📋 Overview

When an insured appeals a claim denial, you must conduct a thorough, good faith reconsideration. Under California regulations, insurers must fully evaluate new information and provide a clear, reasoned response. Failure to properly handle appeals can itself constitute bad faith.

⚠ Fresh Review Required

Appeals require genuine reconsideration - not rubber-stamping the original decision.

🕒 Time Limits Apply

Respond within 40 days of receiving complete appeal documentation.

💰 Document Everything

Detailed file notes showing genuine reconsideration protect against bad faith claims.

Common Appeal Scenarios

  • New evidence - Insured provides documentation not available at initial denial
  • Policy interpretation - Insured disputes your reading of coverage terms
  • Factual dispute - Insured challenges findings that led to denial
  • Procedural issues - Insured claims denial process was flawed
  • Regulatory complaint - Department of Insurance involvement
$450
Professional Appeal Response

Thorough re-evaluation, documentation, and formal response on attorney letterhead.

Schedule Review

🔍 Appeal Process

Proper appeal handling demonstrates good faith and protects against regulatory action.

Required Steps

Step Action Timeline
1. Acknowledge Confirm receipt of appeal Within 15 days
2. Review Assign to different adjuster if possible Promptly
3. Investigate Evaluate new evidence/arguments Ongoing
4. Decide Affirm, modify, or reverse denial Within 40 days
5. Communicate Clear written explanation Same as decision

📄 Appeal Review Checklist

  • ✓All new documents received and reviewed
  • ✓Original file re-examined
  • ✓Policy terms re-analyzed
  • ✓Each argument addressed

📝 Documentation Required

  • ✓Notes showing genuine reconsideration
  • ✓Supervisor review if affirming
  • ✓Expert consultation if needed
  • ✓Clear reasoning in response

💡 Best Practice: Different Reviewer

When possible, assign appeals to a different adjuster or supervisor than who made the original decision. This demonstrates objectivity and fresh perspective.

🛡 Re-Evaluation Factors

Consider whether new information or arguments warrant reversing the denial.

New Medical Evidence

Additional records, second opinions, or clarifying statements from treating physicians may support coverage or causation.

Action: Compare to original evidence; consider whether new information changes analysis.

Policy Language Arguments

Insured may cite case law or regulatory guidance supporting different interpretation of coverage terms.

Action: Research cited authorities; consult coverage counsel if interpretation is genuinely uncertain.

Factual Clarifications

Witness statements, photos, or documents that clarify disputed facts underlying the denial.

Action: Evaluate whether new facts change the outcome; document reasoning either way.

Procedural Challenges

Insured claims investigation was inadequate or denial letter didn't comply with regulations.

Action: Review process for compliance; correct any procedural defects even if coverage position unchanged.

⚠ Red Flags Requiring Escalation

  • Represented by attorney or public adjuster
  • Department of Insurance complaint filed
  • Media involvement or social media activity
  • New evidence significantly undermines denial basis

⚖ Response Options

Choose the appropriate response based on your re-evaluation.

Reverse Denial

If new information supports coverage, reverse the denial and process the claim. Document what changed.

Partial Reversal

If some arguments have merit, consider paying part of the claim while maintaining denial on remainder.

Affirm with Explanation

If denial remains appropriate, provide detailed explanation addressing each argument raised.

Request More Info

If you need additional documentation to complete review, request it promptly.

📝 Sample Responses

Professional templates for appeal responses.

Affirming Denial
We have completed our review of your appeal dated [DATE] regarding our denial of your claim for [LOSS TYPE]. We carefully considered each point raised in your appeal, including: - [Argument 1 and response] - [Argument 2 and response] - [New evidence submitted and analysis] After thorough reconsideration, we must respectfully affirm our original decision. The claim remains denied because [clear explanation of basis]. The policy provision at issue states [quote relevant language]. If you disagree with this decision, you may [identify next steps - appraisal, DOI complaint, litigation rights].
Reversing Denial
We have completed our review of your appeal dated [DATE]. Based on the additional information you provided, we are reversing our prior denial. Specifically, the [new evidence/documentation] demonstrates that [explain what changed the analysis]. Accordingly, we find that your claim is covered under the policy. We are processing payment in the amount of [$AMOUNT], which you should receive within [X] business days. This payment represents [breakdown of covered amounts]. We apologize for any inconvenience caused by the original denial. Please contact us if you have any questions.
Partial Reversal
We have reviewed your appeal and the additional documentation provided. Based on our reconsideration, we are modifying our original decision as follows: We agree that [portion of claim] is covered, and we are processing payment of [$AMOUNT] for this portion. However, we must maintain our denial of [remaining portion] because [explanation]. The new evidence you provided does not change our analysis on this issue because [reasoning]. You may pursue further appeal of the remaining denied amount through [available options].

🚀 Next Steps

Step 1: Acknowledge

Confirm receipt and set expectations for response timeline.

Step 2: Assign

Route to appropriate reviewer - ideally different from original adjuster.

Step 3: Analyze

Conduct genuine reconsideration of all evidence and arguments.

Step 4: Respond

Provide clear, detailed written response within required timeframe.

Need Professional Assistance?

Get expert help with your appeal response.

Schedule Consultation - $450

California Resources

  • Insurance Code 790.03: Unfair Claims Settlement Practices
  • 10 CCR 2695.7: Standards for Prompt, Fair Settlements
  • CDI Complaint Process: insurance.ca.gov