Stripe Fund Hold Recovery: Legal Guide & Demand Letter Generator

 

Introduction: Understanding the Stripe Fund Hold Problem

Maybe you are one of the thousands of merchants who’ve had funds suddenly frozen by Stripe. What begins as a productive business relationship often turns into a financial nightmare when merchants discover their hard-earned money held hostage, sometimes indefinitely, with vague explanations about “risk” or “policy violations.”

As a business attorney who has represented many e-commerce merchants in disputes with payment processors, I’ve witnessed firsthand how devastating these situations can be—and more importantly, how they can be resolved with the right legal approach.

This comprehensive guide includes an interactive demand letter generator that creates professional, legally-compliant demand letters tailored to your specific Stripe situation. The tool incorporates the same legal strategies I use in my practice to help merchants recover their withheld funds.

This guide will walk you through:

• Why Stripe holds merchant funds and the patterns I’ve observed
• The exact legal strategies that have proven successful in releasing funds
• Step-by-step demand letter generator that adapts to your specific situation
• How to navigate Stripe’s mandatory arbitration process
• Real-world case studies and success stories

The included generator tool eliminates guesswork by asking targeted questions about your situation and automatically crafting a demand letter that addresses Stripe’s specific contract terms and legal vulnerabilities. By the end, you’ll have both the knowledge and the tools to take decisive legal action.

Demand Letter with AAA Arbitration Demand Generator

 

The Anatomy of a Stripe Fund Hold: Common Patterns and Practices

Indefinite Fund Holds Following Account Termination

Common scenario involves Stripe abruptly terminating a merchant’s account while citing “risk” concerns, then holding funds for an indeterminate period. Merchants are then told their funds will be released within a specific timeframe—typically 5-7 days or 90 days—only to find that deadline continuously extended without explanation.

According to Section 6.1(b) of the Stripe Services Agreement (SSA), Stripe may indeed “terminate this Agreement (or any part) or close your Stripe Account at any time for any or no reason by notifying you.” While this provision gives Stripe broad discretion to close accounts, it does not explicitly authorize indefinite fund withholding.

Users frequently claim that after Stripe terminates their account, the remaining balance is frozen for extraordinarily long periods with no clear end date. For instance, a BBB complaint filed in May 2025 describes Stripe holding a business’s funds for over six months after an account freeze in October 2024 – all “without providing any clear communication or resolution” bbb.org. In another case, a merchant was promised a 180-day hold for risk review after termination, yet found themselves well beyond that 180-day period with no payout or update from Stripe bbb.org. Reddit threads echo these stories: one user recounted that Stripe suddenly closed their account as “high risk” despite zero disputes, told them to wait 120 days, then “continued to withhold my funds, giving me new reasons to wait indefinitely” instead of ever releasing the money reddit.com. Stripe’s own user agreement allows holds after termination, and indeed merchants on Trustpilot report holds stretching far past the initial timeframe (e.g. “held onto $874.00 paid from my customer for over 120 days now!!” according to one review) newfrontierfunding.com. The lack of any definitive payout date in these situations has led some affected business owners to seek help from regulators or legal channels old.reddit.com, underscoring how common and severe “indefinite” holds have become in online complaints.

Shifting Payout Timelines and Lack of Explanation

Many Stripe users report that payout dates keep shifting, with little to no explanation from the company. It’s common for merchants to be told their funds will be released after a certain waiting period, only to receive a last-minute extension or new delay without clear cause. One Reddit user, for example, followed Stripe’s instruction to wait 120 days for a payout, only to be met with vague excuses and an indefinite extension once those 120 days passed reddit.com. In fact, some merchants say Stripe repeatedly extends holds in 90-day increments – sending emails every 90 days that “Stripe is holding your funds for an additional 90 days,” effectively pushing the timeline out continuously disputifier.com. Such experiences leave merchants feeling whipsawed and helpless. According to an analysis of Stripe’s Trustpilot reviews, “many users have reported issues with accounts being closed or funds being withheld without clear explanations.” newfrontierfunding.com One Trustpilot reviewer noted that even though Stripe’s website advertises prompt payouts, in reality their payout had been delayed well beyond the promised date newfrontierfunding.com. These shifting timelines – often presented with minimal transparency – are a major source of frustration in the Stripe user community.

Retroactive “High Risk” Account Designations

Another common theme is Stripe suddenly designating a business as “high risk” after processing payments, resulting in holds or account shutdowns that merchants didn’t anticipate. In one detailed Reddit post, a small business owner described how Stripe abruptly labeled their long-standing account as “high risk” and deactivated it despite “no disputes, no chargebacks, and no red flags” on their end reddit.com. Similarly, a contractor on Reddit shared that after a single large transaction (a $10,000 ACH payment), Stripe immediately closed the account citing “High Risk,” even though the business had no prior issues or excessive chargebacks; nearly a year later, Stripe was still holding the funds from that transaction old.reddit.com. Observers note that Stripe’s quick trigger on risk is partly because the platform doesn’t perform traditional up-front underwriting of merchants – as one commenter put it, “with Stripe, there is no underwriting, so you get cut off if anything doesn’t match their model of what you ‘should’ be doing.”news.ycombinator.com This retroactive risk assessment means a business can operate normally for months, only to be blindsided by a sudden “high risk” flag and frozen funds. Merchants often express bewilderment at these decisions and anger that no detailed justification is provided for the high-risk label that derailed their income stream reddit.comold.reddit.com.

