission records and diagnoses
  • ✓ Brain imaging (MRI, CT, ultrasound)

Expert Opinions Required

California requires expert testimony to establish standard of care and causation in medical malpractice cases. For birth injury claims, you typically need:

👩‍⚕️ OB/GYN Expert

Board-certified obstetrician to testify about standard of care during pregnancy, labor, and delivery. Must establish what should have been done differently.

🧠 Pediatric Neurologist

Specialist to interpret brain imaging, diagnose the injury (cerebral palsy, HIE), and connect it to events during delivery through causation analysis.

📈 Fetal Monitoring Expert

Expert trained in interpreting electronic fetal monitoring strips to identify when distress began and whether it was properly recognized and acted upon.

💰 Life Care Planner

Expert to project lifetime costs of care including medical treatment, therapy, equipment, home modifications, and attendant care needs.

Additional Evidence to Preserve

  • Hospital policies and protocols - Standards for fetal monitoring, emergency C-sections, shoulder dystocia management
  • Staff credentials and training records - Certifications, continuing education
  • Incident reports - Internal hospital documentation of adverse events
  • Peer review materials - May be discoverable in some circumstances
  • Equipment maintenance logs - For monitoring equipment, surgical instruments
  • Photographs/videos - If any were taken during delivery

⚠ Evidence Preservation is Critical

Send a written preservation letter to the hospital and all providers immediately. Medical records can be altered, and fetal monitoring strips are sometimes "lost." Request copies of ALL records within 30 days of recognizing an injury.

💰 Damages in Birth Injury Cases

Birth injury cases often involve catastrophic, permanent injuries requiring lifetime care. While MICRA caps non-economic damages, economic damages for medical care, therapy, and lost earning capacity have NO CAP and can be substantial.

Types of Recoverable Damages

Damage Category Examples MICRA Cap?
Past Medical Expenses NICU stay, surgeries, hospitalizations, medications, therapy to date NO CAP
Future Medical Care Lifetime medical treatment, surgeries, medications, equipment NO CAP
Therapy Costs Physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, behavioral therapy NO CAP
Home Care/Attendants 24/7 nursing care, home health aides, respite care NO CAP
Lost Earning Capacity Child's future wages they will never be able to earn due to disability NO CAP
Special Education Private schooling, tutoring, educational aids and technology NO CAP
Home Modifications Wheelchair ramps, accessible bathrooms, lifts, vehicle modifications NO CAP
Pain and Suffering Child's physical pain, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life CAPPED ($357K in 2024)

📊 Sample Lifetime Damages Calculation

Example: Severe Cerebral Palsy Case (2024 - 70 Year Life Expectancy)

Past medical expenses (NICU, surgeries, therapy) $1,850,000
Future medical care (life care plan - 70 years) $8,500,000
24/7 attendant care ($25/hr x 24 hrs x 365 days x 70 yrs) $15,330,000
Physical/occupational/speech therapy (lifetime) $2,100,000
Special education and tutoring $450,000
Home modifications and accessible vehicle $350,000
Lost earning capacity (present value) $1,800,000
Total Economic Damages (No Cap) $30,380,000
Pain and suffering (actual value) $10,000,000+
Non-Economic Damages (CAPPED at 2024 limit) $357,000
TOTAL RECOVERABLE DAMAGES $30,737,000

Life Care Planning

A certified life care planner will prepare a comprehensive projection of your child's lifetime needs. This document is essential for calculating future damages and typically includes:

  • Projected medical appointments and procedures by year
  • Medication costs with inflation adjustments
  • Therapy schedules and costs (PT, OT, speech, behavioral)
  • Durable medical equipment (wheelchairs, walkers, orthotics) with replacement schedules
  • Home health aide hours and costs
  • Respite care for family caregivers
  • Home modifications and maintenance
  • Transportation needs (accessible vehicle, modifications)
  • Vocational assessment and supported employment if applicable

💡 Present Value Calculations

Future damages must be reduced to "present value" - the lump sum that, if invested, would generate enough to pay future costs. This involves complex economic calculations using discount rates and inflation projections. An economist expert typically performs these calculations.

