Custody & Visitation Order Violation Letters

Comprehensive guide to enforcing custody and visitation orders when the other parent interferes with your court-ordered parenting time in California.

When a custody or visitation order exists, both parents must comply. When one parent interferes with the other's court-ordered time - whether by denying visits, being chronically late, refusing to return children, or undermining the parenting relationship - the court takes it seriously. A well-crafted demand letter documents the violations and often motivates compliance without the expense of returning to court.

Prerequisites: This guide assumes you have a valid custody or visitation order from a California court (or a valid out-of-state order). If you only have an informal agreement, you need to formalize it with a court order before these enforcement tools apply.

Why Send a Demand Letter First?

Before filing contempt motions or modification requests, a strategic demand letter serves important purposes:

Purpose Why It Matters
Creates Documentation Courts want to see that you attempted to resolve issues before filing. Your demand letter shows good faith and documents the other parent's non-compliance.
Establishes Pattern A single missed exchange might be forgiven; a pattern after written warnings is much harder to explain. Your letters build the case for contempt.
Provides Warning Many parents don't fully understand the consequences of violating court orders. A letter spelling out contempt penalties and custody modification often prompts immediate compliance.
Preserves Relationship Co-parenting continues for years. A private demand is less inflammatory than an immediate court filing, preserving some working relationship.
Faster Resolution Court motions take months. A letter demanding compliance within 7 days often gets faster results.

The Stakes: What's at Risk

Parents who repeatedly violate custody orders face serious consequences:

The "friendly parent" doctrine: California courts favor parents who facilitate the child's relationship with the other parent. A parent who repeatedly interferes with custody is viewed unfavorably, regardless of their other parenting qualities. This can dramatically impact custody decisions.

When to Use This Guide

This Guide Is For:

This Guide Is Not For:

Understanding Your Custody Order

Before asserting violations, you must understand exactly what your order requires. Review your order for:

Physical Custody Schedule

Exchange Details

Communication Requirements

Restrictions

California Legal Framework

Governing Statutes

Contempt of Court

Contempt is the primary enforcement mechanism for custody order violations. To prove contempt, you must establish:

  1. Valid order existed: A clear, specific custody/visitation order from the court
  2. Knowledge of order: The other parent knew about the order (was served, present when made, or otherwise had actual knowledge)
  3. Ability to comply: The other parent could have complied with the order
  4. Willful violation: The other parent intentionally chose not to comply

The standard of proof is beyond a reasonable doubt. This is why documentation is essential.

Penalties for Contempt

Penalty Details
Jail Up to 5 days per violation (each denied visit can be a separate violation)
Fines Up to $1,000 per violation
Attorney's fees Court can order violating parent to pay other parent's legal costs
Make-up time Compensatory parenting time for denied visits
Modified custody Pattern of violations can result in custody modification

Criminal Prosecution

In serious cases, custody violations can result in criminal charges:

Criminal prosecution is generally reserved for egregious cases (abduction, prolonged concealment, fleeing the state).

The Move-Away Standard

Under Marriage of LaMusga and Family Code § 7501, a parent with primary custody has a presumptive right to relocate with the children, but:

Modification Based on Violations

Repeated custody violations can be grounds for modifying custody under the "changed circumstances" standard:

Self-help is not allowed: If the other parent violates the order, you cannot retaliate by withholding child support, denying your own custody time, or taking other self-help measures. Two wrongs don't make a right - and courts will hold both parents accountable.

Types of Custody Violations

1. Denied Visitation

The other parent refuses to make the children available for your court-ordered time.

Examples:

Response: Document each denial with date, time, and circumstances. After multiple denials, a formal demand letter followed by contempt motion is appropriate.

2. Shortened or Interrupted Time

The other parent delivers children late, picks them up early, or interrupts your time with demands or interference.

Examples:

Response: Log every incident. For chronic lateness, demand letter requesting strict compliance. For serious interference, contempt motion may be warranted.

3. Failure to Return Children

The other parent doesn't return children at the end of their time.

Severity levels:

4. Interference with Communication

The other parent blocks your phone/video contact with the children during their time.

Examples:

Response: Document call attempts and outcomes. If order specifies communication rights, this is enforceable through contempt.

5. Parental Alienation

The other parent systematically undermines your relationship with the children.

Warning signs:

Response: This is difficult to prove but serious. Consider requesting a custody evaluation. Document specific incidents of badmouthing. Demand letter may be part of the record, but alienation usually requires professional intervention.

6. Unauthorized Move or Travel

The other parent moves or travels with children without required notice or consent.

Examples:

Response: Depends on your order's specific terms. May require emergency motion if children are being moved imminently. For threatened move, demand letter asserting your rights and intent to oppose.

