📋 HOA Dispute Overview
California homeowner associations (HOAs) are governed by the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, one of the most comprehensive HOA laws in the nation. When disputes arise between homeowners and their HOA, understanding your rights under this law is critical to achieving a favorable resolution.
Common HOA Dispute Scenarios
💰 Assessment Disputes
Improper special assessments, excessive late fees, wrongful liens, and collection violations
📁 Records Request Denials
HOA refusing to provide financial records, meeting minutes, or membership lists
✅ Election Violations
Improper ballot procedures, inspector violations, and voting rights denials
⚠ Fine Disputes
Excessive fines, lack of proper notice, denial of hearing rights
🚧 Architectural Review Denials
Arbitrary denials, inconsistent standards, unreasonable delays
🛠 Maintenance Failures
HOA failing to maintain common areas, deferred maintenance, repair disputes
💡 California-Specific Protections
California provides stronger homeowner protections than most states. The Davis-Stirling Act requires HOAs to follow specific procedures for assessments, elections, fines, and records access. Violations can result in liability for the HOA and recovery of attorney fees for prevailing homeowners.
⚖ Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act
The Davis-Stirling Act (California Civil Code Sections 4000-6150) is the comprehensive statutory framework governing all common interest developments in California, including condominiums, planned developments, and community apartment projects.
Key Statutory Provisions
Civil Code 5200-5210: Association Records
Homeowners have the right to inspect and copy association records within 10 business days of a written request. This includes financial documents, meeting minutes, contracts, and membership lists (with some limitations). The HOA may charge reasonable copying costs but cannot charge for the first two requests per member per fiscal year.
Civil Code 5600-5740: Assessment Collection
Strict rules govern assessment collection, late fees (capped at 10% or $10, whichever is greater), liens, and foreclosure. Before recording a lien, the HOA must send notice at least 30 days in advance. Foreclosure is only permitted when delinquency exceeds $1,800 or is 12+ months past due.
Civil Code 5100-5145: Elections and Voting
All board elections must use secret written ballots counted by an independent inspector of elections. Members must receive notice at least 30 days before an election. The inspector must be independent of the board and cannot be a member of the board, a candidate, or related to either.
Civil Code 5850-5855: Disciplinary Procedures
Before imposing fines or suspending privileges, the HOA must give the member at least 10 days notice and an opportunity to be heard before the board. The notice must describe the alleged violation and the proposed discipline.
Civil Code 4765: Architectural Review
Architectural committees must provide written decisions within 60 days of a complete application. Denials must state the basis for the decision in writing. Committees cannot make arbitrary decisions and must apply standards consistently.
Civil Code 5900-5965: Dispute Resolution (IDR/ADR)
Before filing most lawsuits against an HOA, homeowners must attempt Internal Dispute Resolution (IDR) under CC 5900-5920 and Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) under CC 5925-5965. Failure to offer or participate in these processes can affect attorney fee recovery.
⚠ Mandatory Pre-Suit Requirements
California law requires ADR before filing most HOA enforcement actions. Under Civil Code 5930, the complaint must state that ADR was completed, that one party refused to participate, or that preliminary injunctive relief is necessary. Ignoring this requirement can result in dismissal or denial of attorney fees.
📝 HOA Dispute Types
Each type of HOA dispute has specific legal requirements and remedies under the Davis-Stirling Act. Understanding these distinctions helps you craft an effective demand letter.
💰 Assessment Disputes
▼Common Issues:
- Special assessments imposed without proper member vote (CC 5605)
- Late fees exceeding statutory limits (10% or $10 maximum per CC 5650)
- Liens recorded without proper notice (30 days required under CC 5660)
- Failure to offer payment plans to delinquent owners (CC 5665)
- Foreclosure threats when delinquency is under $1,800 and less than 12 months old
Your Rights: You can demand an itemized statement of charges, challenge improper fees, and require the HOA to follow all statutory procedures before taking enforcement action.