Parents' Claims

In addition to the child's claims, parents may have their own causes of action:

  • Loss of consortium - Loss of the parent-child relationship they expected
  • Emotional distress - Witnessing the birth injury (if present) and ongoing caregiving stress
  • Mother's personal injuries - If the mother was also injured during delivery
  • Past caregiving costs - Value of care provided by parents before professional care obtained

📝 Sample Demand Letter Language

Use these paragraphs to draft your birth injury demand letter or 90-day notice. Customize the highlighted portions for your specific situation.

90-Day Notice Opening (CCP 364)
NOTICE PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE SECTION 364

Dear [HEALTHCARE PROVIDER/HOSPITAL NAME]:

Please take notice that pursuant to California Code of Civil Procedure Section 364, [CHILD'S NAME], a minor, by and through [his/her] parents and guardians ad litem, [PARENT NAMES], intends to commence legal action against you for professional negligence (medical malpractice) arising from obstetric care and delivery. This notice is being provided at least 90 days before the filing of said action as required by law.
Legal Basis - Birth Injury
The legal basis for this claim is professional negligence (medical malpractice) under California law. Specifically, [CHILD'S NAME] alleges that you breached the standard of care applicable to obstetric healthcare providers when you failed to [properly monitor fetal heart rate patterns / timely perform emergency cesarean section / appropriately manage shoulder dystocia / recognize and respond to fetal distress / OTHER SPECIFIC BREACH] during labor and delivery. This claim is governed by California's Medical Injury Compensation Reform Act (MICRA), including Civil Code Section 3333.2, Code of Civil Procedure Sections 340.5 and 364, and related statutes.
Factual Background - Labor and Delivery
On [DATE], [MOTHER'S NAME] presented to [HOSPITAL NAME] in labor at [XX] weeks gestation. [DESCRIBE RELEVANT PRENATAL HISTORY, E.G., "The pregnancy had been uncomplicated" OR "Mother had been diagnosed with gestational diabetes and was considered high-risk"].

During labor, electronic fetal monitoring revealed [DESCRIBE CONCERNING FINDINGS, E.G., "persistent late decelerations beginning at approximately XX:XX, indicating fetal distress from oxygen deprivation"]. Despite these warning signs, the attending physician, [DR. NAME], and nursing staff failed to [DESCRIBE SPECIFIC FAILURES, E.G., "recognize the non-reassuring fetal heart rate pattern" / "call for emergency cesarean section" / "escalate care appropriately"].

Instead, [DESCRIBE WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENED, E.G., "labor was allowed to continue for an additional XX hours" / "Pitocin administration was increased despite signs of hyperstimulation" / "vacuum extraction was attempted X times before finally proceeding to C-section"].
Birth Injury Description
[CHILD'S NAME] was born on [DATE] at [TIME] via [VAGINAL DELIVERY / EMERGENCY CESAREAN SECTION / VACUUM-ASSISTED DELIVERY]. At birth, [he/she] was [DESCRIBE CONDITION, E.G., "limp, pale, and not breathing" / "had APGAR scores of X at one minute and X at five minutes" / "required immediate resuscitation"].

Cord blood gases revealed [DESCRIBE RESULTS IF APPLICABLE, E.G., "severe metabolic acidosis with a pH of X.XX and base deficit of -XX, confirming significant oxygen deprivation during labor"].