7. Unilateral Decision-Making

If you have joint legal custody, both parents must participate in major decisions.

Major decisions typically include:

Response: Demand letter asserting your right to participate in decisions. If decision is already made, consider whether modification motion is appropriate.

The "Difficult Child" Defense

Many violating parents claim "the child doesn't want to go" as justification. California courts have consistently rejected this defense:

Courts expect parents to parent. A court order is not optional based on the child's preference. Parents are expected to ensure compliance with custody orders, just as they would ensure children go to school or the doctor. Allowing a child to dictate custody is itself a form of parental failure - and often evidence of alienation.

The only exception is when a child's safety is genuinely at risk - and even then, the proper response is to seek emergency court orders, not unilaterally deny visitation.

Evidence Gathering

Custody enforcement cases depend heavily on documentation. Start gathering evidence immediately when violations occur.

Core Documents

☐ Complete custody/visitation order (judgment, stipulation, or temporary order)

☐ Any modifications to the original order

☐ Proof the other parent received the order

☐ Any parenting plan or detailed schedule attached to order

☐ Any mediation agreements or court minutes

Violation Documentation

☐ Calendar log of each violation (date, time, what happened)

☐ Screenshots of text messages about exchanges

☐ Emails requesting/confirming/disputing custody time

☐ Photos with timestamps at exchange locations (proving you showed up)

☐ Witness statements from exchange observers

☐ Co-parenting app records (OurFamilyWizard, TalkingParents, etc.)

Communication Interference Evidence

☐ Phone records showing call attempts

☐ Screenshots of unanswered video calls

☐ Texts requesting phone time and responses

☐ Documentation of blocked numbers or changed numbers

☐ Children's statements about being unable to contact you

Parental Alienation Evidence

☐ Recordings of children making disparaging remarks (if legal in your state - California is two-party consent)

☐ Written statements from children (be careful - don't coach)

☐ Social media posts by other parent criticizing you

☐ Reports from therapists, teachers, or counselors

☐ Timeline showing change in children's attitude

Third-Party Evidence

☐ Police reports from denied exchanges

☐ Statements from teachers about custody confusion

☐ Medical records showing missed appointments during your time

☐ Affidavits from family members who witnessed denials

☐ Professional evaluator reports (if any)

Documentation Best Practices

The Custody Log

Keep a contemporaneous log of every exchange and violation. For each entry, record:

The "Calm Parent" Approach

Your documentation should reflect that you are the reasonable parent:

California recording law: California is a "two-party consent" state for recordings. You cannot secretly record phone conversations with the other parent. However, you can: (1) record your own statements at exchanges, (2) take photos/videos in public places, (3) keep written records of what was said, (4) use dashcam footage that captures audio incidentally.

Strategic Considerations

When to Send a Demand Letter

When to Go Directly to Court

Using Co-Parenting Apps

Apps like OurFamilyWizard, TalkingParents, and AppClose create timestamped, unalterable records of all communications. Benefits:

Consider requesting the court order use of a co-parenting app as part of any modification.

Demand Letter Templates

Template 1: Pattern of Denied Visitation

Use when: Other parent has repeatedly denied or interfered with your court-ordered parenting time.

Re: Custody Order Violations - Denied Parenting Time [Your Name] v. [Other Parent Name] [Court Name], Case No. [Number] Dear [Other Parent Name]: I represent [Client Name] regarding your repeated violations of the custody order entered by [Court Name] on [date]. THE ORDER The order requires [summarize relevant custody provisions - e.g., "that [Client Name] have physical custody of [Child's Name(s)] every other weekend from Friday at 6:00 PM to Sunday at 6:00 PM, with exchanges occurring at [location]."] THE VIOLATIONS You have repeatedly failed to comply with this order. Specifically: [Date 1]: [Description - e.g., "You refused to make the children available for the Friday exchange, claiming they were 'sick.' No medical documentation was provided."] [Date 2]: [Description] [Date 3]: [Description] [Continue listing violations with specific dates and factual descriptions] In total, [Client Name] has been denied [number] custodial periods to which [he/she] was entitled under the court order. LEGAL CONSEQUENCES Your repeated interference with court-ordered custody constitutes contempt of court. Each denial is a separate violation punishable by: • Up to 5 days in county jail • Up to $1,000 in fines • Payment of [Client Name]'s attorney's fees • Compensatory parenting time Additionally, your pattern of interference with [Client Name]'s relationship with [his/her] [children/child] may constitute grounds for modifying custody in [his/her] favor. California courts favor parents who facilitate the child's relationship with the other parent. THE DEMAND [Client Name] demands that you: 1. Immediately comply with all terms of the custody order going forward 2. Make the children available for all scheduled parenting time without interference 3. Provide make-up time for the [number] custodial periods that were wrongfully denied If you fail to comply with the custody order, or if you deny another custodial period without legitimate emergency, [Client Name] will immediately file a motion for contempt and request that the court impose the maximum penalties. [Client Name] wants to co-parent cooperatively, but will not tolerate continued interference with [his/her] relationship with [his/her] [children/child]. Please confirm your intent to comply within 7 days. Very truly yours, [Attorney Name] [Bar Number] [Contact Information]

Template 2: Failure to Return Children

Use when: Other parent kept children beyond their custodial time without agreement.

