📚

Overview

California after-school programs serve millions of children through public school-based programs like ASES, federally-funded 21st Century Community Learning Centers, and private childcare providers. When these programs fail to deliver promised services, compromise child safety, or overcharge families, parents have legal remedies available.

Key Protection: California Education Code Section 8482 et seq. establishes the After School Education and Safety (ASES) program, requiring participating programs to provide educational enrichment, physical activity, and nutritional snacks in a safe environment. Private after-school programs must comply with Title 22 licensing requirements through the Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD).

Common after-school program issues in California include:

  • Program cancellation: Sudden closure or cancellation without refunds for prepaid fees
  • Safety violations: Inadequate supervision, unsafe conditions, improper staff ratios
  • Transportation failures: Missed pickups, late drop-offs, leaving children stranded
  • Fee disputes: Overcharging subsidized families, hidden fees, billing errors
  • Licensing violations: Operating without proper CCLD license or expired credentials
  • Breach of contract: Failure to provide promised activities, hours, or services
Public vs. Private Programs: The legal framework differs significantly between public school-operated ASES programs and private after-school providers. Public programs may have government tort claim requirements (Government Code 910), while private providers are subject to standard contract law and CCLD licensing enforcement.
⚖

Legal Basis

California provides multiple legal protections for families using after-school programs:

California Education Code 8482 et seq. - ASES Program ▼

The After School Education and Safety (ASES) program establishes requirements for state-funded after-school programs:

  • Program elements: Must include educational/literacy element, physical activity, and nutritional snack
  • Hours: Operate from end of school day until 6:00 PM
  • Free to families: ASES programs cannot charge participating families
  • Target population: Primarily serves students in low-performing schools
  • Accountability: Programs must meet performance outcomes and reporting requirements
21st Century Community Learning Centers (Federal) ▼

Federal funding through Title IV, Part B of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act:

  • Academic enrichment: Programs must help students meet state standards
  • Supplemental services: Tutoring, mentoring, arts, technology, and recreation
  • Extended hours: Before school, after school, summer, and holidays
  • Community partnerships: Required collaboration with schools and community organizations
  • Evaluation requirements: Programs must demonstrate effectiveness
Title 22 CCR - School-Age Childcare Licensing ▼

California Code of Regulations Title 22 governs licensed childcare facilities:

  • Staff ratios: 1:14 for school-age children (kindergarten and above)
  • Staff qualifications: Background checks, training requirements, first aid/CPR
  • Physical environment: Indoor/outdoor space requirements, safety standards
  • Health and safety: Sanitation, emergency procedures, medication administration
  • Record keeping: Attendance, emergency contacts, incident reports
CCLD Licensing (Health & Safety Code 1596.70 et seq.) ▼

The Community Care Licensing Division enforces childcare standards:

  • License types: Child care centers, family child care homes, school-age programs
  • Enforcement: Inspections, citations, civil penalties, license revocation
  • Complaint investigation: CCLD investigates complaints from parents
  • Public records: Licensing status and citations are public information
  • Exemptions: Some school-operated programs may be license-exempt
Consumer Legal Remedies Act (Civil Code 1750) ▼

CLRA protects consumers from unfair business practices:

  • Prohibited practices: Misrepresentation, bait and switch, false advertising
  • Remedies: Actual damages, restitution, injunctive relief
  • Attorney's fees: Prevailing plaintiffs may recover fees
  • 30-day notice: Required before filing CLRA lawsuit
License-Exempt Programs: Some after-school programs operated directly by public schools may be exempt from CCLD licensing under Health & Safety Code 1596.792. However, they must still meet school district policies and any applicable ASES or federal program requirements.
📋

Common Dispute Types

🚫 Program Cancellation Without Refund

When programs close suddenly or cancel sessions without returning prepaid fees:

  • Mid-year program termination
  • Seasonal closures without notice
  • Provider bankruptcy or abandonment
  • Failure to refund unused prepaid tuition
  • Registration fees retained despite no services

⚠ Unsafe Conditions / Supervision Failures

Safety violations that put children at risk:

  • Inadequate staff-to-child ratios
  • Unqualified or unchecked staff
  • Hazardous facility conditions
  • Failure to supervise during activities
  • No emergency procedures in place

🚌 Transportation Issues / Pickup Failures

Problems with program-provided transportation:

  • Missed school pickups leaving children stranded
  • Late drop-offs causing parent work issues
  • Unsafe transportation conditions
  • Wrong location drop-offs
  • Children left unattended at pickup points

💰 Fee Overcharges for Subsidized Families

Illegal charges to families receiving childcare assistance:

  • Charging above approved family fee
  • Unauthorized co-payment increases
  • Billing for subsidized hours
  • Hidden administrative fees
  • Requiring payment beyond subsidy amount
Safety Emergency: If your child is in immediate danger at an after-school program, remove them from the program immediately. Report safety violations to CCLD at 1-844-538-8766 or your local licensing office. Document everything with photos and written notes.
📂