📁 Records Request Violations (CC 5200-5210)
▼Records You Can Request:
- Annual budget reports and financial statements
- Meeting minutes (board and membership)
- Contracts with third parties (management, maintenance, etc.)
- Insurance policies and claims history
- Membership list (name, property address, mailing address)
- Reserve study and funding plan
- Collection and delinquency reports (redacted)
HOA Obligations: Must respond within 10 business days. Cannot charge for first two requests per year. Must provide records in the format you specify if reasonably available.
Remedies: Court can order production, award actual damages, and award attorney fees to the prevailing party.
✅ Election Violations (CC 5100-5145)
▼Common Violations:
- Failure to use secret ballots (CC 5100)
- Inspector of elections not independent (CC 5110)
- Inadequate notice of election (30 days required)
- Improper ballot handling or counting procedures
- Denying members the right to run for the board
- Failure to verify voter eligibility properly
Remedies: Election results can be voided and new election ordered. Courts can appoint an inspector of elections. Prevailing party may recover attorney fees.
⚠ Fine Disputes (CC 5850-5855)
▼Due Process Requirements:
- Written notice at least 10 days before hearing
- Notice must describe the alleged violation
- Notice must describe the proposed discipline
- Opportunity to be heard before the board
- Decision must be in writing within 15 days of hearing
Challenges: Fines imposed without proper procedure are void. Fines must be authorized by the CC&Rs and reasonable in amount. Selective enforcement (fining you but not others for same violation) is prohibited.
🚧 Architectural Review Denials (CC 4765)
▼Your Rights:
- Written decision within 60 days of complete application
- Denials must state the specific basis in writing
- Standards must be applied consistently to all owners
- Approval cannot be unreasonably withheld
- Certain modifications cannot be prohibited (solar panels, drought-tolerant landscaping, etc.)
Protected Modifications: California law specifically protects your right to install solar energy systems (CC 714), electric vehicle charging stations (CC 4745), and drought-tolerant landscaping (CC 4735). HOAs cannot unreasonably restrict these.
👥 HOA Board Duties and Homeowner Rights
HOA board members have fiduciary duties to act in the best interests of the association and its members. Understanding these duties helps identify when the board has failed to meet its obligations.
Board Fiduciary Duties
🔒 Duty of Care
Board members must act with the care that an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances
💜 Duty of Loyalty
Board members must act in good faith and in the best interests of the association, not for personal benefit
📖 Duty to Follow Governing Documents
The board must comply with the CC&Rs, bylaws, and California law in all actions
📈 Duty of Financial Responsibility
Proper budgeting, reserve funding, and transparent financial management
Homeowner Rights Under Davis-Stirling
| Right | Civil Code Section | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Inspect Records | CC 5200-5210 | Access financial records, meeting minutes, and contracts within 10 business days |
| Vote in Elections | CC 5100-5145 | Secret ballots, independent inspectors, proper notice of elections |
| Due Process for Fines | CC 5850-5855 | Notice and hearing before disciplinary action |
| Attend Board Meetings | CC 4900-4955 | Notice of meetings, right to speak on agenda items |
| Request IDR | CC 5900-5920 | Meet and confer with board to resolve disputes |
| Solar Panel Installation | CC 714 | HOA cannot unreasonably restrict solar energy systems |
| EV Charging Stations | CC 4745 | Right to install electric vehicle charging in your parking space |
| Payment Plans | CC 5665 | Right to payment plan before foreclosure for delinquent assessments |
💥 Attorney Fee Recovery
Under Civil Code 5975(c), in any enforcement action between an association and a member, the prevailing party is entitled to reasonable attorney fees. This is a powerful tool that makes it economical to pursue even smaller HOA disputes if you have a strong case.
🔍 Evidence to Gather
A strong demand letter is backed by solid evidence. Gather these documents before sending your demand to demonstrate the strength of your position.
