📋 What is Competitor Defamation?

Competitor defamation occurs when a business rival makes false statements of fact about your company, products, or services to gain a competitive advantage. These attacks can devastate market share, damage customer relationships, and undermine years of brand-building effort.

Common Types of Competitor Attacks

Competitor defamation takes many forms, from direct false statements to subtle comparative advertising that crosses legal lines:

📣 False Product Claims

Claiming your products are defective, unsafe, or inferior when they are not

💰 Financial Misrepresentation

Falsely stating your company is failing, insolvent, or going out of business

👥 Customer Poaching

Telling your customers lies about your business to steal them away

⚠ Regulatory Falsehoods

Falsely claiming you lack licenses, certifications, or regulatory compliance

👍 Legal Remedies Available

  • Injunctive relief - Court order stopping ongoing false statements
  • Compensatory damages - Lost profits and market share recovery
  • Disgorgement - Competitor's ill-gotten profits from misconduct
  • Attorney fees - Available under Lanham Act for exceptional cases
  • Punitive damages - For malicious or willful misconduct (state claims)

State vs. Federal Claims

🇧 California State Law Claims

▼

California provides defamation claims (CC 44-48), trade libel, slander of title, and unfair competition claims (B&P Code 17200). State claims have a 1-year statute of limitations for defamation, but unfair competition claims have a 4-year SOL. State courts can award punitive damages for malicious conduct.

🇺 Federal Lanham Act Claims

▼

The Lanham Act Section 43(a) (15 U.S.C. 1125(a)) prohibits false or misleading representations about your own or another's goods/services. Federal court provides nationwide injunctions and the ability to recover the competitor's profits. The limitation period is generally 4 years under laches principles.

⚖ California UCL (B&P 17200)

▼

California's Unfair Competition Law allows claims for "unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent" business practices. This sweeping statute can capture competitor misconduct that might not fit neatly into defamation or Lanham Act claims. Remedies include injunctive relief and restitution.

⚠ Critical: Preserve Evidence Immediately

Competitors often delete false statements once they receive a demand letter. Before sending anything: screenshot all content, archive web pages, save email/marketing materials, and record dates of oral statements with witness information. Consider hiring a digital forensics expert for significant cases.

✅ Evidence Checklist

Gather these documents before sending your demand letter. Strong evidence is essential because competitors often deny making statements or claim they were truthful.

📄 False Statements

  • ✓ Screenshots of ads, websites, emails
  • ✓ Marketing materials (print and digital)
  • ✓ Trade show materials or presentations
  • ✓ Witness statements for oral statements

🔍 Proof of Falsity

  • ✓ Product testing or certification documents
  • ✓ Financial records (if solvency claimed)
  • ✓ Licenses and regulatory certifications
  • ✓ Expert opinions on product quality

💰 Damages Evidence

  • ✓ Lost customer communications/records
  • ✓ Sales data before and after statements
  • ✓ Market share analysis
  • ✓ Competitor's revenue from misconduct

👥 Competitor Information

  • ✓ Full legal entity name and address
  • ✓ Names of individuals making statements
  • ✓ Pattern of prior false statements

🔒 Lanham Act: Commercial Advertising Requirement

For Lanham Act claims, the false statement must be "commercial advertising or promotion." Document that the competitor's statements were disseminated widely enough to constitute advertising - trade show presentations, industry publications, mass emails, and websites typically qualify. Individual statements to specific customers may not.

💰 Calculate Your Damages

Competitor defamation can cause substantial quantifiable damages. Strong documentation supports larger settlements and verdicts.

Category Description
Lost Profits Revenue decline attributable to false statements, calculated using before/after analysis
Lost Customers Lifetime value of customers who switched to competitor due to false statements
Lost Market Share Value of market position lost due to reputational harm from false statements
Corrective Advertising Cost of advertising campaign to repair reputation and counter false claims
Defendant's Profits Under Lanham Act, can recover profits competitor earned from false advertising
Punitive Damages State law claims allow punitive damages for willful or malicious conduct

💰 Lanham Act Advantage: Defendant's Profits

Under the Lanham Act, you can recover the competitor's profits from false advertising, even if you cannot prove your exact losses. This disgorgement remedy can exceed your actual damages, especially when the competitor gained significant market share through deception.

📊 Sample Damages Calculation

Example: Competitor Claims Your Software Has Security Vulnerabilities

Lost enterprise contracts (4 x $75,000/year) $300,000
Market share decline (5% x $2M market) $100,000
Corrective advertising campaign $50,000
Third-party security audit (proof of falsity) $25,000
Competitor's profits from stolen customers $200,000
POTENTIAL TOTAL RECOVERY $675,000

💡 Proving Causation

You must prove the false statements caused your damages. Document customer communications mentioning the false claims, survey customers who left, and use expert testimony to analyze sales patterns. The competitor will argue other factors caused your losses - prepare evidence rebutting these defenses.