Evidence Checklist

Gather this evidence to support your after-school program demand:

✔
Program Agreement/Contract

Enrollment agreement, terms of service, fee schedule, refund policy, and any amendments

✔
Payment Records

Receipts, bank statements, credit card records showing all fees paid to the program

✔
Program Communications

Emails, texts, letters, newsletters, and any written communications about services, policies, or issues

✔
Incident Documentation

Written complaints you submitted, incident reports from the program, photos of unsafe conditions

✔
CCLD Licensing Records

Provider's license status, inspection reports, citations (available at ccld.ca.gov)

✔
Subsidy Documentation

If subsidized: Notice of Action, approved family fee, provider reimbursement rate

✔
Alternative Care Costs

Receipts for replacement childcare, lost wage documentation, emergency backup care expenses

✔
Medical Records (if injury)

Medical bills, treatment records, photos of injuries if your child was harmed

Check License Status: Before sending your demand, verify the provider's CCLD license status at ccld.dss.ca.gov/carefacilitysearch. An expired or revoked license significantly strengthens your claim and may entitle you to additional remedies.
💰

Calculate Your Damages

After-school program disputes can result in various types of recoverable damages:

Damage Category Description
Fee Refunds for Cancelled Programs Full refund of unused prepaid fees, registration fees, materials fees for services not rendered
Alternative Care Costs Difference in cost between original program and replacement care (babysitters, other programs, etc.)
Lost Wages for Emergency Pickup Wages lost when required to leave work early due to transportation failures or program closures
Medical Costs (If Injury Occurred) All medical expenses, therapy, future treatment if child was injured due to negligence
Contract Damages Consequential damages from breach including out-of-pocket expenses and foreseeable losses

Sample Damages Calculation

Example: Program cancellation mid-semester with transportation failure

Unused prepaid program fees (3 months) $1,800
Registration fee (non-refundable per contract) $150
Emergency babysitter costs (2 weeks) $600
Lost wages - emergency pickups (8 hours) $320
Higher cost replacement program (3 months) $450
Total Potential Damages $3,320
Small Claims Court: California small claims court handles disputes up to $12,500 for individuals. After-school program disputes often fall within this range, making small claims an efficient option that does not require an attorney.
📝

Sample Demand Letter

After-School Program Demand Letter
[Your Name] [Your Address] [City, State ZIP] [Your Email] [Your Phone] [Date] VIA CERTIFIED MAIL - RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED [Program Name] [Program Director/Owner Name] [Address] [City, State ZIP] Re: Demand for Refund and Damages - After-School Program Breach Child: [Child's Name] Enrollment Period: [Start Date] - [Expected End Date] Program Agreement Date: [Date of Contract] Dear [Director/Owner Name]: I am writing to formally demand compensation for your program's breach of our enrollment agreement and violation of applicable California childcare regulations. BACKGROUND On [date], I enrolled my child, [Child's Name], in your after-school program for the [semester/year] at a cost of $[amount] per month, prepaid [monthly/quarterly/annually]. Per our agreement, [Program Name] was to provide: - After-school care from [time] to [time], Monday through Friday - Educational enrichment activities and homework assistance - [Transportation from [School Name] / Snack / Other promised services] - Supervision by qualified staff in compliance with Title 22 requirements BREACH OF AGREEMENT AND VIOLATIONS Your program has failed to meet its contractual obligations in the following ways: 1. [DESCRIBE SPECIFIC ISSUE #1 - e.g., "Program Cancellation: On [date], you notified families that the program would close effective [date], with only [X] days notice. This left [X] months of prepaid tuition unused, totaling $[amount]."] 2. [DESCRIBE SPECIFIC ISSUE #2 - e.g., "Transportation Failure: On [dates], your program failed to pick up my child from [School Name] as contracted, leaving my child unattended at school. I was forced to leave work early on [X] occasions, resulting in lost wages of $[amount]."] 3. [DESCRIBE SPECIFIC ISSUE #3 - e.g., "Safety Violations: During my visits to the facility, I observed staff-to-child ratios exceeding the 1:14 requirement under Title 22 CCR, creating unsafe conditions for the children."] APPLICABLE LAW Your conduct violates: - California Education Code Section 8482 et seq. (if ASES program) - Title 22 California Code of Regulations (school-age childcare licensing requirements) - Health & Safety Code Section 1596.70 et seq. (CCLD licensing) - California Civil Code (breach of contract) - Consumer Legal Remedies Act, Civil Code 1750 (if applicable) DAMAGES As a direct result of your breach, I have incurred the following damages: Refund of Unused Prepaid Fees: $[amount] Registration/Materials Fees: $[amount] Alternative Care Costs: $[amount] Lost Wages (Emergency Situations): $[amount] Difference in Replacement Program Cost: $[amount] [Medical Expenses, if applicable]: $[amount] TOTAL DAMAGES: $[total amount] DEMAND I hereby demand that within fifteen (15) days of your receipt of this letter, you: 1. Refund all unused prepaid program fees totaling $[amount]; 2. Pay additional damages of $[amount] for [alternative care costs/lost wages/etc.]; and 3. Provide written confirmation of the refund and payment. If I do not receive satisfactory resolution within 15 days, I will: - File a complaint with the Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD) - Report violations to [School District / County Office of Education, if applicable] - Pursue this matter in California Small Claims Court or Superior Court - Seek all available remedies including attorney's fees where permitted by law This letter serves as the 30-day notice required under Civil Code Section 1782 for Consumer Legal Remedies Act claims. Please direct all communications regarding this matter to me at the address above. Sincerely, [Your Signature] [Your Printed Name] Enclosures: - Copy of Enrollment Agreement - Payment Records - Communications Regarding Issues - [Other Supporting Documents] cc: Community Care Licensing Division (if violations) [School District, if public school program]
Government Claims: If your dispute involves a public school-operated after-school program, you may need to file a Government Tort Claim under Government Code 910 before filing a lawsuit. The deadline is typically 6 months from the incident. Consult an attorney for public entity claims.
❓