Lack of Communication and Support Blackout

Perhaps the most consistent grievance across these reports is the utter lack of effective communication from Stripe once funds are held. Users describe reaching out repeatedly to customer support, only to receive canned responses or silence. In the BBB complaint mentioned above, the business owner writes that they contacted Stripe’s support multiple times but got only “vague and lacking in detail” replies and no meaningful update on the status of their funds bbb.org. Others have alleged a near “support blackout” after Stripe flags their account: one Reddit user said Stripe even disabled their ability to call or live chat with support once the account was frozen, leaving email as the only channel – and those emails largely went unanswered reddit.com. Trustpilot reviews likewise mention unresponsive or unhelpful customer support in these scenarios newfrontierfunding.com. On Hacker News, small business owners have resorted to public posts seeking advice because “payments have been withheld… and I am not receiving any responses from [Stripe’s] risk team and their support teams have been useless.” news.ycombinator.com This communication void leaves customers feeling helpless and in the dark. As one frustrated Stripe user wrote, after months of being bounced around with no answers, they “feel like I’m being kept in the dark and treated unfairly.” reddit.com The overwhelming sentiment in these complaints is that once an account is under review or terminated, Stripe’s support often goes silent, providing little transparency or assistance during a critical time.

Chargeback Loop Causing Further Account Risk

Some complaints describe a vicious feedback loop where Stripe’s hold on funds triggers customer disputes – which then makes Stripe even more likely to hold or terminate the account. For example, a Reddit user with around $130,000 frozen explained that Stripe froze her account due to a rising “dispute rate,” but the twist was that the disputes only arose because Stripe was holding all her funds in the first place reddit.com. Since she couldn’t access money to fulfill orders or issue timely refunds, customers started filing chargebacks en masse, which in turn worsened her dispute metrics and prompted Stripe to further clamp down – a Catch-22 scenario reddit.com. In that same post, the user noted Stripe then limited her communication options, making it even harder to resolve the situation reddit.com. A BBB complaint from 2025 describes a similar predicament: the merchant’s funds were held past 180 days with no resolution, meaning neither the business nor its customers could be made whole, putting the owner in “a very difficult position” trying to resolve disputes and protect their reputation bbb.org. He pleaded for Stripe to either release the funds to him or refund the customers, warning that the lack of action and communication was “unacceptable.” bbb.org These examples illustrate how a Stripe freeze can snowball – the company withholds money to guard against potential chargebacks, but that very act can cause chargebacks (when undelivered products or refunds lead angry customers to dispute charges), which then gives Stripe even more reason to keep the account locked. It’s a loop that merchants say is extremely hard to break out of once it begins.

---

The scenarios above are drawn from public user reports on platforms like Reddit, Trustpilot, the BBB, Quora, and Hacker News. They are provided to illustrate common complaints about Stripe’s practices, and while they corroborate patterns discussed in the original blog post, these anecdotal examples have not been independently verified. Each reference is linked to the original source for readers to review firsthand.

Risk Factors That Trigger Stripe Fund Holds and Account Reviews

 

Based on my experience representing merchants in Stripe disputes, certain business patterns consistently trigger account reviews and fund holds. Understanding these risk factors is crucial for both prevention and building an effective legal response when challenging Stripe’s actions.

Sudden Transaction Volume Increases

The Pattern: Businesses experiencing rapid growth—particularly those jumping from hundreds to thousands of dollars in daily processing volume—often trigger automated risk flags. A business processing $500 per day that suddenly handles $15,000 in transactions may find their account under immediate review.

Why This Triggers Scrutiny: Payment processors use transaction velocity as a primary fraud indicator. Money laundering operations typically show similar patterns: minimal activity followed by sudden, large-volume processing.

Legal Relevance: When challenging holds based on growth patterns, document your marketing campaigns, product launches, or business developments that explain the legitimate reasons for increased sales volume.

Cross-Border Transaction Patterns

The Pattern: Businesses where a significant percentage of transactions originate from international customers, particularly from countries with higher historical fraud rates, face elevated scrutiny.

Why This Triggers Scrutiny: International transactions carry higher chargeback risks and present additional compliance challenges. Stripe’s risk algorithms factor geographic distribution of sales heavily into their assessments.

Legal Relevance: Maintain detailed records of your international marketing efforts, customer verification procedures, and fraud prevention measures to counter risk designation challenges.

Product Quality and Customer Satisfaction Issues

The Pattern: High complaint volumes, negative reviews mentioning sizing issues, product quality problems, or items not matching descriptions create risk flags that can lead to account restrictions.

Why This Triggers Scrutiny: Customer dissatisfaction directly correlates with chargeback rates. Stripe monitors various feedback channels and may act preemptively when patterns suggest incoming disputes.

Legal Relevance: Document your quality control processes, customer service responsiveness, and satisfaction metrics to demonstrate proactive business management and low dispute probability.

Fulfillment and Shipping Discrepancies

The Pattern: Businesses with extended shipping times, particularly those not clearly disclosed at checkout, or those experiencing fulfillment delays face account scrutiny.

Why This Triggers Scrutiny: Shipping delays are among the top reasons for customer chargebacks. When customers expect fast delivery but receive products weeks later, dispute rates increase dramatically.

Legal Relevance: Maintain clear documentation of your shipping policies, delivery confirmations, and customer communications regarding order status to demonstrate transparent business practices.

Business Model Transparency and Compliance Gaps

The Pattern: Businesses operating in regulated industries without proper licensing, those whose actual operations differ from their initial account application, or those lacking clear terms of service and refund policies.

