📋 Overview

You've received a notice claiming you violated your lease. This is a serious matter, but many lease violation claims are false, exaggerated, or procedurally defective. This guide will help you understand the notice, evaluate whether it's valid, and respond effectively to protect your tenancy.

Right to Cure

For most lease violations, you have the right to fix ("cure") the problem within 3 days. If you cure, the landlord cannot proceed with eviction.

Time-Sensitive

If the notice gives you a cure period, act quickly. Document everything you do to cure the alleged violation.

Many Are Pretextual

Some landlords use alleged violations to try to evict tenants they want out. Retaliatory enforcement is illegal.

Common Lease Violation Claims

  • Unauthorized occupants - People living in unit not on lease
  • Pet violations - Pets not allowed or not approved
  • Noise complaints - Disturbing other tenants or neighbors
  • Improper use - Running business, short-term rentals
  • Cleanliness/hoarding - Health or safety concerns
  • Property damage - Damage beyond normal wear
  • Parking violations - Using unauthorized spaces or excessive vehicles
  • Alterations - Unauthorized changes to unit
$450
Professional Response to Lease Violation

Notice review, defense identification, formal response letter, and cure documentation guidance.

Schedule Review

🔍 Evaluate the Notice

Carefully review the notice for accuracy and legal defects. Many notices fail to meet legal requirements.

Types of Lease Violation Notices

Notice Type Cure Right? Risk Level
3-Day Notice to Cure or Quit YES - Fix within 3 days MODERATE
3-Day Notice to Quit (incurable) NO - Must vacate HIGH
Warning letter (informal) N/A - Not legal notice LOW
Notice citing multiple violations Depends on violations MODERATE-HIGH

📄 Notice Requirements

  • ✓ Specifically describes the alleged violation
  • ✓ Cites the lease provision violated
  • ✓ States the cure period (if curable)
  • ✓ Properly served (CCP 1162)

⚖ Validity Check

  • ✓ Does the alleged violation actually exist?
  • ✓ Is there a lease term covering this?
  • ✓ Has landlord enforced this before?
  • ✓ Is this retaliation for protected activity?

Curable vs. Incurable Violations

Most lease violations are "curable" - you can fix them to avoid eviction. However, some serious violations are considered "incurable": illegal activity, serious nuisance, assault on other tenants, or repeated violations of the same type. For incurable violations, the landlord can demand you vacate without a chance to cure.

🛡 Your Defenses

You have multiple potential defenses to lease violation claims. Identify which apply to your situation.

No Violation Occurred

The most straightforward defense: the alleged violation simply didn't happen. The landlord has the burden of proving a violation occurred.

When to use: The claim is false, based on mistaken identity, or exaggerated beyond what actually occurred.

No Lease Provision

A landlord can only enforce rules actually contained in the lease. If the lease doesn't prohibit the alleged conduct, there's no violation.

When to use: Review your lease - if there's no provision covering the alleged conduct, the landlord cannot enforce it.

Violation Was Cured

If you received a cure-or-quit notice and fixed the problem within the time allowed, the notice is satisfied and eviction cannot proceed.

When to use: You resolved the issue (removed the pet, reduced noise, addressed the occupant issue, etc.) within the cure period.

Waiver by Landlord

If the landlord knew about the condition and accepted rent without objection, they may have waived the right to enforce. Also applies if they previously permitted the conduct.

When to use: Landlord knew about the pet/occupant/condition for months but only now is complaining.

Selective Enforcement

If the landlord is enforcing rules against you but not other tenants with the same conduct, this may indicate discrimination or retaliation.

When to use: Other tenants have pets/guests/etc. but aren't being cited.

Retaliatory Enforcement

Under Civil Code 1942.5, landlords cannot enforce lease violations in retaliation for tenant exercising legal rights (complaining about repairs, organizing, etc.).

When to use: The notice came shortly after you complained about habitability, reported code violations, or exercised tenant rights.

Weak Defenses to Avoid

  • "Other buildings allow this" - Your lease controls, not other properties
  • "I didn't know about the rule" - Ignorance generally not a defense
  • "The pet is an emotional support animal" - May work, but requires proper documentation
  • "It only happened once" - Single violation can still be grounds if serious

⚖ Response Options

Based on your situation, choose the best response strategy.

Cure the Violation

If the violation exists and can be fixed, cure it within the notice period. Document your cure with photos, receipts, and written confirmation.

  • Ends the matter completely
  • Preserves your tenancy
  • Document everything

Dispute the Claim

If the allegation is false or you have valid defenses, respond in writing disputing the violation and explaining your position.

  • Creates written record
  • Preserves defenses
  • May deter eviction action

Request Meeting

Ask to meet with the landlord to discuss the situation. Many issues can be resolved through communication.

  • May clarify misunderstanding
  • Shows good faith
  • Could lead to resolution

Prepare for Defense

If you believe the landlord will proceed despite your response, begin preparing evidence and witnesses for potential court case.

