Payment Plan Proposal Demand Letters
📅 Payment Plan Proposal Demand Letters
Structuring Realistic Debt Repayment Plans
⚖️ How Payment Plans Work
A payment plan allows a debtor to pay a debt over time in installments rather than in a lump sum. Both debtors and creditors can propose payment plans.
Why Payment Plans Are Used
- Debtor lacks lump sum: Can afford monthly payments but not full balance
- Creditor prefers full payment: Willing to wait if it means collecting 100% vs. settling for less
- Avoid bankruptcy: Payment plan keeps debtor out of bankruptcy, preserving creditor’s recovery
- Stop collection activity: Creditor agrees to halt lawsuits/garnishment during payment period
- Preserve relationship: Business relationships can continue while debt is repaid
Payment Plan vs. Settlement
| Factor | Payment Plan | Lump Sum Settlement |
|---|---|---|
| Total amount paid | Usually full balance + interest | Reduced amount (30-70% of balance) |
| Time to resolve | Months or years | Immediate upon payment |
| Cash needed | Monthly amount; spread over time | Full settlement amount upfront |
| Credit impact | May improve as payments made; “pays as agreed” possible | “Settled for less”; negative mark |
| Risk of default | High: debtor may miss future payments | Low: one-time payment resolves debt |
Key Terms in Payment Plans
- Monthly payment amount: Fixed dollar amount per month
- Duration: Number of months (e.g., 12, 24, 36 months)
- Interest rate: Whether interest continues to accrue during plan
- Start date: When first payment is due
- Automatic payment: ACH debit vs. manual payments
- Default provisions: What happens if debtor misses a payment
- Collection freeze: Creditor agrees not to sue or report during compliance
💰 Proposing a Payment Plan as a Debtor
When to Propose a Payment Plan
- You have stable income but no lump sum savings
- Creditor has threatened lawsuit or garnishment
- You want to pay in full but need time
- Debt is valid and you don’t dispute it
- You’re trying to avoid bankruptcy
Calculating What You Can Afford
Step 1: Create a budget
- Monthly income (after taxes): $______
- Essential expenses (rent, food, utilities, transportation): $______
- Minimum payments on other debts: $______
- Discretionary funds available for this debt: $______
Step 2: Determine realistic payment
- Don’t offer more than you can truly afford month after month
- Leave buffer for emergencies
- Consider whether this is your only debt or one of many
Don’t Overcommit: Offering $500/month when you can only afford $200 will result in default, lawsuit, and worse terms. Be honest about what you can pay consistently.
What to Request from Creditor
- Freeze or reduce interest: Request 0% or reduced rate during payment plan
- Waive late fees: Ask creditor to remove accumulated late charges
- Stop collection activity: No lawsuits, garnishments, or harassing calls while plan is current
- Credit reporting: Request “pays as agreed” or at least no new negative marks while compliant
- Written agreement: Get all terms in writing before making first payment
Structuring Your Proposal
Option A: Full balance over time
- Balance: $10,000
- Propose: $200/month for 50 months (100% repayment)
- Request: 0% interest during plan
Option B: Partial settlement via payment plan
- Balance: $10,000
- Propose: $150/month for 36 months = $5,400 total (54% repayment)
- Request: Creditor forgives remaining $4,600 upon completion
🏢 Creditor-Side: Offering Payment Plans
When to Offer a Payment Plan
- Debtor has income but lacks lump sum
- Debtor is responsive and cooperative
- Debt is large enough that settlement would be too low
- Preserving customer relationship has value
- Litigation costs would exceed likely recovery
Protective Terms for Creditors
- Promissory note or installment agreement: Formalizes the payment plan as enforceable contract
- Personal guarantee: If debtor is a business, require owner’s personal guarantee
- Security interest: Take collateral to secure the payment plan
- Automatic payment: Require ACH authorization to reduce missed payments
- Acceleration clause: If debtor misses X payments, entire balance becomes due immediately
- Attorney fee provision: Debtor pays your attorney fees if you have to sue for breach
- Confession of judgment: Pre-signed judgment (allowed in some states)
- No discharge without completion: Debt not forgiven until all payments made
Interest Rate Considerations
| Interest Option | When to Use |
|---|---|
| 0% interest | Short-term plan (6-12 months); incentive to keep debtor paying |
| Reduced interest | Long-term plan; lower than original rate but covers time value of money |
| Contract rate | Continue original interest rate from contract |
| Late payment penalty | Add penalty rate if payment is late (e.g., 5% late fee per missed payment) |
Default Provisions
Your payment plan agreement should specify what happens if debtor defaults:
“If Debtor misses two consecutive monthly payments, Creditor may declare this agreement in default, accelerate the remaining balance, and pursue all legal remedies including filing suit for the unpaid balance plus interest, late fees, and attorney fees.”
📄 Sample Payment Plan Letters
Sample 1: Debtor Proposes Payment Plan
[Your Name]
[Your Address]
[Date]
[Creditor/Collector Name]
[Address]
Re: Payment Plan Proposal
Account #[Number]
To Whom It May Concern:
I am writing to propose a payment plan to resolve the above-referenced account.
CURRENT SITUATION:
I acknowledge that I owe $[amount] on this account. I am unable to pay the full balance immediately due to [brief explanation: job loss, medical emergency, etc.]. However, I have stable income and am committed to repaying this debt.
