No, the issue is NOT resolved by taking the content down. They infringed your copyright for 8 months. Removal stops future infringement but doesn't address past damages.
Your options for the two registered works:
- Statutory damages: $750-$30,000 per work infringed (up to $150,000 per work if willful). Since you have registrations, you can elect statutory damages, which means you don't need to prove actual losses.
- Actual damages + profits: What you lost (reasonable licensing fee) plus any profits they made attributable to the music use.
- Attorney fees: Available for registered works, which makes contingency representation feasible.
For the unregistered work, you can still claim actual damages but not statutory damages or attorney fees. This is why registration matters — it's $65 and the difference between a strong case and a weak one.
Next step: have an entertainment attorney send a demand for licensing fees. Many of these cases settle for $5K-$15K per song used commercially.