Why This Triggers Scrutiny: Stripe faces regulatory liability for the merchants they enable. Businesses that appear to operate outside disclosed parameters or without proper compliance frameworks present institutional risk.

Legal Relevance: Document complete alignment between your actual business operations and what you disclosed during account setup, including any business model evolution and compliance measures.

What Stripe Actually Wants to See During Account Reviews

When Stripe places your account under review or initiates a fund hold, they’re seeking specific documentation to assess ongoing risk. Understanding their requirements helps you prepare a comprehensive response that addresses their concerns directly.

Financial and Operational Documentation

What They Request:

• Recent invoices and sales documentation proving transaction legitimacy
• Business financial statements demonstrating stability
• Detailed business plan outlining your go-to-market strategy
• Bank statements showing consistent business operations
• Evidence of inventory management and supplier relationships

Strategic Response: Provide comprehensive financial documentation that demonstrates your business is legitimate, stable, and operating within disclosed parameters. Include growth projections that explain recent volume increases.

Customer Satisfaction and Dispute Management

What They Evaluate:

• Historical chargeback and dispute rates compared to industry standards
• Customer service procedures and response times
• Refund and return policy clarity and implementation
• Customer review monitoring and issue resolution processes
• Evidence of proactive customer communication

Strategic Response: Compile metrics showing dispute rates below 0.75% (industry standard), customer satisfaction scores, and documented customer service protocols. Demonstrate you actively manage potential disputes before they become chargebacks.

Product and Service Delivery Verification

What They Analyze:

• Product quality control measures and standards
• Shipping and delivery confirmation systems
• Clear product descriptions and accurate marketing materials
• Order fulfillment timelines and tracking procedures
• Customer onboarding and expectation setting processes

Strategic Response: Provide evidence of systematic quality control, delivery confirmation processes, and transparent customer communications. Show that customer expectations align with actual delivery capabilities.

Compliance and Risk Management Framework

What They Assess:

• Industry-specific licensing and regulatory compliance
• Fraud prevention measures and security protocols
• Business registration and legal entity documentation
• Terms of service, privacy policy, and refund policy completeness
• Data security measures and PCI compliance status

Strategic Response: Document comprehensive compliance with all applicable regulations, robust fraud prevention systems, and clear customer-facing policies. Demonstrate proactive risk management rather than reactive problem-solving.

Business Model Verification and Projections

What They Examine:

• Alignment between actual operations and initial account application
• Scalability plans and growth management strategies
• Revenue diversification and customer base stability
• Marketing methods and customer acquisition strategies
• Long-term business sustainability indicators

Strategic Response: Provide detailed explanation of any business model evolution since account opening, demonstrate sustainable growth strategies, and show evidence of responsible scaling practices. Address each relevant risk factor directly, providing counter-evidence that demonstrates your business operates within normal risk parameters. Use Stripe’s own risk criteria against them by demonstrating how your business meets or exceeds industry standards across all major risk categories. Propose specific ongoing monitoring or reporting arrangements that address Stripe’s concerns while securing fund release.

The key insight is that Stripe’s risk assessment, while broad, follows predictable patterns. By systematically addressing each concern with documented evidence, you transform their risk justification from a general defense into a specific claim requiring proof—shifting the burden back to Stripe to justify continued fund withholding.

Understanding the Legal Framework: The Stripe Services Agreement

Key SSA Provisions That Impact Fund Withholding

To effectively challenge a fund hold, you must understand the specific provisions in the Stripe Services Agreement (SSA) that Stripe relies upon. The most relevant sections include:

• Section 6.1(b) – Allows Stripe to terminate the agreement or close accounts “at any time for any or no reason”
• Section 6.2(i) – Permits suspension when Stripe believes use of services “presents an unacceptable level of credit risk”
• Section 5.4 (Stripe Payments Terms) – Authorizes Stripe to “change the Payout Schedule or suspend payouts” based on risk assessment
• Section 5.6(b) (Stripe Payments Terms) – Permits Stripe to delay or cancel payouts of settlement funds
• Section 5.3 (Stripe Payments Terms) – Makes account holders responsible for disputes, refunds, and reversals

While these provisions grant Stripe significant discretion, they do not authorize indefinite fund withholding without justification. Moreover, all contracts—including the SSA—contain an implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing that limits how discretionary powers can be exercised.

The Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing

A central legal principle in challenging Stripe’s practices is the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, which exists in every contract under California law (which governs the SSA per Section 13.1). This covenant requires parties to act fairly and in good faith when performing contractual obligations.

Even when a contract grants broad discretion, the implied covenant prevents a party from exercising that discretion in a manner that frustrates the other party’s reasonable expectations or deprives them of the benefits of the agreement. This principle provides a powerful legal basis for challenging unreasonable fund withholding.

Preparing Your Legal Strategy: The Demand Letter Plus Arbitration Approach

Why a Simple Demand Letter Often Fails

Many merchants make the mistake of sending a basic demand letter requesting the release of their funds. While this approach occasionally works, I’ve found that Stripe typically responds with boilerplate language citing the SSA provisions mentioned above, or simply delays responding altogether.

The key insight I’ve gained through numerous cases is that Stripe responds much more seriously to the combination of a formal demand letter plus a draft arbitration demand. This combination signals both the seriousness of your intent and your understanding of the dispute resolution process required by the SSA.

The Critical Importance of the 30-Day Notice Requirement

Before filing for arbitration, merchants must satisfy the notice requirement specified in Section 13.3(a) of the SSA, which states:

“A party must notify the other party of its intent to commence arbitration prior to commencing arbitration. The notice must specify the date on which the arbitration demand is intended to be filed, which must be at least 30 days after the date of the notice.”

