No Deal is Better Than a Bad Deal
Walking away from an NDA isn't failure - it's protecting yourself. Some agreements are so one-sided, problematic, or indicative of bad faith that signing would be a mistake regardless of the business opportunity. Here's how to recognize those situations.
Absolute Red Lines (Never Sign)
These terms are so problematic that no legitimate business relationship justifies accepting them. If you see these and they refuse to remove them, walk away.
Perpetual Term with No Exit
Binds you forever with no way out. You'd be liable for the rest of your life - and potentially your estate after death.
Hidden Non-Compete Agreement
Restricts you from working in your own industry. This isn't an NDA - it's a career-limiting agreement in disguise.
Unilateral Modification Rights
They can change the terms at any time without your consent. You'd be agreeing to terms that don't exist yet.
Unreasonable Liquidated Damages
Pre-set damages grossly disproportionate to any realistic harm. Designed to intimidate and create leverage.
Unlimited Third-Party Disclosure
They can share your confidential information with anyone without restriction. Defeats the entire purpose of an NDA.
Broad IP Assignment
Transfers your intellectual property rights just by sharing ideas. You could lose ownership of your own work.
Warning Signs of Bad Actors
Beyond the document itself, certain behaviors indicate you may be dealing with someone who will cause problems.
-
Extreme Time Pressure
"Sign this by end of day or the deal is off." Legitimate businesses understand that legal documents require review. Artificial urgency is a manipulation tactic.
-
Refusal to Negotiate Anything
"This is our standard form. We can't change a single word." While some companies have rigid policies, complete inflexibility on clearly problematic terms is a red flag.
-
Vague or Evasive About Business Purpose
Can't clearly explain why they need an NDA or what information will be shared. Legitimate business discussions have clear purposes.
-
Reluctance to Identify Themselves
Won't provide clear company information, won't put the agreement on letterhead, or uses personal email for business. Know who you're contracting with.
-
Aggressive or Threatening Response to Questions
Becomes hostile when you ask clarifying questions or request changes. If they're difficult before you sign, imagine how they'll be after.
-
Dramatically Imbalanced Mutual NDA
Claims it's "mutual" but only you have real obligations. A true mutual NDA treats both parties equally.
Decision Guide: Negotiate vs. Walk Away
Use this framework to decide whether to continue negotiating or walk away.
Worth Negotiating
- One or two problematic clauses in an otherwise standard NDA
- They seem open to discussing your concerns
- The business opportunity is significant
- Issues are common ones with known fixes
- They provide reasonable explanations for their requirements
Proceed with Caution
- Multiple concerning clauses but no absolute red lines
- They negotiate but slowly or reluctantly
- Opportunity value is uncertain
- You've had to push back multiple times
- Their explanations are unsatisfying
Walk Away
- Any of the absolute red lines above
- Multiple warning signs of bad actors
- They refuse to discuss any changes
- The deal value doesn't justify the risk
- Your gut tells you something is wrong
Interactive Walk-Away Assessment
Check any items that apply to your situation. The more boxes checked, the stronger the case for walking away.
Check all that apply to your NDA:
0 Warning Signs
So far so good. Check any items that apply to see your risk assessment.
How to Decline Professionally
Walking away doesn't mean burning bridges. Here are professional ways to decline that preserve relationships for future opportunities.
Polite but Firm Decline FIRM
Hi [Name], Thank you for the opportunity to discuss [project/partnership]. After careful review of the NDA, I've determined that I'm unable to proceed under the current terms. Specifically, [brief mention of key concerns - e.g., "the perpetual confidentiality term" or "the scope of the intellectual property provisions"] present risks that I'm not comfortable accepting. I appreciate your understanding and wish you success with the project. Best regards, [Your Name]
Leave Door Open SOFT
Hi [Name], Thank you for sending over the NDA. After reviewing it carefully, I have concerns about several provisions that I'm not comfortable signing in their current form. I understand you may have policies that limit your flexibility on these terms. If your position changes, or if you're able to use a more standard mutual NDA in the future, I'd be happy to revisit the conversation. I appreciate the opportunity and hope we can work together down the road. Best regards, [Your Name]
Counter with Your Own NDA BRIDGE
Hi [Name], Thank you for sending over your NDA. I've reviewed it and have concerns about several provisions that create risk I'm not comfortable accepting. Rather than mark up your agreement, I've attached our standard mutual NDA which provides equivalent protection for both parties in a more balanced format. This is the agreement I use for all business discussions and I'm confident it addresses your confidentiality needs while being fair to both sides. Would you be open to proceeding with this alternative? I'm happy to discuss any specific concerns you may have. Best regards, [Your Name]
Related Resources
Still Not Sure? Get Expert Advice
Have an attorney review your specific situation and provide personalized guidance.
Consult an Attorney ($150+)