[CHILD'S NAME] was immediately transferred to the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit (NICU), where [he/she] remained for [XX DAYS/WEEKS]. Subsequent MRI imaging confirmed [DIAGNOSIS, E.G., "hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE)" / "bilateral basal ganglia injury consistent with acute profound asphyxia" / "white matter injury"].
Current Condition and Prognosis
At [AGE] years old, [CHILD'S NAME] has been diagnosed with [DIAGNOSIS, E.G., "spastic quadriplegic cerebral palsy" / "Erb's palsy with permanent brachial plexus injury" / "global developmental delay"]. [He/She] currently experiences:

[LIST SPECIFIC IMPAIRMENTS, E.G., "• Inability to walk, stand, or sit independently / • Severe spasticity requiring Botox injections and baclofen pump / • Cortical visual impairment / • Seizure disorder requiring daily medication / • Inability to speak, requiring augmentative communication device / • G-tube dependency for nutrition"]

Medical experts have determined that [CHILD'S NAME]'s condition is permanent and will require lifelong 24-hour care, ongoing medical treatment, multiple surgeries, and intensive therapy services. [He/She] will never be able to live independently or engage in gainful employment.
Damages Summary
As a direct and proximate result of your negligence, [CHILD'S NAME] has sustained catastrophic, permanent injuries requiring lifetime care. Our preliminary damages calculation, based on a life care plan prepared by [LIFE CARE PLANNER NAME] and economic analysis by [ECONOMIST NAME], includes:

Economic Damages (No MICRA Cap):
Past medical expenses: $[AMOUNT]
Future medical care (present value): $[AMOUNT]
Future attendant care (present value): $[AMOUNT]
Therapy services (lifetime): $[AMOUNT]
Lost earning capacity: $[AMOUNT]
Home modifications and equipment: $[AMOUNT]
Total Economic Damages: $[AMOUNT]

Non-Economic Damages (Subject to MICRA Cap):
[CHILD'S NAME] has experienced and will continue to experience significant pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and physical impairment. These damages are subject to the MICRA cap of $[CURRENT CAP AMOUNT] under Civil Code Section 3333.2 as amended by AB 35.
Settlement Demand
This claim has been reviewed by qualified medical experts, including [EXPERT SPECIALTY, E.G., "a board-certified OB/GYN" / "a pediatric neurologist" / "a perinatologist"], who has confirmed that the standard of care was breached and that the breach caused [CHILD'S NAME]'s injuries.

To fully resolve all claims arising from this matter, including claims of both the minor child and [his/her] parents, we demand compensation in the total amount of $[TOTAL DEMAND].

This demand reflects the full economic damages of $[AMOUNT], the applicable MICRA cap for non-economic damages, and additional damages for [PARENTS' NAMES]'s loss of consortium and emotional distress.

Please have your professional liability insurance carrier contact the undersigned within 45 days to discuss resolution. We are prepared to provide supporting documentation, including medical records, expert reports, and the life care plan, to facilitate evaluation.
Closing and Preservation Notice
This notice is sent in compliance with Code of Civil Procedure Section 364 and tolls the statute of limitations for 90 days from the date of service. Please note that because [CHILD'S NAME] is a minor, the statute of limitations under CCP 340.5 has been tolled.

You are hereby directed to preserve all documents, records, and evidence related to [MOTHER'S NAME]'s prenatal care, labor, and delivery, and [CHILD'S NAME]'s birth and subsequent treatment, including but not limited to: complete medical records, electronic fetal monitoring strips (both paper and electronic formats), nursing notes, physician orders, medication administration records, operative reports, incident reports, peer review materials, correspondence, billing records, hospital policies and protocols, and staff training records.

Spoliation or destruction of evidence will result in adverse inference requests at trial and potential sanctions. If we do not receive a substantive response within 45 days, we will proceed with filing a complaint in California Superior Court upon expiration of the 90-day notice period.

This communication is a pre-litigation settlement demand protected by California Evidence Code Section 1152.

🚀 Next Steps

Birth injury cases are complex and require specialized legal representation. Here is what to do after recognizing a potential birth injury claim.