URGENT: DEMAND FOR IMMEDIATE RETURN OF CHILDREN Re: [Your Name] v. [Other Parent Name] Case No. [Number] SENT VIA CERTIFIED MAIL, EMAIL, AND TEXT Dear [Other Parent Name]: I represent [Client Name]. This letter concerns your failure to return [Child's Name(s)] as required by the custody order. THE VIOLATION The custody order entered on [date] requires you to return [Child's Name(s)] to [Client Name] at [time] on [date] at [location]. You failed to return the [children/child] as ordered. [Client Name] arrived at the designated time and place, but you did not appear and have not responded to communications. As of this letter, [Child's Name(s)] [has/have] been in your custody for [X] days/hours beyond the court-ordered exchange time. THIS IS A SERIOUS MATTER Your refusal to return [Child's Name(s)] may constitute: 1. CONTEMPT OF COURT: Punishable by up to 5 days in jail and $1,000 fine per violation 2. CRIMINAL CONDUCT: Under Penal Code § 278.5, maliciously depriving a parent of custody is a crime punishable by up to 4 years in state prison 3. GROUNDS FOR CUSTODY MODIFICATION: Demonstrating that you cannot be trusted to comply with court orders IMMEDIATE DEMAND You must return [Child's Name(s)] to [Client Name] within 24 HOURS of receiving this letter. Specifically, you must: • Contact [Client Name] or this office immediately at [phone number] • Arrange an exchange at [location] within 24 hours • Comply with all future exchanges as ordered If [Child's Name(s)] [is/are] not returned within 24 hours, [Client Name] will: • File a police report for custodial interference • Seek emergency court orders for immediate return • File contempt charges seeking jail time • Request the court modify custody based on your demonstrated unwillingness to co-parent This is not a negotiation. Return the [children/child] immediately. [Attorney Name] [Contact Information] cc: [Local Police Department - optional for serious situations]

Template 3: Communication Interference

Use when: Other parent is blocking phone/video contact with children during their custodial time.

Re: Interference with Court-Ordered Communication [Case Name and Number] Dear [Other Parent Name]: I represent [Client Name] regarding your interference with [his/her] court-ordered communication with [Child's Name(s)]. THE ORDER The custody order entered on [date] provides that [Client Name] shall have [phone/video] contact with [Child's Name(s)] [describe schedule - e.g., "every Tuesday and Thursday evening between 7:00 PM and 8:00 PM during your custodial periods."] THE VIOLATIONS You have repeatedly prevented this communication from occurring: [Date 1]: [Client Name] called at the designated time. [Describe what happened - e.g., "The call went to voicemail. No call back was made."] [Date 2]: [Description] [Date 3]: [Description] [Continue with specific instances] [Client Name] has been denied meaningful contact with [his/her] [children/child] on [number] occasions in the past [timeframe]. WHY THIS MATTERS The children have a right to maintain a relationship with both parents. Your interference: • Violates a court order (contempt) • Harms the children's relationship with their [father/mother] • May constitute parental alienation • Demonstrates unwillingness to facilitate co-parenting Courts take this seriously. Under Family Code § 3040, a parent's willingness to facilitate the child's relationship with the other parent is a factor in custody determinations. THE DEMAND 1. Immediately ensure [Child's Name(s)] [is/are] available for all scheduled calls 2. Provide a working phone number where the [children/child] can be reached during your custodial time 3. Allow calls to occur privately, without listening in or interrupting 4. Do not punish or guilt the [children/child] for speaking with [Client Name] If communication continues to be blocked, [Client Name] will file a motion requesting: • Contempt finding with appropriate penalties • Specific communication schedule with enforcement provisions • Modification of custody based on your interference with the parental relationship [Client Name] simply wants to maintain [his/her] relationship with [his/her] [children/child]. Please facilitate this. [Attorney Name]

Template 4: Unauthorized Relocation Threat

Use when: Other parent is threatening to move with children without proper notice or consent.