📁 General Documents
- ✓ CC&Rs, Bylaws, and Rules
- ✓ All correspondence with HOA
- ✓ Board meeting minutes (relevant)
- ✓ Notices received from HOA
- ✓ Photos documenting any issues
💰 Assessment Disputes
- ✓ Assessment statements and invoices
- ✓ Payment history/receipts
- ✓ Lien notices (if any)
- ✓ Special assessment ballot/vote results
- ✓ Late fee calculations
📁 Records Requests
- ✓ Copy of your written request
- ✓ Proof of delivery (certified mail, email)
- ✓ Any HOA response received
- ✓ Timeline of request and response
✅ Election Issues
- ✓ Election notice and timeline
- ✓ Ballot materials
- ✓ Inspector of elections information
- ✓ Witness statements (if irregularities)
⚠ Fine Disputes
- ✓ Violation notice received
- ✓ Hearing notice and date
- ✓ Evidence of alleged violation
- ✓ Evidence others not fined for same issue
- ✓ Written decision from board
🚧 Architectural Disputes
- ✓ Your application and all attachments
- ✓ Denial letter with stated reasons
- ✓ Architectural guidelines
- ✓ Photos of similar approved modifications
📄 Sample Demand Letter Language
Use these sample paragraphs as starting points for your demand letter. Customize each section with your specific facts and circumstances.
Assessment Dispute - Late Fee Violation
I hereby demand that the Association immediately: (1) credit my account $[EXCESS AMOUNT] for the unlawful late fees; (2) provide an itemized accounting of all charges to my account; and (3) confirm in writing that future late fees will comply with Civil Code 5650. If this matter is not resolved within 15 days, I will pursue all available remedies under the Davis-Stirling Act, including recovery of attorney fees as the prevailing party under Civil Code 5975(c).
Records Request Demand (Civil Code 5200-5210)
1. Annual budget reports and financial statements for fiscal years [YEARS]
2. Board meeting minutes for the past [NUMBER] months
3. Contracts with [MANAGEMENT COMPANY/VENDOR]
4. Current reserve study and funding plan
5. Insurance policies and claims history for the past three years
Under Civil Code 5210, you must make these records available for inspection within 10 business days of this written request. Please contact me at [PHONE/EMAIL] to schedule inspection. This is my [FIRST/SECOND] records request this fiscal year, so no copying fee may be charged for the first request.
Failure to comply with this request may result in legal action seeking actual damages, attorney fees, and court-ordered production under Civil Code 5235.
Election Violation Demand
[SELECT APPLICABLE VIOLATIONS:]
- The inspector of elections was not independent as required by Civil Code 5110 because [REASON - e.g., "the inspector is a current board member"]
- Secret ballot requirements under Civil Code 5100 were violated because [REASON]
- Proper notice of 30 days was not provided as required by the Association's election rules
- Ballots were not counted in an open meeting as required by Civil Code 5120
These violations undermine the integrity of the election and violate members' fundamental voting rights. I demand that the Board: (1) void the election results; (2) appoint a properly independent inspector of elections; and (3) conduct a new election in full compliance with Civil Code 5100-5145.
If this demand is not satisfied within 30 days, I will pursue judicial relief under Civil Code 5145, including voiding the election, appointment of an inspector by the court, and recovery of attorney fees.
Fine Dispute - Due Process Violation
This fine was imposed in violation of Civil Code 5850-5855 because:
[SELECT APPLICABLE:]
- I did not receive written notice at least 10 days before the hearing as required by CC 5855(a)
- The notice did not describe the proposed discipline as required by CC 5855(a)
- I was not given an opportunity to be heard before the Board as required by CC 5855(b)
- The written decision was not provided within 15 days as required by CC 5855(c)
- The fine constitutes selective enforcement as [OTHER UNITS/OWNERS] have not been fined for identical conduct
Because the Association failed to follow mandatory due process procedures, this fine is void and unenforceable. I demand immediate removal of this fine from my account and written confirmation that my account balance is current. Failure to comply within 15 days will result in legal action, including recovery of attorney fees under Civil Code 5975(c).
