Landlord Keeping $3,800 Security Deposit for “Normal Wear and Tear” in California

I publish illustrative scenarios prepared by my practice. All participants and conversations are fictional. The fictional posts are not posts by real users, accounts of client experiences, or reports of actual results.
Illustrative scenario prepared by my practice.
For informational purposes only. This is not legal advice.
Hypothetical question

Lived in an apartment in San Diego for 5 years. Paid $3,800 security deposit. Left the place clean, did a walk-through with the property manager who said "looks good." Now I got an itemized deduction list: $1,200 for "carpet replacement," $800 for "repainting," $600 for "deep cleaning," and $1,200 for "appliance wear." They're keeping the entire deposit.

After 5 years, isn't carpet and paint normal wear and tear?? The apartment was in better condition than when I moved in.

Illustrative response

Document everything with move-in and move-out photos if you have them. The walk-through where the property manager said "looks good" is great evidence. Did you record it or get it in writing?

Illustrative response

Small claims court update: filed my case, hearing is in 6 weeks. The filing fee was only $75 and I don't need a lawyer. The court clerk was actually very helpful in explaining the process. If your claim is under $10K (or $12.5K in some states), small claims is the way to go.