Failing to provide this 30-day notice can result in procedural dismissal of your arbitration claim, forcing you to restart the process. Your demand letter should explicitly state that it serves as your 30-day notice pursuant to Section 13.3(a) of the SSA.

Crafting an Effective Demand Letter

An effective demand letter should include:

1. Clear identification of your Stripe account details and the amount being withheld
2. Specific timeline of events including account termination date and any promised release dates
3. Reference to relevant SSA provisions that Stripe may have breached
4. Statement that the letter serves as your 30-day notice per Section 13.3(a)
5. Clear demand for the release of funds by a specific date
6. Statement that you will proceed with the attached arbitration demand if the issue is not resolved
7. Citation of specific legal claims (breach of contract, conversion, etc.)

Preparing a Draft Arbitration Demand

Your draft arbitration demand should be a professionally formatted document that follows the American Arbitration Association (AAA) requirements. It should include:

1. Identifying information for all parties
2. Statement that arbitration is required by Section 13.2 of the SSA
3. Comprehensive statement of claims, including:
   • Breach of contract
   • Conversion (wrongful retention of funds)
   • Breach of implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing
   • Violation of California Business & Professions Code § 17200 (unfair business practices)
4. Detailed factual background
5. Clear statement of the relief sought

 

Understanding the Arbitration Process: What Merchants Need to Know

Why Arbitration, Not Litigation: Section 13.2 of the SSA

Many merchants mistakenly believe they can file a lawsuit against Stripe in court. However, Section 13.2 of the SSA contains a binding arbitration clause:

“All disputes, claims and controversies, whether based on past, present or future events, arising out of or relating to… the breach, termination, enforcement, interpretation or validity of any provision of this Agreement… will be determined by binding arbitration in San Francisco, California before a single arbitrator.”

This means that with very limited exceptions (primarily relating to intellectual property disputes), all claims against Stripe must be brought through arbitration rather than court litigation.

The Cost Difference: Arbitration vs. Court Filing

A significant disadvantage of arbitration is the higher cost compared to court filing:

• Court Filing Fee: Approximately $435 to file in federal court
• AAA Filing Fee: Typically around $1,700-$2,900 for commercial disputes, depending on claim size
• Additional Arbitration Costs: Arbitrator fees ($1,500-$2,500 per day), hearing room rental, etc.

This cost differential can create a significant barrier for merchants with smaller claims. However, the AAA does offer a more streamlined process for claims under $25,000, as I’ll discuss below.

Expedited Process for Claims Under $25,000

If your claim is for less than $25,000, you may be eligible for the AAA’s Expedited Procedures, which are referenced in Section 13.2(b) of the SSA:

“Where no party’s claim exceeds $25,000 (excluding interest, attorneys’ fees and arbitration fees and costs), and in other cases where the parties agree, Section E-6 of the Expedited Procedures of the American Arbitration Association’s Commercial Arbitration Rules will apply.”

These expedited procedures typically involve:

• Decision based primarily on documents rather than in-person hearings
• A more streamlined process with shorter timelines
• Lower overall costs

Filing Your Arbitration Demand with the AAA

To file your arbitration demand with the AAA, you’ll need to:

1. Complete the AAA Commercial Arbitration Rules Demand for Arbitration form
2. Include a copy of the arbitration clause from the SSA
3. Pay the appropriate filing fee
4. Submit all documents to the AAA’s case filing services

The AAA case filing can be done online through the AAA WebFile system, or documents can be sent to:

American Arbitration Association
Case Filing Services
1101 Laurel Oak Road, Suite 100
Voorhees, NJ 08043

For Stripe’s address (required on the form), use:

Stripe, Inc.
354 Oyster Point Boulevard
South San Francisco, CA 94080

Legal Claims That Have Proven Effective in Stripe Disputes

Breach of Contract

The most straightforward claim is that Stripe has breached the SSA by:

• Failing to process promised payment reversals within stated timeframes
• Withholding funds for an unreasonable period without contractual authority
• Failing to provide clear criteria or timeline for the release of held funds

While Stripe will argue that the SSA gives them broad discretion, courts and arbitrators have recognized limits to contractual discretion, particularly when a party’s actions appear arbitrary or without reasonable justification.

Conversion (Wrongful Retention of Funds)

Conversion is a legal claim alleging that Stripe has wrongfully exercised dominion over your property (the withheld funds). Elements of this claim include:

• Your right to immediate possession of the funds
• Stripe’s wrongful retention of the funds beyond any reasonable period necessary for risk management
• Damages resulting from being deprived of your funds

The conversion claim is particularly powerful because it can potentially lead to punitive damages in egregious cases.

Breach of Implied Covenant of Good Faith and Fair Dealing

As discussed earlier, this claim focuses on Stripe’s obligation to exercise its contractual discretion in good faith. Specific breaches might include:

• Arbitrarily designating your account as high risk without substantial justification
• Implementing policies designed to frustrate merchants’ ability to recover withheld funds
• Using shifting or arbitrary standards to justify continued fund withholding

Violation of California Business & Professions Code § 17200

California’s Unfair Competition Law (Business & Professions Code § 17200) prohibits unfair, fraudulent, and unlawful business practices. This broad statute can capture various aspects of Stripe’s conduct, including:

• Systematically withholding merchant funds without clear contractual authority
• Making false representations regarding the timeline for processing payments or releases
• Profiting from interest earned on improperly withheld merchant funds

This claim is particularly valuable because it allows for restitution of ill-gotten gains, which may include interest earned on improperly withheld funds.