Architectural Review Denial Challenge
The denial violates California Civil Code Section 4765 and the Association's governing documents because:
[SELECT APPLICABLE:]
- The denial was not provided within 60 days of my complete application as required by CC 4765
- The denial did not state the specific basis for the decision in writing as required
- The proposed modification complies with all written architectural guidelines
- The Association has approved identical modifications for other homeowners at [ADDRESSES]
- The denial unreasonably restricts [SOLAR PANELS/EV CHARGING/DROUGHT-TOLERANT LANDSCAPING] in violation of Civil Code [714/4745/4735]
I demand that the Association: (1) reconsider my application in light of the above; (2) approve the modification; or (3) provide written reasons that comply with the law and governing documents. If my application is not approved within 30 days, I will pursue IDR, ADR, and if necessary, judicial relief including attorney fees.
📝 Need a Complete Custom Letter?
I draft comprehensive HOA demand letters for a flat fee of $450. Each letter is customized to your specific situation, cites all applicable Davis-Stirling provisions, and is designed to achieve results. Book a consultation to discuss your case.
🚀 When to Escalate: IDR, ADR, and Litigation
California law establishes a specific escalation path for HOA disputes. Following this process correctly is essential for preserving your rights and maximizing your chances of success.
The Davis-Stirling Dispute Resolution Process
Step 1: Demand Letter
Send a written demand letter clearly stating your position, the legal basis, and what resolution you seek. Keep copies and proof of delivery. This establishes your good faith effort to resolve the dispute.
Step 2: Internal Dispute Resolution (IDR) - CC 5900-5920
Request IDR in writing. Either party can request a meet-and-confer with one or more board members. The HOA must acknowledge your request within 15 days. IDR is informal but creates a record of your attempts to resolve.
Step 3: Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) - CC 5925-5965
Before filing most enforcement actions, you must offer ADR (mediation or arbitration). If the HOA refuses to participate, you can proceed to court. Participating in ADR in good faith can strengthen your fee recovery claim.
Step 4: Litigation
If ADR fails or is refused, you can file suit in Superior Court. Your complaint must certify ADR compliance. The prevailing party in an enforcement action is entitled to attorney fees under CC 5975(c).
When to Skip to Litigation
⚠ Emergency Situations
If you need preliminary injunctive relief to prevent irreparable harm, you may proceed directly to court
🔒 Statute Running
If the statute of limitations is about to expire, file suit immediately to preserve your claims
🚫 HOA Refuses ADR
If the HOA refuses or fails to respond to your ADR offer within 30 days, you can proceed to court
Escalation Decision Matrix
✅ Pursue Escalation When:
- Clear violation of Davis-Stirling or CC&Rs
- Strong documentary evidence of the violation
- Financial harm exceeds cost of ADR/litigation
- HOA is unresponsive to reasonable demands
- Pattern of violations affecting multiple owners
- Attorney fee recovery makes case economical
🔴 Consider Alternatives When:
- Dispute is primarily interpersonal, not legal
- Amount at stake is minimal
- Facts are disputed and evidence is weak
- You are selling the property soon
- HOA is willing to negotiate in good faith
- Board election could change leadership
⚖ Statute of Limitations
4 years for breach of written contract (CC&Rs, bylaws)
3 years for statutory violations
2 years for personal injury claims
Do not let the statute run while attempting informal resolution. If the deadline approaches, file suit to preserve your rights. You can continue settlement discussions during litigation.
Need Help With Your HOA Dispute?
I represent California homeowners and HOAs in Davis-Stirling disputes. Demand letters are $450 flat; litigation at $240/hour. Let me evaluate your case.
Schedule Consultation🖩 Hoa Davis Stirling Damages Calculator
Use this interactive calculator to estimate potential damages in your case. Enter your information below to get an estimate of recoverable damages.
📈 Estimated Damages Breakdown
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to Resolve Your HOA Dispute?
I personally handle California HOA matters under the Davis-Stirling Act. Demand letters are $450 flat; litigation and ongoing representation at $240/hour. Let me help you protect your rights.
Book a 30-Minute ConsultationOr email me directly: owner@terms.law