📝 Sample Language

Copy and customize these paragraphs for your competitor defamation demand letter.

Opening Paragraph
I am writing on behalf of [YOUR COMPANY NAME] regarding false and defamatory statements that [COMPETITOR NAME] has published about our company. Your client's conduct constitutes defamation, trade libel, and false advertising in violation of California law and the federal Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. Section 1125(a). We demand immediate cessation of this unlawful conduct and compensation for damages caused.
Identifying False Statements
[COMPETITOR NAME] has disseminated the following false statements: In [DESCRIBE MEDIUM: marketing emails, website, trade show presentations] dated [DATE(S)], your company stated that [QUOTE OR PARAPHRASE FALSE STATEMENT]. This statement is demonstrably false. [EXPLAIN WHY FALSE AND CITE EVIDENCE]. These statements constitute commercial advertising or promotion, were made with knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for truth, and have caused our clients significant competitive injury.
Lanham Act Violation
Your false statements violate Section 43(a) of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. 1125(a), which prohibits false or misleading representations of fact in commercial advertising about another's goods, services, or commercial activities. The statements were made in interstate commerce through [DESCRIBE: national advertising, internet marketing, interstate sales communications]. Under the Lanham Act, [YOUR COMPANY] is entitled to injunctive relief, actual damages, and recovery of [COMPETITOR NAME]'s profits attributable to this false advertising.
Damages Paragraph
As a direct result of [COMPETITOR NAME]'s false statements, [YOUR COMPANY] has suffered: lost sales of approximately $[AMOUNT]; loss of [NUMBER] customer accounts representing $[AMOUNT] in annual revenue; diminished market share; and harm to our business reputation that will take years to repair. We have also incurred $[AMOUNT] in corrective advertising and reputation management expenses. Under the Lanham Act, we are entitled to recover your client's profits from this false advertising, which we estimate at $[AMOUNT].
Demands for Action
We hereby demand that within [14] days of this letter, [COMPETITOR NAME]: (1) immediately cease and desist from all false statements about [YOUR COMPANY] and its products/services; (2) remove all false statements from websites, marketing materials, and any other media; (3) issue a written retraction and corrective statement to all recipients of the false advertising; (4) preserve all documents relating to the false statements and their dissemination; and (5) pay compensation of $[AMOUNT] for damages caused. Failure to comply will result in immediate commencement of litigation in federal court, where we will seek injunctive relief, treble damages, attorney fees, and all other remedies available under law.

🚀 Next Steps

Strategic next steps after sending your demand letter and preparing for potential litigation.

Immediate Actions

📌 Send via Certified Mail and Email

Send your demand letter via certified mail with return receipt requested to create a documented record. Also send via email to the competitor's legal department and CEO. This ensures receipt and creates urgency. Keep copies of all delivery confirmations.

If They Stop the False Statements

  1. Document the removal - Screenshot evidence that statements have been taken down
  2. Negotiate corrective advertising - Require them to issue corrections to their audience
  3. Settle damages claim - Removal doesn't eliminate your right to past damages
  4. Obtain written commitment - Get enforceable agreement to prevent future violations

If They Don't Respond or Refuse

Days 1-14

Wait for response. Continue documenting ongoing violations. Prepare litigation strategy.

Days 15-30

Engage litigation counsel. Evaluate federal vs. state court strategy. Prepare preliminary injunction motion.

Filing Lawsuit

File in federal court (Lanham Act) or state court. Immediately move for temporary restraining order if statements continue.

Discovery

Subpoena advertising records, customer communications, and internal emails showing knowledge of falsity.

💰 Federal Court Advantages

Filing Lanham Act claims in federal court provides several advantages: nationwide injunctions, potential recovery of defendant's profits without proving your losses, attorney fees in exceptional cases, and typically faster resolution than state court. Consider federal venue for significant cases.

Litigation Strategy Considerations

  1. TRO/Preliminary Injunction

    If false statements continue, immediately move for a temporary restraining order. Courts can order immediate removal of false advertising pending full trial.

  2. Discovery Focus

    Target internal communications showing knowledge of falsity, approval chains for advertising, and customer complaints they received about your products.

  3. Expert Witnesses

    Engage damages experts (forensic accountants), survey experts (consumer confusion), and industry experts (falsity of technical claims).

  4. Settlement Leverage

    Strong preliminary injunction motion often forces settlement. Document ongoing violations to maximize leverage.

Need Legal Help?

Competitor defamation cases require strategic coordination of federal and state claims. Get a 30-minute strategy call with a business litigation attorney.

Book Consultation - $125

California & Federal Resources

  • Federal Courts (Lanham Act): uscourts.gov - Find your local federal district court
  • California Courts: courts.ca.gov - State court filings and forms
  • FTC Complaint: reportfraud.ftc.gov - Report deceptive advertising practices
  • State Bar Lawyer Referral: calbar.ca.gov - Find a qualified attorney