Immediate Actions

Step 1: Request All Medical Records

Request complete copies of all prenatal records, labor and delivery records, fetal monitoring strips, and the child's medical records. Hospitals must provide copies within 15 days under California law. Send requests via certified mail.

Step 2: Send Preservation Letter

Immediately send a written preservation letter to the hospital and all providers instructing them to preserve all evidence related to the birth. This prevents "accidental" loss of fetal monitoring strips or other critical evidence.

Step 3: Consult a Birth Injury Attorney

Birth injury cases require specialized expertise. Seek an attorney who focuses on birth injury/obstetric malpractice cases and has access to qualified medical experts. Most offer free consultations and work on contingency.

Step 4: Expert Medical Review

Your attorney will have the records reviewed by qualified experts (OB/GYN, pediatric neurologist, fetal monitoring specialist) to evaluate whether there is a viable claim. This typically takes 30-60 days.

Step 5: Send 90-Day Notice (CCP 364)

If experts confirm malpractice, send the 90-day notice to all potential defendants. This tolls the statute of limitations and provides opportunity for pre-suit resolution.

Statute of Limitations for Minors

💡 Special Rules for Children Under 6

Under CCP 340.5, minors who are under 6 years old when injured have their statute of limitations tolled until they turn 6. They then have until their 8th birthday to file suit (3 years from when tolling ends). This provides additional time, but you should NOT wait - evidence deteriorates, memories fade, and early investigation is critical.

MICRA Notice Requirements

📧 90 Days Before Filing

Must serve written notice at least 90 days before filing lawsuit. Notice must state legal basis and type of loss sustained.

🕑 Tolling Effect

Filing 90-day notice tolls (pauses) the statute of limitations for 90 days, effectively extending your deadline.

📋 Each Defendant

Must send separate notice to each healthcare provider you intend to sue (hospital, OB, nurses, anesthesiologist, etc.).

📝 Certificate of Merit

Before filing, attorney must consult with a qualified expert who confirms meritorious basis for the claim (CCP 411.30).

Litigation Timeline

Pre-Suit (6-12 months)

Records gathering, expert review, 90-day notice period, settlement negotiations. Many strong cases settle during this phase.

Filing and Discovery (12-24 months)

Complaint filed in Superior Court, defendants answer, extensive written discovery, document production, depositions of parties and experts.

Expert Discovery (6-12 months)

Expert witness designations, expert depositions, expert reports. Both sides retain multiple medical experts.

Mediation/Settlement Conferences

Court-ordered or voluntary mediation. Majority of cases settle before trial, often after expert depositions clarify strengths and weaknesses.

Trial (2-4 weeks)

If no settlement, jury trial. Birth injury trials typically last 2-4 weeks with extensive expert testimony.

⚠ Why You Need a Specialized Birth Injury Attorney

Birth injury cases are among the most complex and expensive to litigate:

  • Expert costs - May require $100,000-$500,000+ in expert fees and case costs
  • Specialized knowledge - Requires attorneys who understand obstetrics, fetal monitoring, and neonatology
  • Aggressive defense - Hospitals and their insurers fight these cases vigorously
  • Life care planning - Requires coordination with life care planners, economists, and medical specialists
  • Contingency basis - Good birth injury attorneys front all costs and only get paid if you win

Get a Free Birth Injury Case Evaluation

Birth injury cases have strict deadlines and require specialized expertise. Get a free, confidential consultation with an experienced California birth injury attorney to evaluate your case.

Free Consultation

California Resources

  • Medical Board of California: mbc.ca.gov - File complaints, verify physician licenses
  • California Department of Public Health: cdph.ca.gov - Hospital licensing and complaint information
  • California Courts Self-Help: selfhelp.courts.ca.gov - Court forms and procedures
  • State Bar Lawyer Referral: calbar.ca.gov - Find certified specialists in medical malpractice
  • United Cerebral Palsy: ucp.org - Resources for families affected by cerebral palsy

Related Guides