PAYMENT PLAN PROPOSAL:
Monthly Payment: $[amount]
Start Date: [Date – usually first of next month]
Duration: [X] months
Total Amount to be Paid: $[amount]
This plan will pay the debt in full over [X] months.
REQUESTED TERMS:
1. Interest: I request that interest be frozen at 0% during this payment plan
2. Late Fees: I request that all late fees and penalties be waived
3. Collection Activity: While I am current on this payment plan, no further collection activity (lawsuits, garnishment, collection calls)
4. Credit Reporting: Report this account as “pays as agreed” or “current” while payments are timely
5. Written Agreement: Provide written confirmation of these terms before I make the first payment
PAYMENT METHOD:
I will make payments via [ACH/check/online payment] on the [1st/15th] of each month.
I am committed to honoring this payment plan. Please respond in writing by [date] if you accept this proposal.
Sincerely,
[Your Signature]
[Your Name]
[Phone]
[Email]
Sample 2: Creditor Offers Payment Plan
[Creditor Letterhead]
[Date]
[Debtor Name]
[Address]
Re: Payment Plan Offer
Account #[Number]
Balance Due: $[Amount]
Dear [Debtor Name]:
We understand you are experiencing financial difficulty. To assist you in resolving this account, we are offering the following payment plan.
PAYMENT PLAN TERMS:
Account Balance: $[amount]
Monthly Payment: $[amount]
Number of Payments: [X] months
First Payment Due: [Date]
Interest Rate: [X]% per annum (or 0% if goodwill offer)
Total amount to be paid: $[amount including any interest]
PAYMENT METHOD:
Payments will be automatically debited from your bank account via ACH on the [date] of each month. Please complete the enclosed ACH authorization form.
AGREEMENT CONDITIONS:
1. First Payment: Your first payment of $[amount] is due by [date] to activate this agreement.
2. Timely Payments Required: All subsequent payments must be made on time. If you miss two consecutive payments, this agreement will terminate and the entire remaining balance will become immediately due.
3. Collection Activity Suspended: While you remain current on this payment plan, we will not initiate legal action. However, if you default, we reserve the right to file suit for the full balance plus interest, late fees, and attorney fees.
4. Credit Reporting: We will report your payment activity to credit bureaus. Timely payments will be reported as “pays as agreed.”
5. No Waiver of Rights: This payment plan does not waive any of our rights or remedies under the original agreement or applicable law.
ACCEPTANCE:
To accept this offer, sign and return the enclosed agreement along with your first payment and ACH authorization by [date – 15 days].
If we do not receive your acceptance by that date, this offer is withdrawn and we will pursue other collection remedies.
We hope this payment plan will help you resolve this obligation.
Sincerely,
[Signature]
[Name]
[Title]
Enclosures: Payment Plan Agreement, ACH Authorization Form
⚠️ Legal Risks and Considerations
Statute of Limitations Risk (Debtors)
Making partial payments on a debt can restart the statute of limitations in many states.
SOL Restart Risk:
- If debt is close to statute of limitations expiration, entering a payment plan may restart the clock
- Once restarted, creditor has a fresh SOL period to sue you
- In some states, ANY payment restarts SOL; in others, only a written promise to pay does
- Check your state’s law before proposing a payment plan on old debt
Default Consequences
If you miss payments under a payment plan:
- Creditor may accelerate and demand full balance immediately
- Any waived interest or fees may be reinstated
- Creditor can sue for full balance plus penalties
- Prior payments don’t protect you—they may just reduce the balance creditor sues for
Credit Reporting
How payment plans appear on credit reports:
- If you’re current on the plan: May show as “pays as agreed” or “current”
- If you default on the plan: Will show as delinquent
- Original delinquency still shows: The initial missed payments that led to collections still appear
- Completion of plan: Some creditors report “paid in full” upon completion
Tax Consequences (Partial Forgiveness Plans)
If your payment plan includes forgiveness of part of the debt upon completion:
- Example: Owe $10,000, pay $6,000 over 36 months, creditor forgives remaining $4,000
- The $4,000 forgiven is cancellation of debt (COD) income
- You’ll receive Form 1099-C and must report it (subject to insolvency exception)
Written Agreement is Essential
Never Start Payments Without Written Agreement:
- Verbal promises from collectors are not binding
- Without written terms, creditor can still sue despite your payments
- Demand written confirmation of interest freeze, late fee waiver, and collection suspension
- If creditor won’t provide written agreement, reconsider the payment plan
💼 How I Help with Payment Plan Negotiations
I help both debtors propose realistic payment plans and creditors structure enforceable plans that maximize recovery.
For Debtors:
- Analyze budget to determine affordable payment
- Negotiate favorable terms (0% interest, fee waivers)
- Draft payment plan proposal letters
- Review creditor’s proposed plan for unfair terms
- Defend against lawsuits while negotiating plan
For Creditors:
- Draft enforceable payment plan agreements
- Include protective provisions (acceleration, attorney fees, security)
- Structure plans to maximize collection while minimizing defaults
- Enforce defaulted plans through litigation
- Balance payment plans vs. litigation economics
Structure a Sustainable Payment Plan
Whether you’re a debtor seeking relief or a creditor maximizing recovery, I can help negotiate fair and enforceable payment terms.
Email owner@terms.law
Schedule a Call
Book a call to discuss your payment plan matter.