Case Studies: What Works and What Doesn’t

Case Study 1: Simple Inquiry vs. Legal Demand Letter

Approach: Merchant sent multiple requests through standard support channels asking for release of $45,000 in withheld funds.
Result: After three months, Stripe extended the holding period for another 90 days without clear justification.

Revised Approach: Merchant sent formal demand letter with draft arbitration demand through certified mail to Stripe’s legal department.
Result: Within two weeks, Stripe provided a specific release date for the full amount.

Case Study 2: Addressing the “High Risk” Designation

Approach: E-commerce merchant with $120,000 in held funds attempted to dispute Stripe’s “high risk” designation through emails and support tickets.
Result: No substantive response for over 60 days.

Revised Approach: Demand letter specifically challenging the risk designation and providing evidence of low historical dispute rates, combined with arbitration demand draft.
Result: Stripe agreed to release funds in installments over 30 days and provided specific criteria for risk reassessment.

Case Study 3: The Impact of the 30-Day Notice Requirement

Approach: Merchant immediately filed arbitration without providing the 30-day notice required by Section 13.3(a).
Result: Procedural complications delayed the process by months, with Stripe arguing the arbitration was improperly initiated.

Revised Approach: New demand letter explicitly serving as 30-day notice, followed by properly timed arbitration filing.
Result: Stripe engaged in settlement discussions during the 30-day period, ultimately resulting in full fund release.

Step-by-Step Action Plan for Merchants with Held Funds

Step 1: Document and Gather Evidence

Before taking legal action, gather all relevant documentation:

• Complete account history and transaction records
• All communications with Stripe regarding your account and fund withholding
• Evidence of your compliance with Stripe’s policies (low dispute rates, etc.)
• Documentation of damages caused by the fund withholding

Step 2: Draft and Send Your Demand Letter with Arbitration Draft

Prepare a comprehensive demand letter that:

• Clearly identifies your account and the amount being withheld
• References specific SSA provisions that Stripe may have breached
• States explicitly that it serves as your 30-day notice per Section 13.3(a)
• Includes a draft arbitration demand
• Sets a specific deadline for response (typically 10-14 days)

Send this package via certified mail with return receipt to:

Stripe, Inc.
Legal Department
354 Oyster Point Boulevard
South San Francisco, CA 94080

Also email a copy to complaints@stripe.com to ensure multiple delivery channels.

Step 3: Prepare for Arbitration During the 30-Day Notice Period

If Stripe doesn’t respond satisfactorily, use the 30-day notice period to:

• Finalize your arbitration demand
• Prepare supporting documentation
• Arrange for payment of AAA filing fees
• Consider consulting with an attorney if you haven’t already

Step 4: File for Arbitration if Necessary

If the 30-day period elapses without resolution:

• Submit your arbitration demand to the AAA with the required filing fee
• Provide copies of all submissions to Stripe
• Be prepared for preliminary administrative conferences and procedural matters

Step 5: Consider Settlement Opportunities Throughout the Process

Many Stripe disputes settle before reaching an arbitration hearing. Remain open to reasonable settlement offers while continuing to assert your rights to your withheld funds.

Understanding the AAA Fee Structure and Process

Filing and Administrative Fees

The American Arbitration Association (AAA) uses a tiered fee structure based on the claim amount. As of 2024, the standard filing fees for commercial disputes are:

• Claims under $75,000: Initial filing fee of $925, final fee of $800
• Claims $75,000 to $150,000: Initial filing fee of $1,925, final fee of $1,375
• Claims $150,000 to $300,000: Initial filing fee of $2,900, final fee of $2,200

The AAA also offers a “flexible fee schedule” that allows for lower initial filing fees but higher overall costs. Under this schedule, the fees are paid in three installments rather than two.

Arbitrator Compensation

In addition to the AAA’s administrative fees, parties must pay for the arbitrator’s time. Arbitrator rates typically range from $1,500 to $2,500 per day, with many arbitrators charging hourly rates of $300-$600. These fees are generally split between the parties unless the arbitrator decides otherwise in the final award.

Expedited Procedures for Claims Under $25,000

For claims under $25,000, the AAA’s Expedited Procedures apply. Key features include:

• Cases are generally decided based on document submissions only, without an in-person hearing (unless the arbitrator determines a hearing is necessary)
• The entire process is typically completed within 60-90 days
• A single arbitrator is appointed by the AAA
• The proceedings are more streamlined, with fewer formal procedures

These expedited procedures can significantly reduce both time and cost, making them an attractive option for smaller claims against Stripe.

Conclusion: Turning Legal Knowledge Into Fund Recovery

When Stripe holds your funds, you’re not without recourse. By understanding the legal framework, preparing proper documentation, and following the procedures outlined in this guide, you can significantly increase your chances of recovering withheld funds.

Remember these key takeaways:

1. A demand letter alone is rarely sufficient—combine it with a draft arbitration demand
2. Always provide the 30-day notice required by Section 13.3(a) of the SSA
3. Understand the cost implications of arbitration and consider expedited procedures for smaller claims
4. Document everything thoroughly, from your transaction history to all communications with Stripe
5. Frame your legal claims properly, focusing on breach of contract, conversion, and the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing

While dealing with withheld funds is undoubtedly stressful, merchants who approach the situation with legal precision and strategic patience often achieve positive outcomes. The strategies outlined in this guide have helped recover millions in withheld funds for merchants across various industries.

