Vehicle Damage, Repairs, Total Loss, and Diminished Value - California Law
After a California car accident, you have options for getting your vehicle repaired. You can file a claim with your own collision coverage (faster, but requires paying your deductible) or file a third-party claim against the at-fault driver's insurance (no deductible, but potentially longer process).
You have the right to choose any repair facility; insurance companies cannot require you to use their preferred shops. Get at least two repair estimates to compare with the insurance company's estimate. The insurer must pay for repairs that restore your vehicle to pre-accident condition, including OEM parts if appropriate. Review the repair estimate carefully and question any items that seem inadequate.
A vehicle is totaled when repair costs exceed approximately 70-80% of its value. When totaled, you're entitled to the fair market value immediately before the accident, not book value or loan balance. If you disagree with the valuation, research comparable vehicles using Kelley Blue Book, NADA guides, and local listings.
Document your vehicle's features, condition, and upgrades. Consider getting an independent appraisal and negotiate with evidence of higher values. If you owe more than the vehicle's value, gap insurance can cover the difference. You may keep the totaled vehicle by accepting a reduced payout minus salvage value, but it will receive a salvage title.
Diminished value is the reduction in your vehicle's market value after an accident, even when fully repaired. A car with accident history is worth less than an identical vehicle without accident history. California recognizes diminished value claims against at-fault parties.
To prove diminished value, obtain a pre-accident valuation, get a post-repair appraisal from a certified appraiser specializing in diminished value, and calculate the difference. Newer vehicles with lower mileage typically have higher claims. Include diminished value as a separate line item when negotiating your settlement.
Yes, if another driver was at fault, you're entitled to a rental car for the reasonable repair time or, if totaled, reasonable time to obtain a replacement. The at-fault driver's insurance should cover rental costs. You're entitled to a comparable rental, meaning similar size and features.
Keep your rental period reasonable by authorizing repairs promptly and responding to insurance requests quickly. For total loss claims, reasonable replacement time is typically one to two weeks after payment. Keep all rental receipts to document expenses. If using your own insurance, you may have rental reimbursement coverage with daily limits.
Beyond vehicle damage, you can claim compensation for:
Document items with photographs, provide receipts or proof of value, and include itemized losses in your claim. For items without receipts, describe them in detail and provide comparable replacement costs.
Yes, California law protects your right to choose any repair shop. Insurance companies cannot require you to use preferred shops or direct repair programs. Under California Insurance Code Section 758.5, insurers must inform you of this right.
However, if you use an insurance-preferred shop, they typically guarantee the work. If your chosen shop's estimate differs from the insurance estimate, negotiation may be needed. To protect yourself, get estimates from multiple shops, choose a reputable facility, and ensure the shop will work with your insurance on supplemental claims if additional damage is discovered.
When actual repair costs exceed the insurance estimate, most insurers have a supplemental claim process. The shop should document additional damage with photographs and submit a supplement request. If the insurer disputes legitimate costs, you can request a re-inspection, provide documentation supporting repair necessity, or file a complaint with the California Department of Insurance.
Don't authorize repairs beyond the approved amount without supplement approval, or you may be responsible for the difference. Communicate clearly with both your shop and insurance company throughout the process.
Multi-vehicle accidents create complex property damage scenarios. Fault is typically divided among multiple parties using comparative negligence. Each driver's insurance may be partially responsible.
Document the entire accident scene including all vehicles' positions and damage. Exchange information with all drivers. Report to your insurer and identify all other insurers involved. You may need to file claims against multiple insurers. If combined coverage is insufficient, your uninsured motorist property damage coverage may help. For complex multi-vehicle accidents, consider consulting an attorney.
California's statute of limitations for property damage claims is three years from the accident date. You must file a lawsuit within three years or lose your right to sue. Insurance claims have different, typically shorter deadlines. Report accidents promptly to preserve coverage.
If making a claim against a government entity, you must file a Government Tort Claim within six months. Don't wait until the deadline approaches. Acting quickly preserves evidence and provides leverage in negotiations. If approaching the deadline without resolution, consult an attorney about filing suit.
Yes, towing and storage fees are recoverable as part of your property damage claim. Recoverable expenses include towing from the accident scene, storage fees while awaiting inspection, and additional towing to a repair shop.
Keep all receipts. Storage fees accumulate quickly, so minimize storage time by promptly getting your vehicle inspected and authorizing repairs. Insurance companies may dispute unreasonable storage fees. If the vehicle is totaled, storage fees should cease once you're notified. Negotiate with the insurer about ongoing storage responsibility if disputing total loss valuation.
Generate a professional, legally-compliant demand letter in minutes.
Create Your Letter