🚚

Overview

When movers damage, lose, or steal your belongings during a California move, you have strong legal rights to recover compensation. I personally draft demand letters that enforce your claims under California PUC regulations and federal law.

Key Distinction: Different rules apply to intrastate moves (within California) versus interstate moves (crossing state lines). California intrastate moves are governed by Business & Professions Code 19225+ and PUC General Order 136-D. Interstate moves fall under the federal Carmack Amendment (49 USC 14706).

Common moving company problems I handle:

  • Damaged furniture and items: Scratches, dents, broken parts, water damage
  • Lost or missing items: Boxes that never arrive, belongings that disappear
  • Theft: Valuables, electronics, jewelry stolen by movers
  • Hostage goods: Movers demanding more money than quoted before unloading
  • Undisclosed charges: Hidden fees not in the original estimate
  • Failed delivery: Late delivery, delivery to wrong location, no-show
  • Improper packing: Inadequate protection leading to breakage
Critical - Sign BEFORE You Sign! NEVER sign the delivery receipt without noting all visible damage. Write "SUBJECT TO INSPECTION" and list any obvious damage. For hidden damage discovered later, report within 14 days. Signing "clear" may limit your recovery.
For Moving Companies: I also assist moving companies that have received demand letters from customers. Whether you are the shipper or carrier, I provide strategic guidance on resolving these disputes.
⚖

Legal Basis

Your rights depend on whether your move was intrastate or interstate:

California Business & Professions Code 19225+ (Intrastate) ▾

California law regulates household goods carriers for moves within the state:

  • Licensing Required: Movers must be registered with California PUC
  • Written Estimates: Required before the move begins
  • Maximum Charges: Cannot exceed estimate by more than 10% for non-binding
  • Valuation Disclosure: Must explain coverage options in writing
  • Inventory Requirements: Must provide itemized inventory at pickup
  • Claims Process: Must acknowledge claims within 30 days

Unlicensed movers face criminal penalties, and contracts may be voidable.

PUC General Order 136-D (Intrastate) ▾

The California Public Utilities Commission sets detailed requirements:

  • Pre-Move Survey: Must offer in-home estimate for moves over 25 miles
  • Bill of Lading: Required document showing shipment details
  • Valuation Options: Must explain released value vs. full value in plain language
  • Consumer Rights: Must provide Your Rights and Responsibilities booklet
  • Dispute Resolution: PUC has authority to mediate disputes

Failure to comply may entitle you to full value protection regardless of forms signed.

Carmack Amendment - 49 USC 14706 (Interstate) ▾

Federal law governs interstate household goods moves:

  • Carrier Liability: Carriers liable for actual loss or damage
  • Burden of Proof: Shipper must prove goods delivered in good condition, carrier received them, and damage occurred
  • Limited Defenses: Carrier can only escape liability for act of God, public enemy, shipper's fault, or inherent vice
  • Claim Timeline: 9 months to file claim; 30 days to acknowledge; 120 days to resolve
  • Preemption: Generally preempts state law claims (but not always)
49 CFR Part 375 - FMCSA Regulations (Interstate) ▾

Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration regulations require:

  • Written Estimates: Binding or non-binding, in writing
  • Valuation Disclosure: Must explain 60 cents/lb vs. full value options
  • Inventory Sheet: Detailed list at pickup noting condition
  • Bill of Lading: Contract of carriage with all terms
  • FMCSA Registration: Must have valid MC/DOT numbers

Violations can result in carrier fines and strengthen your claim.

Released Value vs. Full Value Protection ▾

Understanding your valuation coverage is critical:

Coverage Type Cost Protection
Released Value Free (default) 60 cents per pound per item
Full Value Protection Additional fee Repair, replace, or current value

Important: If the mover failed to properly explain these options before loading, you may be entitled to full value regardless of what you signed.

Claim Deadlines: Interstate: 9 months from delivery to file claim. Intrastate: Similar timeframes, check your contract. Hidden damage: Report within 14 days of discovery. Do not delay - missed deadlines can bar your entire claim.
📋

Evidence Checklist

I gather this evidence to build the strongest moving damage claim:

✔
Moving Contract and Estimate

Original written estimate (binding or non-binding), bill of lading, order for service

✔
Inventory Sheets

Pickup inventory with condition notes and delivery inventory with noted damage

✔
Valuation Selection Form

Document showing which coverage you selected (released value or full value)

✔
Photographs - Before and After

Photos of items before the move and all damage discovered at delivery

✔
Delivery Receipt with Notes

Signed receipt showing "SUBJECT TO INSPECTION" and listed damages

✔
Proof of Item Value

Purchase receipts, appraisals, replacement cost quotes for damaged items

✔
Repair Estimates

Written estimates from qualified repair shops for damaged furniture/items

✔
Communications

All emails, texts, and written correspondence with the moving company

💲

Calculate Damages

Your recovery depends on the valuation coverage you selected or should have been offered:

The "60 Cents Per Pound" Trap

65" Flat Screen TV (50 lbs) - Worth $1,500
Recovery at 60 cents/lb $30.00
Leather Sofa (150 lbs) - Worth $3,500
Recovery at 60 cents/lb $90.00
Antique Dresser (100 lbs) - Worth $5,000
Recovery at 60 cents/lb $60.00
Total Actual Loss $10,000
Total Released Value Recovery $180.00
Why This Matters: If the mover failed to properly explain valuation options before loading your goods, I argue you are entitled to full value protection regardless of what paperwork you signed.