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the ASES program and what rights do parents have? ▼

The After School Education and Safety (ASES) program, established under California Education Code Section 8482, provides funding for after-school programs serving students in grades K-9. Parents have the right to safe, quality programming that includes educational enrichment, physical activity, and a nutritious snack. Programs must maintain proper adult-to-child ratios and comply with all CCLD licensing requirements. If your ASES program fails to meet these standards, you may be entitled to refunds and damages.

What California laws protect children in after-school programs? ▼

California after-school programs are governed by multiple laws including: Education Code 8482 et seq. (ASES program requirements), Title 22 California Code of Regulations (licensing standards for school-age childcare), Health and Safety Code 1596.70 et seq. (childcare licensing), and Civil Code 1750 et seq. (Consumer Legal Remedies Act). Public school programs must also comply with federal 21st Century Community Learning Centers requirements if federally funded.

Can I get a refund if an after-school program is cancelled? ▼

Yes, you are generally entitled to a full refund for any unused portion of prepaid after-school program fees if the program is cancelled. Under California Civil Code, providers cannot retain fees for services not rendered. If the program breached its contract by failing to provide promised services, you may also recover additional damages including the cost of alternative care arrangements and lost wages.

What supervision ratios are required for California after-school programs? ▼

California Title 22 regulations require licensed school-age childcare programs to maintain specific staff-to-child ratios. For school-age programs (kindergarten and above), the general requirement is 1:14 (one adult for every 14 children). However, ASES-funded programs and programs serving younger children may have different requirements. Field trips and transportation activities typically require lower ratios for safety.

What should I do if my child was injured at an after-school program? ▼

If your child was injured at an after-school program: 1) Seek immediate medical attention, 2) Document the injury with photos and medical records, 3) Request an incident report from the program, 4) File a complaint with CCLD (Community Care Licensing Division) if safety violations occurred, 5) Send a written demand letter to the program operator, and 6) Consult an attorney for significant injuries. You may recover medical costs, pain and suffering, and other damages.

Are subsidized families protected from fee overcharges in after-school programs? ▼

Yes, families receiving childcare subsidies through programs like CalWORKs or Alternative Payment Programs are protected from illegal fee overcharges. Providers cannot charge subsidized families more than the approved family fee or co-payment. Charging unauthorized fees violates California Education Code and subsidy program rules. Affected families can report violations to their county childcare resource and referral agency and demand refunds of any improper charges.

➡

Next Steps

1. Document Everything ▼
  • Save all contracts, receipts, and payment records
  • Take photos of any unsafe conditions
  • Keep copies of all communications with the program
  • Write down dates, times, and details of all incidents
  • Get witness contact information if applicable
2. Attempt Direct Resolution ▼
  • Contact the program director in writing first
  • Clearly state the issue and your requested resolution
  • Give them a reasonable deadline to respond (7-14 days)
  • Keep copies of all written communications
  • Follow up verbal discussions with written confirmation
3. Send Formal Demand Letter ▼
  • Use the sample letter template provided above
  • Send via certified mail with return receipt
  • Clearly itemize all damages and amounts claimed
  • Set a specific deadline for response (15-30 days)
  • Keep a copy for your records
4. File Regulatory Complaints ▼
  • CCLD: File complaints about licensing violations at 1-844-538-8766
  • School District: For public school programs, contact the district office
  • County Office of Education: For ASES program issues
  • R&R Agency: Report subsidy fraud to your local Resource & Referral
5. Consider Legal Action ▼
  • Small Claims Court: Up to $12,500 without an attorney
  • Superior Court: For larger claims or injury cases
  • Government Tort Claim: Required before suing public programs (6-month deadline)
  • Consult Attorney: For significant injuries or complex cases
California Resources:

Need Help With Your After-School Program Dispute?

Get a consultation to discuss your specific situation and options for resolving your childcare dispute.

Schedule Consultation Email: owner@terms.law