Re: Notice of Opposition to Proposed Relocation [Case Name and Number] SENT VIA CERTIFIED MAIL AND EMAIL Dear [Other Parent Name]: I represent [Client Name]. It has come to our attention that you intend to relocate with [Child's Name(s)] to [location/city/state] without [proper notice/consent/court approval]. LEGAL REQUIREMENTS Under California Family Code § 7501 and the custody order in this matter: [Choose applicable provisions:] • The custody order requires you to provide [X] days written notice before relocating with the children • The custody order prohibits relocation outside [geographic area] without court approval • Joint custody requires that major decisions, including relocation, be made jointly • Relocation affecting custody requires court approval under Marriage of LaMusga standards NOTICE OF OPPOSITION [Client Name] opposes the proposed relocation. Any unilateral relocation would: • Violate the existing custody order • Constitute contempt of court • Severely impact [Client Name]'s relationship with [his/her] [children/child] • Potentially constitute custodial interference under Penal Code § 278.5 [Client Name] intends to exercise [his/her] right to oppose this move and seek court determination of the children's best interests. THE DEMAND 1. DO NOT relocate with [Child's Name(s)] without court approval 2. If you wish to relocate, file a proper motion with the court and allow [Client Name] an opportunity to respond 3. Maintain the current custody arrangement until the court rules on any relocation request If you relocate without following proper procedures, [Client Name] will: • Seek emergency court orders for return of the children • File contempt charges • Report the matter to law enforcement if appropriate • Seek full custody based on your demonstrated disregard for court orders and [Client Name]'s parental rights This is not a matter to take lightly. Moving with children in violation of custody orders can result in criminal charges and loss of custody. [Attorney Name]

Template 5: General Compliance Warning (Escalating Pattern)

Use when: Multiple types of violations; need to put other parent on notice that pattern is documented.

Re: Pattern of Custody Order Violations - Final Warning Before Court Action [Case Name and Number] SENT VIA CERTIFIED MAIL AND EMAIL Dear [Other Parent Name]: I represent [Client Name]. This letter documents your continuing pattern of custody order violations and serves as a final warning before we seek court enforcement. DOCUMENTED VIOLATIONS Since [date], [Client Name] has documented the following violations of the [Court Name] custody order: DENIED VISITATION: • [Date]: [Brief description] • [Date]: [Brief description] [Continue as applicable] LATE/INCOMPLETE EXCHANGES: • [Date]: [Brief description] • [Date]: [Brief description] [Continue as applicable] COMMUNICATION INTERFERENCE: • [Date]: [Brief description] • [Date]: [Brief description] [Continue as applicable] OTHER VIOLATIONS: • [Date]: [Brief description] [Continue as applicable] THE PATTERN IS CLEAR This is not a series of isolated incidents. Your conduct demonstrates a pattern of deliberate interference with [Client Name]'s relationship with [his/her] [children/child]. Whether through denied visits, late exchanges, blocked phone calls, or other interference, you have consistently prioritized conflict over the children's need for a relationship with both parents. CONSEQUENCES If this pattern continues, [Client Name] will pursue: 1. CONTEMPT MOTION: Seeking jail time, fines, and attorney's fees for each documented violation 2. CUSTODY MODIFICATION: Requesting that custody be modified in [Client Name]'s favor based on your demonstrated inability or unwillingness to co-parent and facilitate the children's relationship with their [father/mother] 3. MAKE-UP TIME: Requesting compensatory parenting time for all denied custodial periods THE DEMAND Starting immediately, you must: 1. Comply fully with every provision of the custody order 2. Make the children available for all scheduled parenting time 3. Facilitate rather than obstruct communication during your custodial periods 4. Communicate respectfully about scheduling and the children's needs This is your final warning. Any further violation will result in immediate court action. [Client Name] has given you multiple opportunities to correct course. This letter documents that you have been warned. Your choice now is whether to co-parent in good faith or face the legal consequences of continued obstruction. [Attorney Name] [Contact Information]

Is Your Co-Parent Violating Custody Orders?

I help parents in California enforce custody and visitation orders. Here's what I can do for you:

  • Review your custody order and identify enforceable provisions
  • Draft and send formal demand letters documenting violations
  • Prepare and file contempt motions
  • Seek make-up parenting time for denied visits
  • Request custody modifications based on pattern of interference
  • Handle emergency motions when children are at risk
  • Coordinate with law enforcement when appropriate
  • Negotiate structured co-parenting arrangements
Typical costs:
• Demand letter with certified mail: ~$450 (includes review of order and documentation of violations)
• Contempt motion and hearing: ~$240/hour
• Custody modification motion: ~$240/hour
• Emergency orders: ~$240/hour (prioritized handling)

Schedule a Consultation

Book a paid consultation to discuss your situation.

Email: owner@terms.law