Full Value Protection Recovery

65" Flat Screen TV - Replacement $1,500
Leather Sofa - Repair/Replace $3,500
Antique Dresser - Appraised Value $5,000
Total Full Value Recovery $10,000
Replacement Value ▾

For destroyed or lost items:

  • Current replacement cost for similar items
  • Appraised value for antiques, art, collectibles
  • Original purchase price minus depreciation (if no receipt)
  • Market value based on comparable sales
Repair Costs ▾

For repairable damage:

  • Professional repair estimates
  • Refinishing or restoration costs
  • If repair exceeds replacement, entitled to replacement
  • Diminished value even after repair (for valuable items)
Consequential Damages ▾

Additional recoverable costs:

  • Storage fees for delayed delivery
  • Hotel costs if delayed move-in
  • Rental costs for temporary replacement items
  • Lost wages from dealing with claims
  • Emotional distress (in extreme cases)
Hostage Goods Situations ▾

When movers hold goods for ransom:

  • Full value of goods held
  • Return of any excess charges paid under duress
  • Storage fees you incurred elsewhere
  • Statutory penalties for unlawful conduct
  • Potential criminal charges against mover
My Fee Structure: I handle moving damage claims at $450 flat fee for demand letters, $240/hr for negotiations and small claims assistance, or 33-40% contingency for larger claims (typically over $10,000). I assess the best structure based on your claim value.
📝

Sample Language

I use template language like this for moving damage demand letters:

Formal Damage Claim - Interstate Move
[Your Name] [Your Address] [City, State ZIP] [Email] [Date] VIA CERTIFIED MAIL - RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED [Moving Company Name] Claims Department [Address] [City, State ZIP] Re: Formal Claim for Loss and Damage to Household Goods Bill of Lading #: [Number] Move Date: [Date] Origin: [Address] Destination: [Address] Dear Claims Department: NOTICE OF CLAIM PURSUANT TO 49 USC 14706 This letter constitutes formal notice of claim for loss and damage to my household goods pursuant to the Carmack Amendment (49 USC 14706) and 49 CFR Part 370. DAMAGED/LOST ITEMS The following items were damaged, lost, or destroyed during your handling: 1. [Item Description] - Condition at pickup: [Good condition/no damage noted on inventory] - Condition at delivery: [Describe damage] - Weight: [X] lbs - Replacement value: $[Amount] 2. [Item Description] - Condition at pickup: [Condition] - Condition at delivery: [Describe damage] - Weight: [X] lbs - Repair estimate: $[Amount] 3. [Item Description - if lost] - Listed on pickup inventory: Yes, Item #[Number] - Not present at delivery - Replacement value: $[Amount] TOTAL CLAIM: $[Total Amount] Photographs documenting all damage are enclosed. VALUATION CHALLENGE Your company failed to provide the required valuation disclosure as mandated by 49 CFR 375.303. Specifically, [describe failure - e.g., "no written explanation of valuation options was provided before loading began" OR "the valuation selection form was presented after goods were already on the truck"]. As a result, I reject the 60 cents per pound limitation and demand full value compensation for all damaged and lost items. LEGAL REQUIREMENTS Under 49 CFR 370.5, you are required to: - Acknowledge this claim in writing within 30 days - Pay, deny, or make a settlement offer within 120 days Failure to comply subjects your company to FMCSA enforcement action and strengthens any subsequent litigation. DEMAND I demand payment of $[Total Amount] representing full value compensation for all damaged and lost items. If I do not receive satisfactory resolution within 120 days, I will: 1. File a complaint with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration 2. File suit in [appropriate court] 3. Seek attorney's fees and all additional damages available under law Sincerely, [Your Name] Enclosures: - Photographs of damage - Copy of Bill of Lading - Copy of Inventory Sheet - Repair estimates/replacement quotes
California Intrastate Move Claim
[Your Name] [Your Address] [Date] VIA CERTIFIED MAIL [Moving Company Name] [Address] Re: Claim for Damaged Goods - California Intrastate Move Date of Move: [Date] PUC-T Number: [If known] Dear [Moving Company]: DEMAND FOR COMPENSATION UNDER CALIFORNIA LAW This letter constitutes formal claim for damage to my household goods during your handling of my move from [Origin City] to [Destination City] on [Date]. REGULATORY VIOLATIONS Your company violated California Business & Professions Code Section 19225 et seq. and PUC General Order 136-D by: 1. [Failing to provide written estimate before move] 2. [Failing to properly explain valuation options] 3. [Charging amounts exceeding estimate by more than 10%] 4. [Failing to provide inventory at pickup] 5. [Other violations] DAMAGES CLAIMED Item 1: [Description] - Damage: [Description] - Value/Repair Cost: $[Amount] Item 2: [Description] - Damage: [Description] - Value/Repair Cost: $[Amount] [Continue listing] TOTAL DAMAGES: $[Amount] FULL VALUE ENTITLEMENT Due to your failure to properly explain and offer valuation coverage as required by PUC General Order 136-D, I am entitled to full value compensation regardless of any released value limitation. DEMAND I demand payment of $[Amount] within thirty (30) days. If payment is not received, I will: 1. File a complaint with the California Public Utilities Commission 2. File suit in California Small Claims Court [or Superior Court] 3. Report your company to the California Attorney General 4. Pursue all available statutory penalties Please note that operating as an unlicensed mover or violating PUC regulations can result in criminal penalties under Business & Professions Code Section 19254. Sincerely, [Your Name]
Hostage Goods Emergency Demand
[Your Name] [Your Address] [Date] VIA EMAIL AND CERTIFIED MAIL [Moving Company Name] [Address] Re: URGENT - Unlawful Holding of Household Goods Original Estimate: $[Amount] Amount Demanded: $[Higher Amount] To Whom It May Concern: DEMAND FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE OF GOODS Your company is currently holding my household goods hostage in violation of federal and California law. You are demanding $[Amount Demanded] before delivery, despite providing a [binding/non-binding] estimate of only $[Original Amount]. LEGAL VIOLATIONS Your conduct violates: 1. 49 USC 14706 - Unlawful refusal to deliver 2. 49 CFR 375.403 - Exceeding estimate limits 3. California Business & Professions Code 19231 - Household goods carrier violations 4. California Penal Code 518 - Extortion Under federal law, for non-binding estimates you may only collect the estimate plus 10% at delivery. Any additional charges must be billed within 30 days and I have 30 days to pay. IMMEDIATE DEMAND I demand that you: 1. IMMEDIATELY deliver all my household goods to [Delivery Address] 2. Accept payment of $[Original Estimate + 10%] at delivery 3. Provide itemized bill for any claimed additional charges CONSEQUENCES If my goods are not delivered within 24 hours, I will: 1. Contact local police to report theft/extortion 2. File emergency complaint with California PUC 3. File complaint with FMCSA 4. File suit seeking full value of all goods plus punitive damages 5. Report to California Attorney General The total value of goods you are holding exceeds $[Value]. Continued refusal to deliver constitutes conversion and may result in criminal prosecution. CONTACT ME IMMEDIATELY at [Email] to arrange delivery. [Your Name] cc: California Public Utilities Commission FMCSA Safety Hotline [Local Police Department]
✎

Next Steps

When dealing with moving company damage, I recommend these steps:

1. Document Everything at Delivery ▾

Before signing anything:

  • Write "SUBJECT TO INSPECTION" on delivery receipt
  • Note all visible damage on the receipt
  • Take photos/video of all damage immediately
  • Compare delivery inventory to pickup inventory
  • Do NOT let driver rush you - take your time
2. Report Hidden Damage Immediately ▾

For damage discovered after unpacking:

  • Report within 14 days of discovery (sooner is better)
  • Send written notice via email AND certified mail
  • Photograph items before moving them further
  • Keep all packing materials as evidence
3. File Formal Written Claim ▾

Submit a proper claim within 9 months:

  • Send via certified mail with return receipt
  • Include itemized list with values and weights
  • Attach all photographs
  • Include repair estimates or replacement quotes
  • Request acknowledgment within 30 days
4. File Regulatory Complaints ▾

Report to appropriate agencies:

  • Interstate: FMCSA at 1-888-DOT-SAFT or nccdb.fmcsa.dot.gov
  • Intrastate: California PUC Consumer Affairs
  • Both: California Attorney General Consumer Protection
  • BBB: File complaint for public record
5. Pursue Legal Action ▾

If the mover denies or ignores your claim:

  • Small Claims Court: Up to $12,500 in California
  • Superior Court: Larger claims, attorney fees possible
  • Federal Court: Interstate Carmack claims over $75,000
  • File in county where move ended or mover has office
Time Is Critical: The 9-month claim deadline is strictly enforced. Hidden damage must be reported within 14 days. Do not delay - every day you wait weakens your claim.

Movers Damaged Your Belongings?

I personally draft demand letters for California moving damage claims. Get the compensation you deserve.

Email Me