Do I Need a Lawyer for an HOA Dispute?

Answer 6 quick questions to get personalized guidance for your California case

Question 1 of 6

What is the main issue with your HOA?

Threatening foreclosure or has filed a lien for unpaid assessments

Disputing assessments, fines, or special assessments

CC&R enforcement dispute (architectural, landscaping, pets, etc.)

Won't provide records or financial information I requested

Election violations or board governance issues

Discrimination or selective enforcement against me

Question 2 of 6

How much money is involved?

Over $10,000 (large special assessment or accumulated fines)

$5,000 - $10,000

$1,000 - $5,000

Under $1,000 or non-monetary dispute

Question 3 of 6

Have you already tried to resolve this through HOA processes?

Yes - completed IDR (Internal Dispute Resolution) and/or ADR (mediation)

Yes - completed IDR but haven't done mediation

I requested IDR/ADR but HOA hasn't responded

Haven't requested formal dispute resolution yet

Question 4 of 6

Is this a pattern of behavior or one-time issue?

Pattern - HOA consistently targets me or violates rules

Ongoing dispute that keeps escalating

Single incident or decision I'm challenging

Simple misunderstanding that might be easily resolved

Question 5 of 6

Do you believe the HOA violated California law (not just CC&Rs)?

Yes - violated Davis-Stirling Act requirements

Yes - Fair Housing Act discrimination

Yes - Open Meeting Act or election violations

Not sure - just disagree with their interpretation of CC&Rs

Question 6 of 6

What outcome are you seeking?

Stop foreclosure or immediate HOA action

Financial compensation for damages

Just want HOA to follow rules or reverse decision

Want access to records or information

✅

You Can Likely Handle This Yourself

Based on your answers, you can resolve this through HOA dispute resolution processes and demand letters.

Recommended DIY Steps:

Request IDR (Internal Dispute Resolution) - HOA must respond in 30 days
Send formal demand letter citing specific Davis-Stirling violations
Request all records in writing (HOA must provide within 10-30 days)
Attend board meetings and make your case in open session
Consider ADR (mediation) before litigation - often resolves disputes

📝 Create Demand Letter 🔗 HOA Records Request Template

⚖

You Should Consult an HOA Attorney

Your situation involves significant money, potential foreclosure, or legal violations that require professional help.

Why You Need an Attorney:

Foreclosure threats require immediate legal defense
Davis-Stirling violations may entitle you to attorney's fees
Discrimination claims have specific legal requirements
Pattern of harassment or selective enforcement is hard to prove alone
An attorney letter often prompts HOA to settle quickly

Book $125 Consultation 🕵 Find HOA Lawyer 📝 Create Demand Letter First

🤔

Try IDR/ADR First, Then Decide

Your case has merit but may be resolved through California's required dispute resolution processes.

Recommended Approach:

Send IDR request - HOA is required to participate
Document everything in writing
Request ADR (mediation) if IDR fails
get a consultation from an HOA attorney
If ADR fails, you've built a record for court

📝 Create Demand Letter 🕵 HOA Dispute Resources

Understanding HOA Disputes in California

California's Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act provides significant protections for homeowners in HOAs. Understanding your rights can help you resolve disputes without expensive litigation.

Types of HOA Disputes

Assessment Disputes: Challenging regular dues, special assessments, fines, or late fees
CC&R Enforcement: Disputes over architectural approvals, landscaping, pets, parking, rentals
Election Issues: Voting irregularities, candidate eligibility, recall procedures
Records Access: HOA refusing to provide financial records, meeting minutes, or membership lists
Maintenance Disputes: HOA failing to maintain common areas or boundaries
Discrimination: Selective enforcement, harassment, or Fair Housing violations

California Requires Dispute Resolution First!

Before you can sue your HOA in most cases, California Civil Code 5930-5965 requires:

IDR (Internal Dispute Resolution): Request in writing. HOA must respond within 30 days
ADR (Alternative Dispute Resolution): Mediation required for enforcement disputes
Failure to complete these can bar your lawsuit or affect attorney's fees

DIY vs. Hiring a Lawyer: Cost Comparison

Approach	Cost	Best For
IDR Request	Free	Required first step for most disputes
Demand Letter	Free (DIY)	Documenting violations, requesting compliance
ADR/Mediation	$200-500 per party	Most enforcement disputes
Small Claims Court	$75-100	Money disputes up to $12,500
HOA Attorney	$300-500/hour	Foreclosure, discrimination, complex cases

⚠ Facing Foreclosure? Act Immediately!

California allows HOAs to foreclose for unpaid assessments as low as $1,800:

You have 30 days to request IDR after lien notice
You may have 90 days from notice to pay and avoid foreclosure
An attorney can often negotiate a payment plan or challenge improper liens
Don't ignore foreclosure notices - you could lose your home

Your Rights Under Davis-Stirling

Records Access: HOA must provide most records within 10 days of request
Meeting Notice: Board meetings require 4-day notice; annual meeting requires 10-90 days
Open Meetings: Members can attend and address the board
Election Rules: Secret ballots, independent inspector, specific procedures
Fine Limits: Must follow disciplinary procedures before imposing fines
Assessment Limits: Special assessments over 5% of budget require member vote

When You Can Recover Attorney's Fees

Under California Civil Code 5975, the prevailing party in HOA enforcement actions can recover attorney's fees. This means:

If HOA sued you and you win, HOA pays your attorney
If you sue HOA for violations and win, HOA pays your attorney
This makes it feasible for attorneys to take smaller HOA cases
Both sides have risk, encouraging settlement

Related Resources

Quick Legal Tools

Free calculators to help with your case:

📅