If you’re facing a Stripe fund hold issue, I encourage you to take action today using the templates and approaches outlined above. Your business deserves access to its rightful funds, and with the right legal approach, you can overcome Stripe’s withholding practices.

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Stripe Fund Holds

How long can Stripe legally hold my funds?

The Stripe Services Agreement (SSA) doesn’t specify a maximum time limit for fund holds, which creates significant ambiguity. Section 5.4 of the Stripe Payments Terms states that “Stripe may change the Payout Schedule or suspend payouts to your Bank Account based on Stripe’s assessment of risk.”

While Stripe often claims they can hold funds for 90-180 days to cover potential chargebacks, indefinite holds likely exceed what’s reasonable under contract law principles. The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing (which exists in every contract under California law) requires Stripe to exercise its discretion reasonably.

For card payments, the maximum chargeback period is typically 120 days after the transaction date for most card networks. This is often used as justification for holding funds for this duration. However, if your business has a clean history with minimal chargebacks, holding funds beyond this period becomes increasingly difficult to justify legally.

In my experience representing merchants, funds held beyond 180 days without specific evidence of ongoing risk can be effectively challenged through the legal process outlined in this guide.

Can Stripe legally close my account without warning?

Yes, according to Section 6.1(b) of the SSA, Stripe may “terminate this Agreement (or any part) or close your Stripe Account at any time for any or no reason by notifying you.” This broad discretion is enforceable under contract law, provided Stripe gives you notice of the termination.

However, the mere right to terminate doesn’t automatically grant Stripe the right to indefinitely withhold your funds. These are separate issues. While Stripe can close your account with minimal justification, their handling of your funds post-termination must still satisfy good faith standards and reasonable commercial practices.

If Stripe closes your account while you have substantial funds in your balance, you should immediately document the situation and begin preparing your demand letter, even if they promise to release funds within a specific timeframe.

What’s the difference between funds held in “reserve” versus funds in a terminated account?

This is an important distinction that affects your legal approach. A reserve is a portion of your funds Stripe temporarily holds while your account remains active. Section 5.6(c) of the Stripe Payments Terms covers reserves, allowing Stripe to “establish any reserve amount and minimum balance requirement” they determine necessary.

In contrast, when your account is terminated, the entire remaining balance becomes unavailable for withdrawal. This situation is governed by different provisions, primarily Sections 6.1 and 6.2 regarding termination and suspension.

For reserves, you’ll generally want to negotiate the percentage and duration through standard support channels before escalating to legal action. For terminated accounts with withheld funds, the demand letter plus arbitration approach outlined in this guide is typically necessary.

How do I prove my business isn’t actually “high risk” as Stripe claims?

Compile comprehensive evidence including:

1. Complete transaction history showing your actual dispute/chargeback rate (ideally below 0.75%, which is considered the industry standard)
2. Documentation of your order fulfillment processes and timelines
3. Customer satisfaction metrics and reviews
4. Compliance with industry standards or regulations
5. Evidence that you disclosed your full business model during the onboarding process
6. Comparisons to standard risk metrics in your industry

Include this evidence with your demand letter to directly challenge Stripe’s risk determination. Many merchants discover that Stripe’s “high risk” designation lacks specific evidence or metrics, making it vulnerable to challenge when confronted with well-documented counterevidence.

In arbitration proceedings, this evidence becomes crucial for challenging Stripe’s primary defense (risk justification) for withholding funds. Arbitrators typically respond favorably to concrete metrics that contradict vague risk assertions.

What specific damages can I claim beyond my withheld funds?

In addition to the principal amount withheld, you may potentially claim:

1. Interest on withheld funds – Calculated at the legal rate (typically 10% per annum in California for contract claims)
2. Consequential damages – Documented business losses directly resulting from the fund withholding, such as:
   • Inability to fulfill orders or maintain inventory
   • Loss of vendors or suppliers due to payment failures
   • Costs of emergency financing obtained to cover the shortfall
   • Lost profits from business interruption
3. Costs of arbitration – Including filing fees and arbitrator compensation
4. Attorney’s fees – If provided for by statute or the arbitrator’s discretion
5. Reputational damages – Though harder to quantify, significant documented harm to your business reputation

Ensure all claimed damages are thoroughly documented. Speculative or undocumented damages will likely be rejected by the arbitrator.

Can I sue Stripe in small claims court instead of arbitration?

Generally, no. Section 13.2 of the SSA requires binding arbitration for nearly all disputes. While some states have laws limiting the enforceability of arbitration clauses in certain contexts, courts have typically upheld Stripe’s arbitration provision.

The only significant exception in the SSA is for disputes “principally related to either party’s IP Rights,” which can be litigated in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California.

There’s also a class action waiver in Section 13.6, meaning you cannot participate in a class action lawsuit against Stripe regarding fund withholding issues.

Your most viable path is through the arbitration process specified in the SSA, following the procedures outlined in this guide.

How much does arbitration with Stripe typically cost?

The total cost varies based on your claim amount and case complexity, but typically includes:

1. AAA Filing Fees:
   • Claims under $75,000: Initial filing fee of $925, final fee of $800
   • Claims $75,000 to $150,000: Initial filing fee of $1,925, final fee of $1,375
   • Claims $150,000 to $300,000: Initial filing fee of $2,900, final fee of $2,200
2. Arbitrator Compensation:
   • Typically $300-$600 per hour or $1,500-$2,500 per day
   • For a simple case decided on documents only: $3,000-$5,000
   • For cases requiring hearings: $10,000+ depending on complexity and duration
3. Additional Costs:
   • Hearing room rental (if applicable): $500-$1,000 per day
   • Administrative expenses: Varies
   • Attorney’s fees (if represented): Typically $5,000-$20,000 for straightforward cases

For claims under $25,000, consider requesting the expedited procedures under Section E-6 of the AAA Commercial Rules, which can substantially reduce both time and cost by resolving the dispute based on document submissions without a hearing.

