📋 Overview
You have received a demand letter from a wedding client claiming you breached your photography contract. Photography disputes often involve highly subjective complaints about artistic quality, as well as more concrete issues like delivery timelines and missing shots. Your defenses center on artistic discretion, substantial performance, and clear contract provisions.
📷 Artistic Discretion
Photography is an art form. Your contract likely reserves artistic discretion for editing style, composition, and creative choices.
📄 Portfolio Evidence
Your portfolio demonstrates your style. Clients who booked after viewing your work accepted that style.
📈 Volume Delivered
Hundreds of delivered images demonstrate substantial performance even if some shots were missed.
Common Photography Claim Types
- Image quality complaints - Dissatisfaction with editing, lighting, composition
- Missing shots or moments - Key photos allegedly not captured
- Late delivery - Images delivered after promised timeline
- Fewer images than expected - Final count below client expectations
- No-show or early departure - Photographer failed to attend or left early
- Raw file demands - Client demanding unedited images not included in contract
- Copyright disputes - Client claiming ownership rights to images
Attorney Services Pricing
- 📄 Response letter: Flat fee $450
- ⏱ Extended negotiation: $240/hr
- 📊 Copyright/litigation: Hourly rates
🔍 Evaluate the Claim
Photography complaints often blend objective issues (delivery timing, number of photos) with subjective quality assessments. Separate these elements in your analysis.
Claim Risk Assessment
| Claim Type |
Typical Exposure |
Defense Strength |
| Complete no-show |
Full refund + potential consequential damages |
WEAK |
| Lost all images (equipment failure) |
Full refund, insurance claim recommended |
WEAK |
| Subjective quality complaints |
Generally defensible with portfolio evidence |
STRONG |
| Late delivery (within reason) |
Partial refund or additional deliverables |
MODERATE |
| Missed specific shot (first kiss, etc.) |
Depends on shot list and circumstances |
MODERATE |
| Demand for raw files not in contract |
No liability if contract excludes raws |
STRONG |
📄 Contract Review
- ✓Coverage hours defined
- ✓Delivery timeline specified
- ✓Artistic discretion clause
- ✓Limitation of liability
📷 Documentation Needed
- ✓Client-approved shot list
- ✓Gallery delivery confirmation
- ✓Communications showing your style
- ✓Backup files and raw images
⚠ Data Loss Is Serious
If you lost images due to equipment failure or data corruption, notify your professional liability insurance immediately. Equipment failure coverage may apply. Never admit to data loss without understanding your coverage.
🛡 Your Defenses
Wedding photographers have unique defenses based on the artistic nature of the work and industry standards.
Artistic Discretion
Photography contracts typically reserve artistic discretion to the photographer for editing style, composition, color grading, and creative choices. Subjective preferences about these elements are not grounds for breach claims.
When to use: Client complains about editing style, poses, color tones, or creative choices that fall within normal artistic variation.
Portfolio Acceptance
The client viewed your portfolio and sample work before booking. By booking after reviewing your work, they accepted your established style. Complaints that the work does not match expectations are countered by portfolio evidence.
When to use: Client claims photos do not match their vision despite booking after viewing your portfolio.
Substantial Performance
If you delivered hundreds of quality images covering the wedding comprehensively, you have substantially performed even if a few specific moments were missed. Minor gaps do not constitute material breach.
When to use: Client focuses on 2-3 missing shots despite receiving 500+ quality images.
No Guaranteed Shots Disclaimer
Most photography contracts disclaim guarantees of specific shots because photographers cannot control all variables (lighting, guest movement, timing, obstructions). Document that no shot list was provided or that obstacles prevented specific captures.
When to use: Client complains about specific missing shots, but your contract disclaims shot guarantees.
Delivery Within Contract Terms
If you delivered images within the timeline specified in your contract (often 6-12 weeks), late delivery claims fail. Many contracts include delivery windows rather than fixed dates.
When to use: Client complains about timing, but delivery was within contractual timeframe.
Copyright Ownership Defense
Under copyright law, the photographer owns the copyright to images unless explicitly assigned in writing. Client licenses are typically limited to personal use. Demands for raw files or full copyright are outside standard agreements.
When to use: Client demands raw files, commercial use rights, or claims ownership of your images.
🚨 Weak Defense Situations
- Complete failure to attend the wedding
- Lost or corrupted all images with no backup
- Significantly fewer images than contract specified
- Major equipment failure affecting substantial portions
- Left wedding early without coverage of key events
⚖ Response Options
Select your response based on the nature of the complaint and your documentation.
Deny with Artistic Discretion Defense
For subjective quality complaints, deny the claim citing your artistic discretion clause, portfolio evidence, and the substantial volume of delivered images.
- Reference contract provisions
- Cite portfolio acceptance
- Document delivery volume
Offer Additional Editing
If the complaint is about editing style, offer to re-edit select images to client preferences without providing a refund.
- Addresses concerns directly
- No cash refund needed
- Shows good faith
Partial Refund for Objective Issues
If there are legitimate delivery delays or documented missed coverage, offer proportional compensation while defending against broader claims.
- Addresses real issues
- Limits broader exposure
- Professional resolution
Insurance Claim for Equipment Failure
If equipment failure caused significant image loss, file a professional liability claim and work with insurance to resolve client compensation.
