Private members-only forum

Got hit with $2,800 in estimated tax penalties - first year making decent money freelancing

Started by carlos_r_5 · Sep 18, 2025 · 9 replies
For informational purposes only. Tax situations are individual and require professional advice.
CR
carlos_r_5 OP

I just got my 2024 taxes done and I owe $2,800 in estimated tax penalties on top of my regular tax bill. I'm shocked and kind of panicking.

Background: I was a W-2 employee making $50K until July 2024. Then I went full-time freelance and made $85K in just 6 months (Aug-Dec). Total income for 2024 was $135K.

I paid my full tax bill when I filed in February, but the IRS is penalizing me because I didn't make quarterly estimated payments. Nobody told me I had to do that!

Is there any way to get this penalty waived? This seems really unfair for a first-time freelancer.

CR
carlos_r_5 OP

Wait, so if I had just paid 100% of my 2023 tax throughout 2024, I wouldn't have any penalty? Even though my 2024 income was way higher?

My 2023 tax was only like $4,000 because I was making $50K all year. My 2024 tax is $28,000.

DP
discovery_phase_14

First-time abatement is your best bet. It's administrative relief and the IRS grants it pretty readily if you qualify.

To request it:

  • Call the IRS at 1-800-829-1040
  • Tell them you want to request first-time penalty abatement for estimated tax penalties
  • They'll verify you have a clean compliance history
  • If approved, they waive the penalty immediately

You can also write a letter, but calling is faster. I've had clients get this approved in a 10-minute phone call.

OY
objection_your_honor_5

Also, for 2025, make sure you start making quarterly payments! Don't get hit with this again.

A good rule of thumb: set aside 30-35% of every payment you receive for taxes. Put it in a separate savings account and don't touch it.

Then make estimated payments each quarter. You can do it online at IRS.gov/payments.

DG
daniel_g_14 Attorney

One more thing - you should also run the annualized income calculation even if you get first-time abatement. Here's why:

Since you only went full-time freelance in August, your income was heavily weighted to the second half of the year. The annualized method calculates what you owed each quarter based on actual income to that point, not evenly spreading your annual liability.

This could reduce your penalty from $2,800 to maybe $800-1,200. Then first-time abatement wipes out whatever remains.

Form 2210 Schedule AI is complicated. Consider having a CPA run the calculation - it'll cost you $200-300 but could save you $1,500+.

LE
legal_eagle_wannabe_11

Pro tip: If you're married, you can also adjust your spouse's W-2 withholding to cover your estimated taxes. Withholding is treated as paid evenly throughout the year (even if it all comes out in December), so you avoid the quarterly payment headache.

My wife increased her W-4 withholding to cover my self-employment tax. Way easier than making quarterly payments.

TD
TransactionalLaw_Dan_5

This thread is so helpful - I'm in almost the exact same boat right now. Went full-time freelance in July 2025 and just realized I haven't made any estimated tax payments. I've made about $62K since July and I'm terrified of getting hit with penalties when I file in April.

One question: if I make a huge Q4 estimated payment in January (before the Jan 15 deadline), does that help reduce the penalty? Or is the penalty already locked in based on when I should have paid throughout the year?

Also planning to use first-time penalty abatement like OP did, but want to minimize the penalty amount first if possible.

DG
daniel_g_14 Attorney

@TransactionalLaw_Dan_5 - Good question. Yes, making a large Q4 payment helps. The penalty is calculated quarter by quarter based on when income was earned. Since you started in July, you had no income Q1-Q2 so no penalty for those periods anyway.

Make your Q4 payment by January 15th deadline and you'll only have penalties for Q3 (Sept 15 deadline) on the income you earned July-August. The annualized income method will reduce this further since most of your income was earned Q4.

For 2025, set up quarterly payments from day one. IRS Direct Pay lets you schedule them in advance so you don't forget fr fr.

TP
the_peoples_lawyer_8

Been freelancing for 5 years and the best thing I ever did was open a separate high-yield savings account just for taxes. Every time I get paid, 30% goes straight into that account automatically.

When quarterly payments are due, the money is just sitting there waiting. No stress, no scrambling. Plus I earn a little interest on it while I wait. Its like paying myself to save for taxes lol

GH
grace_h_7

Piggybacking on this thread - don't forget about state estimated taxes too! I was so focused on the IRS payments that I completely forgot California also requires quarterly estimates. Got hit with a state penalty on top of the federal one my first year.

The quarterly deadlines are the same as federal (mostly) but you have to make seperate payments to the Franchise Tax Board. Fun times.