Many merchants find that simply filing the arbitration demand is enough to prompt settlement discussions, potentially avoiding most of these costs.

How long does the arbitration process typically take?

The timeline varies significantly based on claim size, complexity, and the specific arbitrator assigned:

1. Expedited Procedures (claims under $25,000):
   • Typically 60-90 days from filing to final award
   • No hearing unless the arbitrator determines it’s necessary
   • Streamlined document exchange and limited discovery
2. Standard Procedures (larger claims):
   • Preliminary hearing: 30-45 days after arbitrator appointment
   • Discovery phase: 60-120 days
   • Evidentiary hearing: Scheduled 30-60 days after discovery closes
   • Final award: Typically issued within 30 days after hearing
   • Total timeline: 6-12 months from filing to resolution

However, in my experience with Stripe cases, approximately 70% settle after arbitration is filed but before the evidentiary hearing occurs. The mere act of filing often prompts Stripe to engage in meaningful settlement discussions, potentially shortening the timeline to 2-4 months.

Keep in mind that the 30-day notice period required by Section 13.3(a) adds to this timeline, but also creates an opportunity for early resolution.

Will Stripe blacklist me from other payment processors if I pursue arbitration?

This is a common concern, but I’ve found no evidence that Stripe shares information about merchants who pursue legal action with other payment processors. Payment processors make their own risk determinations based on:

1. Your credit history and business financials
2. Your industry and business model
3. Information from card networks about your chargeback history

The payment processing industry is competitive, and many alternatives exist:

• Traditional merchant accounts through banks
• Other payment service providers (PayPal, Square, etc.)
• High-risk merchant account specialists

In my experience representing dozens of merchants in Stripe disputes, none have reported difficulty obtaining services from other providers after challenging Stripe through arbitration. In fact, many successful merchants maintain accounts with multiple processors simultaneously as a risk management strategy.

Can I immediately file for arbitration, or must I exhaust Stripe’s internal appeals process first?

The SSA doesn’t require you to exhaust internal appeals before initiating arbitration. However, Section 13.3(a) does require you to provide 30 days’ notice before filing your arbitration demand.

From a practical standpoint, I recommend:

1. First, attempt to resolve the issue through standard support channels
2. If unsuccessful after 2-3 weeks, send your formal demand letter serving as your 30-day notice
3. Use the 30-day notice period to continue negotiating while preparing for arbitration
4. File for arbitration if the issue remains unresolved after the notice period

This approach satisfies both legal requirements and practical considerations. The demand letter often elevates your issue to more senior staff who have greater authority to resolve your situation without proceeding to formal arbitration.

What are Stripe’s typical defenses in arbitration, and how do I counter them?

Stripe typically relies on several standard defenses, each requiring specific counterarguments:

1. “High Risk” Defense: Stripe claims withholding was justified by elevated risk factors.
   • Counter: Provide documented chargeback rates, transaction history, and industry comparisons proving your business operates within normal risk parameters.
2. “Contractual Discretion” Defense: Stripe argues the SSA grants them broad discretion regarding fund withholding.
   • Counter: Emphasize the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, which limits how discretion can be exercised, citing California precedent.
3. “Ongoing Chargeback Liability” Defense: Stripe claims funds must be held to cover potential future chargebacks.
   • Counter: Present evidence that sufficient time has passed beyond reasonable chargeback windows (typically 120 days), making continued withholding unnecessary.
4. “Terms of Service Violation” Defense: Stripe alleges your business violated their acceptable use policies.
   • Counter: Demonstrate full disclosure of your business model during onboarding and compliance with all policies, requesting specific evidence of alleged violations.
5. “Procedural” Defenses: Stripe may claim improper notice or jurisdictional issues.
   • Counter: Meticulously document your compliance with all procedural requirements in the SSA, particularly the 30-day notice requirement.

The most effective preparation involves anticipating these defenses and preemptively addressing them in your initial arbitration demand with specific evidence and legal arguments.

Can I recover the interest Stripe earned on my withheld funds?

Yes, this is potentially recoverable under several legal theories:

1. Restitution under California Business & Professions Code § 17200: This allows recovery of profits from unfair business practices, which would include interest earned on improperly withheld funds.
2. Conversion damages: When a party wrongfully retains another’s property, damages can include the benefits derived from that property during the retention period.
3. Prejudgment interest: California Civil Code § 3287(a) allows recovery of interest from the day the right to recover the funds arose.

To maximize your chance of recovering this interest:

• Explicitly include it in your demand letter and arbitration demand
• Calculate the approximate interest earned (using average money market rates for the period)
• Argue that allowing Stripe to keep this interest would reward them for improper withholding

While arbitrators don’t always award interest, the legal basis for such claims is sound, and including this demand strengthens your overall position.

What happens if Stripe releases my funds during the arbitration process?

If Stripe releases your funds after arbitration has commenced but before a final award, several scenarios may unfold:

1. Partial settlement: You may agree to dismiss the arbitration in exchange for the fund release, potentially negotiating for coverage of your filing fees and costs.
2. Continued proceedings for remaining damages: You can continue the arbitration to pursue consequential damages, interest, attorney’s fees, and costs even after the principal funds are released.
3. Mootness argument: Stripe may argue the dispute is now moot and should be dismissed, but you can counter that additional damages remain unaddressed.

