Private members-only forum

CPA/Accountant Liability: financial advisor churning account

Started by daveP_22 · Sep 20, 2023 · 542 views · 0 replies
For informational purposes only. This is not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction. Consult a qualified attorney for advice specific to your situation.
DA
daveP_22 OP

EDIT: added more context below. I'm dealing with a situation and need some guidance.

financial advisor churning account. I've been dealing with this for about 9 weeks now and the situation isn't improving.

I have already tried to resolve this directly but did not get a clear answer.

What are my legal options here? Is it worth pursuing?

JA
just_a_lurker_99_12

Churning is one of the most well-established securities violations. You likely have claims through FINRA arbitration (mandatory for most brokerage disputes):

Key metrics: Courts and FINRA panels look at (1) turnover ratio (number of times the portfolio was turned over — above 6x annually is presumptive churning), (2) cost-to-equity ratio (annualized costs as a percentage of account equity — above 20% is excessive), and (3) whether trades were suitable for your stated objectives.

For a conservative retirement account with 200+ trades, your case is strong. The advisor also likely violated their suitability obligations (FINRA Rule 2111) and fiduciary duty if they had discretion over the account smh.

Damages: The typical recovery is the difference between your actual account performance and what a properly managed conservative portfolio would have earned (a "well-managed account" analysis). Plus commissions generated by excessive trading.

FINRA arbitration is faster than court (typically 12-16 months). Securities attorneys usually work on contingency (25-33%). Your brokerage firm is jointly liable for the advisor's misconduct under respondeat superior.