- Professional coverage applies
- Limits personal exposure
- Industry standard response
📊 Response Analysis
Example: $4,500 wedding photography contract
Contract value$4,500
Images delivered650 edited photos
Coverage hours worked10 hours
Post-processing hours25+ hours
Client refund demand$4,500
SUBSTANTIAL PERFORMANCE:Delivered as contracted
📝 Sample Responses
Customize these response templates for your specific situation.
RE: Your Letter Dated [DATE] Regarding [CLIENT NAME] Wedding Photography
We have reviewed your demand letter regarding photography services for the [DATE] wedding.
We respectfully deny your claims of breach. Our Photography Agreement includes the following provision at Section [X]:
"[Quote artistic discretion clause, e.g., "Photographer retains full artistic discretion over image selection, editing style, color grading, cropping, and creative presentation. Client acknowledges reviewing Photographer's portfolio and accepting Photographer's established style."]"
Your complaints regarding [editing style, color tones, composition choices] fall squarely within this reserved artistic discretion. The images delivered are consistent with the style displayed in our portfolio, which you reviewed before booking our services.
We delivered [NUMBER] professionally edited images, exceeding our contractual commitment of [NUMBER]. The gallery was delivered on [DATE], within our [X]-week delivery window.
Wedding photography is inherently artistic, and no two photographers produce identical work. The images we created faithfully document your wedding day in our established artistic style. Subjective preferences about creative choices do not constitute breach of contract.
Having fully performed our obligations, no refund is due.
RE: [CLIENT NAME] Wedding Photography - Response
We have reviewed your concerns regarding specific photographs from your [DATE] wedding.
Our Photography Agreement at Section [X] provides:
"[Quote disclaimer, e.g., "Due to the unpredictable nature of weddings, Photographer cannot guarantee capture of any specific moment. Factors including timing, lighting, guest positioning, and venue conditions affect image availability."]"
Regarding the specific shots you mention:
- [Shot 1]: [Explain circumstances - "The moment occurred while I was photographing the bridal party entrance as directed by your coordinator" / "Guest obstruction blocked the shot" / etc.]
- [Shot 2]: [Explanation]
We delivered [NUMBER] images comprehensively documenting your ceremony, reception, portraits, and key moments. This constitutes substantial performance of our agreement. The absence of [2-3] specific captures among hundreds of delivered images does not constitute material breach.
Additionally, no shot list was provided to us before the wedding date. Our contract does not guarantee specific photographs without a pre-approved shot list.
We are proud of the work we delivered and stand behind its quality.
RE: [CLIENT NAME] Wedding Photography - Resolution
We have reviewed your concerns regarding the delivery timing of your wedding photographs.
While our contract specified delivery within [X] weeks, we acknowledge that delivery occurred at [X] weeks. We understand this delay caused frustration, and we apologize for the extended timeline. [Optional: Brief explanation - "An unexpected family emergency required our attention during the editing period."]
The gallery of [NUMBER] professionally edited images has now been delivered and available for your download. We believe the quality of the final images meets our professional standards and captures your wedding day beautifully.
In recognition of the delivery delay, we offer the following:
[Choose one or combine:]
- A credit of $[AMOUNT] toward a future portrait session or print order
- [X] additional edited images of your choice from the wedding
- A partial refund of $[AMOUNT], representing [X%] of the contract price
We do not agree that the delay warrants a full refund given the substantial work delivered. However, we want to address your legitimate concern about timing.
Please confirm which accommodation you prefer.
RE: Demand for Raw Files and Copyright - [CLIENT NAME]
We have received your demand for raw/unedited image files and copyright transfer.
Our Photography Agreement clearly defines the deliverables and rights granted. Section [X] states:
"[Quote deliverables section, e.g., "Client shall receive high-resolution edited JPEG images. Raw files are not included and remain the property of Photographer."]"
Section [X] regarding copyright provides:
"[Quote copyright section, e.g., "Photographer retains copyright to all images created. Client is granted a limited, non-exclusive license for personal use including printing, social media, and personal display. Commercial use requires separate licensing."]"
Under U.S. Copyright Law (17 U.S.C. Section 201), copyright vests in the creator of the work - the photographer - unless explicitly assigned in writing. Our agreement does not include a copyright assignment.
The industry standard is for photographers to retain raw files and copyright while granting clients personal use licenses. This protects both parties' interests and is consistent with our agreed terms.
We have fulfilled our contractual obligations by delivering [NUMBER] edited images with the agreed license grant. Raw files and copyright transfer were not part of our agreement and are not available.
🚀 Next Steps
Take these actions after receiving a photography breach claim.
Step 1: Secure Your Files
Ensure all raw files, edited images, and backups are preserved and accessible.
Step 2: Review Contract
Identify artistic discretion, delivery timeline, liability limits, and deliverable specifications.
Step 3: Document Delivery
Confirm gallery delivery dates, image counts, and any download confirmations.
Step 4: Respond Professionally
Send written response within 10-14 days with specific contract references.
Protecting Your Photography Business
- Strong contracts - Include artistic discretion, delivery windows, and liability caps
- Portfolio consistency - Maintain portfolio showing your consistent style
- Backup protocols - Multiple backup systems for all client work
- Professional insurance - Equipment and professional liability coverage
Get Professional Help
Photography disputes often involve copyright and artistic discretion issues. Get a professional response on attorney letterhead.
Schedule Consultation - $450
Related Resources