I typically advise clients to:

• Document exactly when funds were released compared to when they should have been
• Calculate specific additional damages beyond the principal amount
• Consider whether a formal settlement agreement would be more advantageous than simply accepting the funds and dismissing the arbitration

This situation actually occurs frequently, as Stripe often releases funds after arbitration is filed but before significant proceedings take place—effectively conceding the principal claim while attempting to avoid additional liability.

Should I hire an attorney for my Stripe arbitration?

While you can represent yourself (pro se) in arbitration proceedings, I recommend at least consulting with an attorney experienced in payment processor disputes for these reasons:

1. Complex legal landscape: The intersection of contract law, financial regulations, and arbitration procedure creates significant complexity.
2. Strategic positioning: Attorneys experienced with Stripe disputes know which arguments and evidence most effectively prompt settlements.
3. Procedural expertise: AAA arbitration involves specific rules and procedures that can be challenging for non-attorneys to navigate.
4. Negotiation leverage: Stripe’s legal team typically takes represented claimants more seriously in settlement discussions.

For smaller claims (under $25,000), you might consider:

• An initial consultation to help prepare your demand letter and arbitration demand
• Proceeding pro se with the expedited document-only procedures
• Further consultation only if the case proceeds to more complex stages

For larger claims, full representation is typically justified by the amount at stake and complexity involved. Many attorneys handling these matters will work on contingency or hybrid fee arrangements for substantial claims.

Are there specific types of businesses that face higher risk of Stripe fund holds?

Yes, certain business categories face elevated scrutiny and higher risk of fund holds:

1. High-ticket item sellers: Businesses selling expensive products (typically $500+) face heightened risk assessment due to higher average transaction values.
2. Subscription services: Particularly those with longer fulfillment periods or future delivery models.
3. Dropshipping businesses: Due to longer fulfillment timelines and less direct inventory control.
4. Digital products/services: Particularly those in competitive niches with higher historical dispute rates.
5. Newly established businesses: Those with limited processing history or rapid growth.
6. Businesses in Stripe’s “restricted” categories: Those listed in Stripe’s Restricted Businesses list, even if conditionally permitted.

If your business falls into these categories, consider these proactive measures:

• Maintain detailed documentation of all customer communications
• Implement clear refund policies and responsive customer service
• Consider using multiple payment processors to diversify risk
• Build a processing history gradually rather than scaling rapidly
• Maintain a reserve of capital outside Stripe to manage potential holds

These preventative steps won’t guarantee immunity from holds, but they can significantly strengthen your position if a hold occurs.

What’s the difference between a Stripe account “closure” and “suspension”?

These terms have distinct implications under the SSA:

Account Closure (Section 6.1):

• Permanent termination of your relationship with Stripe
• Typically requires you to find a new payment processor
• Funds may be held for a specified period (often 90-180 days) to cover potential chargebacks
• After the hold period, remaining funds should be released to your bank account

Account Suspension (Section 6.2):

• Temporary pause in services
• May allow for reinstatement if specified issues are resolved
• Does not necessarily trigger automatic fund release timelines
• Often preceded by requests for additional information or documentation

The legal approach differs for each situation:

• For closures, focus on challenging unreasonable hold periods beyond those needed for legitimate risk management
• For suspensions, address the specific issues Stripe has identified while simultaneously asserting your right to reasonable fund access

From a strategic perspective, account suspensions sometimes offer more negotiation room for reinstatement, while closures typically focus the dispute solely on fund release timelines.

Can Stripe legally process refunds from my withheld funds without my permission?

Section 5.3 of the Stripe Payments Terms makes merchants responsible “for the full amount of all Disputes, Refunds and Reversals regardless of the reason or timing.” Section 5.4 further permits Stripe to “deduct, recoup, or setoff Refunds, adjustments, fees, and other amounts you owe us” from your Stripe account balance.

However, these provisions should reasonably apply only to:

1. Customer-initiated refund requests
2. Legitimate chargebacks following proper dispute procedures
3. Fees and adjustments directly related to your account activity

Stripe should not proactively process mass refunds without reasonable justification. If Stripe has issued unauthorized refunds from your balance, document:

• Which transactions were refunded
• Whether customers had actually requested these refunds
• Any communication from Stripe about their refund decisions

This documentation strengthens claims that Stripe has exceeded its contractual authority and potentially breached the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing by issuing refunds without proper basis.

What if my withheld funds exceed the AAA filing threshold for expedited proceedings?

If your withheld amount exceeds $25,000 (the threshold for expedited proceedings under Section E-6 of the AAA Rules), consider these strategic options:

1. Claim Bifurcation: Potentially file for only part of your total claim to stay under the expedited threshold, reserving the right to pursue the remainder separately.
2. Request Expedited Treatment: Even for larger claims, parties can jointly request expedited procedures, or you can request them unilaterally (though Stripe would need to agree).
3. Document-Only Procedure: For claims between $25,000-$100,000, request a documents-only procedure under R-30(b) of the AAA Commercial Rules to reduce costs.
4. Selective Fee Structure: The AAA offers both Standard and Flexible Fee Schedules; analyze which is more advantageous for your claim size and expected timeline.

Many merchants find that even with higher filing costs for larger claims, the increased leverage often leads to faster settlement discussions, potentially justifying the additional upfront expense.

 

Sergei Tokmakov is the attorney behind Terms.Law, representing e-commerce merchants in disputes with payment processors.