  • Gather documentation
  • Identify witnesses
  • Consult attorney

Timeline: Lease Violation Eviction

Understanding the timeline helps you plan your response

3-Day cure period (if curable) Days 1-3
Landlord files unlawful detainer Day 4+
Tenant answer due (after service) 5 court days
Trial date (after answer) 20+ days
MINIMUM TIME TO LOCKOUT 5-8 weeks

Reasonable Accommodation for Disability

If you have a disability, you may be entitled to a reasonable accommodation that excuses the alleged violation. For example, an assistance animal is allowed even if the lease prohibits pets. This requires documentation from a healthcare provider.

📝 Sample Responses

Copy and customize these response templates for your situation.

Cure Confirmation Letter
Dear [LANDLORD NAME], I received your 3-Day Notice to Cure or Quit dated [DATE] regarding [ALLEGED VIOLATION]. I have cured this violation as follows: [DESCRIBE WHAT YOU DID - e.g., "The unauthorized occupant has vacated the premises as of [DATE]" / "The pet has been permanently removed from the property" / "The noise issue has been addressed and will not recur"]. Attached please find [documentation - photos, receipt, written statement from departing occupant, etc.] confirming the cure. As the violation has been cured within the three-day period, this matter is now resolved. Please confirm receipt of this letter and acknowledge that no further action will be taken.
Dispute - No Violation Occurred
Dear [LANDLORD NAME], I received your notice dated [DATE] alleging that I [STATE ALLEGED VIOLATION]. I respectfully dispute this claim. [EXPLAIN WHY THE ALLEGATION IS FALSE - e.g., "The person seen at my unit is a regular guest, not an occupant. They do not reside here and have their own residence at [address]" / "I have not had any pet in the unit. The complaint may be based on a visitor's pet who was present briefly" / etc.] I have been a responsible tenant at [ADDRESS] for [X] years and have always complied with my lease obligations. I am happy to discuss this matter further or provide any additional information that would help clarify the situation. Please withdraw this notice as the alleged violation did not occur.
Dispute - Waiver/Prior Approval
Dear [LANDLORD NAME], I received your notice dated [DATE] regarding [ALLEGED VIOLATION]. I respectfully dispute this notice for the following reasons. You have been aware of this condition since [DATE/TIMEFRAME]. Specifically, [describe how landlord knew - "you inspected the unit on [date] and saw the pet" / "I informed you when [person] moved in" / etc.]. Since that time, you have continued to accept my rent payments without objection. Under California law, a landlord who knows of a lease violation and continues to accept rent waives the right to later enforce that provision. Your continued acceptance of rent with knowledge of this condition constitutes waiver. [If applicable: Additionally, you provided express or implied permission for this condition on [date] when you [describe].] For these reasons, I believe this notice is without legal basis and request that you withdraw it.
Response - Retaliation Claim
Dear [LANDLORD NAME], I received your notice dated [DATE] alleging [VIOLATION]. I believe this notice is retaliatory and therefore unlawful under California Civil Code Section 1942.5. On [DATE], I [complained about habitability issues / reported code violations to [agency] / requested repairs / organized with other tenants / exercised other protected rights]. Your notice was served within [X] days of this protected activity. Under California law, there is a rebuttable presumption that a notice served within 180 days of protected tenant activity is retaliatory. The timing of this notice, combined with [other evidence of retaliatory motive], strongly suggests retaliation. Retaliatory eviction is illegal and can result in the landlord being liable for actual damages, punitive damages, and attorney fees. I urge you to withdraw this notice. If you proceed with an unlawful detainer based on this notice, I will assert retaliation as an affirmative defense and seek all available remedies.

🚀 Next Steps

What to do after receiving a lease violation notice.

Step 1: Read Carefully

Identify exactly what violation is alleged, what lease provision it cites, and whether a cure period is offered.

Step 2: Check Your Lease

Review your lease to confirm the cited provision exists and applies to the alleged conduct.

Step 3: Gather Evidence

Collect photos, communications, and any evidence supporting your defense or showing cure.

Step 4: Respond in Writing

Whether curing or disputing, always respond in writing and keep copies of everything.

If You Cure the Violation

  • Document thoroughly - Photos, receipts, witness statements
  • Notify landlord in writing - Confirm the cure in writing
  • Keep proof of cure - May be needed if landlord disputes
  • Avoid repeat violations - A second similar violation may be "incurable"

If Landlord Files Eviction

  • File answer within 5 court days - Deadline is strict
  • Assert all defenses - Include cure, waiver, retaliation, etc.
  • Request jury trial - If desired, must be requested in writing
  • Seek legal help - Many areas have free tenant legal aid

Protect Your Housing

Lease violation notices can lead to eviction if not handled properly. Get professional help to evaluate your notice and prepare an effective response.

Schedule Consultation - $450

California Resources

  • CCP 1161: Unlawful detainer requirements including notice
  • Civil Code 1942.5: Retaliatory eviction protections
  • CA Courts Self-Help: selfhelp.courts.ca.gov - Free forms and information
  • Legal Aid: lawhelpca.org - Find free legal help in your area